Search the Community

Been watching his videos and following him for a while now. I agree with him largely, but also disagree with him for his stance on some of his views. His critics hardly ever pose a reasonable challenge, but argue that he is a revisionist. He has the following claims: 1. Damdami Taksal is falsehood that has taken over sikhi. He claims Jarnail Singh bhindrawale along with his followers are/were “Gunday” that have done so much damage to the panth. 2. His stance about the tarn taran issue is also controversial. 3. He disagrees with the main story of the Amrit sanchar of 1699. He claims that the panj pyare that got up were basically told by Guru Gobind Singh to do so prior to the ceremony. Basically it was staged. 4. He doesn’t believe in dasam Granth and claims that it’s false. Specifically triya charritar. This has been his main issue, to stop the Parkash of dasam Granth from all the takhts. He has other criticisms regarding dasam bani and other stories sikhs have been told growing up. All the people on this forum that disagree with him, what is your opinion? Can anyone any mahapurakh, pseudo mahapurakhs of the 21st century, can prove him wrong. Are we just blindly following whatever is being shoved down our throats?