Jump to content

hsingh8963

Members
  • Posts

    762
  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    12

Everything posted by hsingh8963

  1. Chaos erupted inside Turlock Gurdwara Sahib in California after a Taksali Singh asked Prof Sarbjit Singh Dhunda a question on Dasam Granth. The question revolved around the maryada of Akal Takht Sahib on Dasam Granth and whether parcharaks are allowed to protest against it. After the question was asked a person with Sarbjit Singh Dhunda somehow felt offended and walked out of the Gurdwara. Sikh sangat became upset on why the question wasn’t fully answered and the urge to leave. Some members of the sangat felt Prof Dhunda was corned on the topic while some said he avoided the questions. SIKH24 OP/ED Do you believe that Professor Sahib Singh’s teeka is the best ever written on Guru Granth Sahib Ji Dhunda: Yes Do you believe that everything written in Guru Granth Sahib Ji is true or not? After some thought, Dhunda answers yes. Do you believe in 8.4 million lives and if there is a life after death or if the soul continues its journey? Dhunda is not able to answer this because he believes there is nothing after life and God has only created us to be better human beings. Dhunda’s explanations are then questioned by references from various shabads in Guru Granth Sahib. Over and over, it is mentioned that there is an after life and what we do, we will have to repent. After this was the biggest question - Do you believe in the super natural concepts mentioned in Guru Granth Sahib Ji? And do you believe that these were just written or those events actually took place? Dhunda answers, however he tries to be smart. He questions that how can a fish go in the air and how can a cow be back alive after it was dead? Responding to Dhunda’s questions, Singhs mention that Professor Sahib Singh and other scholars have all said and interpreted those gurbani verses in the way that those incidents have occurred just how they have been written. S. Kulwant Singh states that if God wants, anything is possible. So if that means the cow was alive again according to Gurbani, then it was, because God made that happen to show and honor the protection of his devotees. After this, Bhai Amarbir Singh from Manteca asked the following question - Does any Sikh parcharak have the right, according to Akal Takht Sahib to openly condemn Sri Dasam Granth? Dhunda asks that the Singhs provide him proof where he has gone against Akal Takht Sahib. Amarbir Singh mentioned that Dhunda has done so many times and there are many recordings. However, during the debate, Dhunda then cleverly changes topic and Balraj Singh, Dhunda’s main sponsor from Patterson gets up and says this was not part of the debate today. Singhs however stated that we are not asking if Sri Dasam Granth is right or wrong, it is only asked if according to our Akal Takht Maryada, is it right to condemn Dasam Granth. After this, Dhunda and his supporters get up try to leave the debate. However, Singhs pose the next question - Do you believe that doing Waheguru Simran is a waste of time and if that had any meaning for the after life. In response, Dhunda pauses for a moment, and then finally answers that Simran is only for us to get a peace of mind here in this world and that he doesn’t know if it has any meaning after since he has not died yet. Singhs insist that over and over, Guru Granth Sahib Ji answers this there is a meaning and without the recitation of God, no one will find the door of liberation at the God’s court, unless God chooses otherwise. So that being, what right does Dhunda have to say Waheguru Simran is pretty much a waste of time? Conclusion These were the basic questions Dhunda could not answer because he does not believe in these concepts. While is it is of utmost important to live a perfect life, it is important to also live life in a way as prescribed by the Gurus, ie. by recitation and understanding of Gurbani and by doing naam simran, keeping rehit, etc. If after life was not important, then why wear a dastar, keep a beard, keep rehit, take amrit?
  2. https://www.facebook.com/AkaliJathaShaheedan/videos/907852932589230/?pnref=story Video
  3. There is a video I will upload soon.... The way they dealt with it is good. Now these people will be more inclined to become Gursikhi
  4. Honestly don't worry about it man. Just focus on sass grass Simran. People are always going to look for something to latch onto and talk about meaninglessly If you tie a dumalla they will start calling you a Nihang lol... Don't worry about it man....
  5. I like how they handled the situation... Now these people may be more inclined to embrace sikhi.
  6. Those responsible have to beg for forgiveness at the young boys feet. Thanks to the jatha!!! Akaal!!!!!!!!
  7. Cool cool probably listen to fardikot teeka then sant Baba gurbachan singh ji bhindranwales
  8. Cool how yall all feel about professor sahib Singhs?
  9. What is the most accurate teeka of Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji in your opinion?
  10. Akalifauja what is your opinion on this...... In pretty sure from what I have read is that we have basically the same thoughts on this...
