Jump to content

Arsh1469

Members
  • Posts

    415
  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    16

Everything posted by Arsh1469

  1. Ok I will help by getting 2 wives and having 100s mistresses and forcing my kids to be Sikh. Guess I've done my part.
  2. Listen to SGGS academy they do good katha in simple Punjabi.
  3. Go to GurmutVeechar.com has so much katha I recommend Sant Gurbachan Singh Bhindrawale
  4. Dasam Granth doesn't mention Dusht Daman all it says is that Guru Ji in his previous life did deep meditation at a location forgot the name. It is called the seven peak mountain in bani
  5. Guru Sahib knew someone would assassinate them they accepted hukam. Guru Ji knew that someone working at Anandpur would betray him and get his children and mother killed but he didn't change it he accepted hukam.
  6. I just have to say love Banda hate Banda you have to admit that he had a huge influence in Sikh History.
  7. Can you provide the name of the text he translated.
  8. I don't want this to be a debate just a place where we can share our opinions on the heroic or evil Banda Singh (Heard people say he didn't take amirt) IMHO he was bad. Genocideal man who drifted off the Gurus path and made himself a Guru. (That was a terrible opinion by me long ago. I have changed how I see Baba Banda Singh Ji Bahadur now. Please forgive me for the nindya.
  9. Not denying that just saying we should take a Hukamnama from Guru Ji about Gobind Gita.
  10. If anyones knows everything it is Guru Ji so what to lose from asking about it?
  11. I don't know why no one has thought of this before but why don't we take a hukamnama asking Guru Ji if Gobind Gita ia his bani.
  12. Well Khan Singh says it was written by a court poet which is possible. I feel we need to do more research on this and Sarbloh Granth
  13. Any evidence that Guru Ji wrote Gobind Gita? I believe in all of Dasam Granth but for the removed banis I am skeptical. I know it is in some Dasam Granth Birs wrriten by Baba Deep Singh Ji but do we know definitively that he wrote those Birs and if yes what is the evidence? Do any historical texts mention it?
  14. What are you saying? Are you saying I am a Hindu. I have always been a Sikh
  15. Nah I haven't eaten meat since I was 10 and I don't want to.
  16. After doing some research the ban on beef in the Sikh empire had nothing to do with the Sikh belief. It was to gain Hindu support in Kashmir.
  17. That is what some Christians say (atleast the Christians I know)
  18. Sikhism its Philosophy and History is also good
  19. 1984 India's Guilty Secret The best book about the Sikh Genocide A History of the Sikhs by Kushwant Singh I know he has some controversial views about Bhindranwale but his book is amazing and provides primary sources for everything Sikh History from Persian Sources is amazing and show a different view on Sikh History Warrior Saints is an amazing book which is definitely a must read
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

Terms of Use