Why Khalastan won't Survive?

[Bijla Singh]

Many people don't support Khalastan on the basis that a Sikh country will not survive long enough. So those who think this way have a chance to explain in some details. Why do you think Khalastan will not survive? Only discuss survival. if you don't support it for any other reasons don't use this topic to post. Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh

[ravindersidhu]

few question which come to my mind are

What kind of taxes will there be in khalistan,

how will the military be established,

how will we secure the borders, there will be india on one side and pakistan on the other, both r traditional enemies ... most ppl in punjab say drugs r smuggled in from rajasthan, so securing the indian border would be very important,

right now the indian govt gives LPG and other fuels, some of which r at a subsidised rate, so won't these things be more expensive in the newly formed khalastan... how will that be managed

in 47 when sikhs moved from pakistan to punjab they got lands in return of what they lost in pakistan, will there be such an arrangement for those who lose assets in india, coz there r many sikhs in UP who own farming land

other than that intelligent manpower, that will be another challenge

when i try to imagine a khalastan these questions come to my mind

another thing is there r a large number of followers of these radha soami's and nirankari's in punjab itself, what will be the status of these preachers, giving religious freedom is one thing but allowing them to go on preaching the bogus stuff,

is there a way to resolve this peacefully, will minimal resentment from the people

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa

Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh

[paul_84]

well my thinking is that it will survive but as ive heard frum people they say that religion and government should be seperate because if they are one then a state can never stay held.. fateh

[The Khalsa Fauj]

It won't be made until all jathas follow one maryada. All issues solved. Joined together. No hatred. Not here to start a debate between jathas but many fanatic taksalis say that AKJs aren't Sikh because they don't follow raagmaala. I was surprised at the hatred the youth has for other jathas or other Sikhs. Brainwashing has to stop.

[Ranz_Killa]

wjkk wjkf..

Some people say that if Khalistan is made, then Pakistan will try takin it over or somthin??? somethin amongst them lines, im not sure.. not even sure how big khalistan will be? will it be just panjab today, how Panjab was years n years ago, before India started cuttin it down..

Also, one thing that i think about a lot, is the population in Panjab, cos i duno wher i heard it, but i heard that there are many Hindus (Hindu Panjabis) livin in Panjab, and there are more Non Sikhs than Sikhs in Panjab.. is that true or an incorrect fact?

Wjkk wjkf

[Ranz_Killa]

Sorry, double post

[Guest Akaal108]

It won't be made until all jathas follow one maryada. All issues solved. Joined together. No hatred. Not here to start a debate between jathas but many fanatic taksalis say that AKJs aren't Sikh because they don't follow raagmaala. I was surprised at the hatred the youth has for other jathas or other Sikhs. Brainwashing has to stop.

98567[/snapback]

and some akj fanatic says - others are not sikh who don't follow sarbloh bibek and consider kes as kakar and read - ragmalla.

[Bijla Singh]

Some people say that if Khalistan is made, then Pakistan will try takin it over or somthin??? somethin amongst them lines, im not sure.. not even sure how big khalistan will be? will it be just panjab today, how Panjab was years n years ago, before India started cuttin it down..

Also, one thing that i think about a lot, is the population in Panjab, cos i duno wher i heard it, but i heard that there are many Hindus (Hindu Panjabis) livin in Panjab, and there are more Non Sikhs than Sikhs in Panjab.. is that true or an incorrect fact?

More land doesn't ensure success of a country. Switzerland, a landlock country is lot better than Afghanistan. Not only today but it has always been better. japan is better than china. Population means nothing. Sikhs are more in Punjab but in Sikh Raj Sikhs were only 15%, hindus 25% and rest were muslims. More people only means one thing, poverty. Less people but hard working are better than more lazy people. Sikhs are hard working people. it is a fact. So a country's success does not depend on land or population as much as you think. It makes very little difference.

Only when jathas are out of the picture we will start thinking about Khalsa jatha. Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh

[ms514]

Sat Sri Akal:

First...

Seriously though, the Khalsa's affairs are handled by the Guru. Stop worrying about these things...

[Punjabi_Link]

Has anybody hear these quotes before? If so, then who said it?

"Sikhs can conquer the world in 7 days, but cannot rule for a single day"

"Sikhs and their homeland is like a sandwich about to be cut in half"

P.S. LONG LIVE KHALISTAN!!!