  11. Where can I buy a longer Kachera (Kachera for Chola) Online??
  12. Look at the Pages of Kaglidar Chamatkar (Google Kalgidar Chamatkar its available in Punjabi and English).... All these things are explained.... No one is saying Jesus was right... All I am saying is do not do nindya of other faiths and we all know Gursikhi is the true path. Your post listed flaws in the religion which we all understand.... Look at the pages...
  13. What I was talking about is on Ang 19 the other meditators were talking about the glimpses of saints he had like Budha, Jesus, and Muhammad, Budha, Gorak talking about how Guru Ji would go to help save the world.
  14. Im going with Singh123456777 on this one... Jesus and all other saints that came are not to be attacked.... Guru Maharaj Is The Avatar That has come in this Dark Age and we all understand this. Jesus Muhammad Budha all told the other devotees at Hemkunt Sahib that Dusht Daman Was the true Guru that would come to the dark of Kalyug... So yea I guess you could say they all came to the charan of Guru Ji, or "approved".... Kalgidar CHAMATKAR PAGE 19 and onwards
  15. Let's all comment advice here.. Then comment the link of this thread on the other site. This is his post. I hate you God I hate u i know that the title of my question will be annoying to you but after facing numerous problems in my life, i have to say that i hate you god. he knows everything but he is still not helping me, he is just watching at me laughing. so that's why i have decided not to follow your path. my mom was wrong who was teaching me that try your best and rest leave to god because now i have finally concluded that there is no god, and by mistake if there is any thing in this world like god then i can respectfully say that that thing always favors and help the bad people. that thing named god always mug the innocent people and make them to suffer a lot. the rich is becoming more richer day by day and poor people like me are loosing money everyday and are becoming more poorer day by day. i am soo sorry but i am writing all this because now i am fed up from my life. i don't want to live anymore now. even after praying a lot, doing ardaas, paath, listening kirtans and doing good karmas what i am getting is only failure everywhere. i even cry everyday in front of babaji to sort out my problems which i have been facing from last two years and please bless me but the result and the response i am getting is only a zero. its been more than an year for me living in New Zealand and still i can say that i am useless with no job. people are earning a lot of money everyday, their bank accounts are very heavy. they have paid back their student loans. they are living a luxurious life and they are all happy. even the students including girls who came this year have earned more money than me. the girl whom i liked said to me that u r useless, u have spent one year and u earn only $250 a week. boy who came here last week has started earning $1000 a week. everyone have got good jobs because their family members have helped them a lot and the most strange thing about these rich guys are that all of them have cut down their hair. they visit gurudwara but don't maintain their kesh. no one helped me here. i was alone, i struggled a lot but still i am a loser. i have no money left in my bank a/c now. my student loan amount is increasing day by day. the world is earning money everyday but my <banned word filter activated> life sucks me. i don't know whether i would be able to complete my degree or not ? whether i would be able to pay my rent and other expenses, whether i would be able to live in this world or not ? i have just became a burden on my parents and i have decided that i will suicide if my this <banned word filter activated> continues. i don't know why should i believe in god now. i have decided that i will cut my hair and i will tear all my turbans, i will shave my beard and i will not follow the path of guru now because even after doing a lot of bhakti, the god is favoring the cuttings then why should i be a fool to remain a useless man. sorry, i know my words will be very harsh to you but honestly god is not helping me even after practicing gurbani and now i am fed up from my life...
  16. What is that Tuk from Bani? or Rehat Maraydas that talks about the importance of saying fateh? Or like when two Sikhs meet they should say fateh? Could somebody please provide it?
  17. Make an account my friend IF YOU EVER EVER EVER NEED ANYTHING post one this site. Also please view this amazing divan!! And this amazing katha I'm sure it will make you feel better http://m.youtube.com/watch?v=RmjzNT-styA http://m.youtube.com/watch?v=7O84bHZ4mZk http://m.youtube.com/watch?v=MiPN9p1r7e0
  18. http://lifehacker.com/my-never-ending-search-for-comfortable-in-ear-headphone-1679696172 Check this out..... also Check out AirBuds
  19. Akal Warrior Ji. I already said... If you support the film there is another thread that you made. Again I will say the Producer said that... You know what NeverMind. I'm not looking for a fight. Please stick to the other thread.
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

Terms of Use