Jump to content
Sign in to follow this  
singh surma

Sant Bhindranwale and the Babbar Khlasa

Recommended Posts

i had read on a few sites that the Babbar Khalsa opposed Bhindranwale...is this true?

also did the Babbar Khalsa openly kill hindus and others who disagreed with them?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

waheguru ji kekhalsa, waheguru ji ke fateh

Pyare jio, this is not true. Sant ji and the babaars got on very well. I have written about this extensively after interviewing the peronalities involved.

Some books mention it, and like all bad historians, rather than interviewing and doing the research, some writers have just copied those before.

The GOI wanted trouble between the two groups. Sant ji, Bhai Amolak singh (now in Austrailia) and the late Bhai Joginder SIngh Talwara agreed before 1984 that no rehit issues would be used to split the Panth in them difficult days. Everyone stuck to their words.

Also detailed interviews of Bibi Amarjit kaur ( wife of Bhai Fauja Singh) also confirm that much of this is not true. Books claimed she made statemnts against Sant Ji. She did not it was Bibi Harsharan kaur, (now in Panchain).

If you do a search of articles, you will come across much of the research done into this matter. Do not believe everything you hear from self-interest groups, or read in books from dodgy historians.

waheguru ji kekhalsa, waheguru ji ke fateh

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Waheguru ji ka khalsa

Waheguru ji ki fateh

I'de like to reply by saying that No! BKI and Sant ji did not have problems. If you want, get Sant Jees tapes and listen through and he mentions Shaheed Jathedar Talvinder Singh Babbar. As well singhs did have difference of opinions but the main objectives were all the same.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Bhai Amolak singh (now in Austrailia)
he speaks very rudely against Taksal and sounds like him and AKJ did everything.
Bhai Joginder SIngh Talwara agreed before 1984 that no rehit issues would be used to split the Panth in them difficult days.

does 1996 count as diificult days? because Joginder Singh Ji did involve the rehat issues when Taksal and AKJ decided to join together.

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I think their was differences between two groups.. but who care now.. they are gone !!!! Wanna be like them.. then first do good in studies.. become good lawyers, doctors, engineers and then do good for punjabi (be it sikh, hindu, muslim, christian) !! That will make our shaheed fighters happy !!!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest Akaal108

It's very well known in taksali circles that shaheed bhai sahib bhai fauja singh ji's wife tried to kill sant baba jarnail singh ji bhindranvaley.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

N30 wrote:

“It's very well known in taksali circles that shaheed bhai sahib bhai fauja singh ji's wife tried to kill sant baba jarnail singh ji bhindranvaley.”

Oh really?? Well I’ve been around Taksal ‘circles’ since my childhood, and I haven’t heard this type of BS in my life. Some shararatee anti-panthic people have tried to tell lies but I have never heard of Bibi Jee trying to ‘kill’ Baba Jernail Singh Jee Bhindrawalay as you claim. Even the dodgy authors who try to show hate between the Babbars and Sant Jee never claim this BS story of bibi jee trying to kill Sant Jee.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest Akaal108
N30 wrote:
“It's very well known in taksali circles that shaheed bhai sahib bhai fauja singh ji's wife tried to kill sant baba jarnail singh ji bhindranvaley.”

Oh really?? Well I’ve been around Taksal ‘circles’ since my childhood, and I haven’t heard this type of BS in my life. Some shararatee anti-panthic people have tried to tell lies but I have never heard of Bibi Jee trying to ‘kill’ Baba Jernail Singh Jee Bhindrawalay as you claim. Even the dodgy authors who try to show hate between the Babbars and Sant Jee never claim this BS story of bibi jee trying to kill Sant Jee.

100777[/snapback]

Hey Hey if taksali could have different version as of how bhai sahib bhai randhir singh ji beleived in ragmalla in his last days then what make soo sure they don't beleive in above? surely, it may be very well an bs... i don't take someone words as gospel truth but i m stating what they think.. if you got problem.. contact them. :e:

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest A Singh.

Here is an excerpt from an interview with Bhai Fauja Singh's wife, Bibi Amarjit Kaur, taken from August 2004 edition of So Kaheeat Hai Soora.

Usually in the media and in the religious-political groups, you are presented as having been opposed to Sant jee. How much truth is there in this?

There is no truth in this at all. I truly respected Sant Giani Jarnail Singh jee from my heart and will continue to do so. He used to have a lot of respect for me as well. I remember that when we used to meet in the Parkarma, he would say Fateh first and would say over and over, “Well Bibi jee, are you well? Is there any seva…if you need anything let me know. My head bows before you and because you are the wife of a Shaheed, I respect you from my heart.”

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest Akaal108
Here is an excerpt from an interview with Bhai Fauja Singh's wife, Bibi Amarjit Kaur, taken from August 2004 edition of So Kaheeat Hai Soora.
Usually in the media and in the religious-political groups, you are presented as having been opposed to Sant jee. How much truth is there in this?

There is no truth in this at all. I truly respected Sant Giani Jarnail Singh jee from my heart and will continue to do so. He used to have a lot of respect for me as well. I remember that when we used to meet in the Parkarma, he would say Fateh first and would say over and over, “Well Bibi jee, are you well? Is there any seva…if you need anything let me know. My head bows before you and because you are the wife of a Shaheed, I respect you from my heart.”

100834[/snapback]

Thanks for this dialogue. :doh:

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Wait for what?? Why wait?? Are you part of some master plan or something :doh: @ ?? I think most of the cyber supporters of the freedom fighters are fake.. ask singhs how hard it is to stay away from family, bear the torture and hide their identity so on.. guys like you and even me will shiver just by the one joothey of pp.

Neo veeerjee.. i think its not good to spoil the image of the bibi jee.. i think that's more likely to be a hoax by yung punks.. but even if it is true.. things like this should be avoided all the time.. definately on internet.. If we don't avoid than we are one of the reason of having soo many problems in our kaum..

anyway me out...

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest Akaal108
Neo veeerjee.. i think its not good to spoil the image of the bibi jee.. i think that's more likely to be a hoax by yung punks.. but even if it is true.. things like this should be avoided all the time.. definately on internet.. If we don't avoid than we are one of the reason of having soo many problems in our kaum..

anyway me out...

amen to that bro.. will be careful next time :T:

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
guys like you and even me will shiver just by the one joothey of pp.

wah wah bahut bahaduri di gaal keeti ah tu, a real lion of the panth, police di jooti toh darn wala

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Wait for what?? Why wait??  Are you part of some master plan or something  :doh: @ ?? I think most of the cyber supporters of the freedom fighters are fake.. ask singhs how hard it is to stay away from family, bear the torture and hide their identity so on.. guys like you and even me will shiver just by the one joothey of pp.

Neo veeerjee.. i think its not good to spoil the image of the bibi jee.. i think that's more likely to be a hoax by yung punks.. but even if it is true.. things like this should be avoided all the time.. definately on internet.. If we don't avoid than we are one of the reason of having soo many problems in our kaum..

anyway me out...

101139[/snapback]

ur screen name is SINGH rite....singh means lion and a lion isnt afraid of anything get that through ur head and talkin about being away from our family and fighting and giving away our lives for our panth..maybe u cannot do that and maybe u are scared of that but hey dont drag me into that if god ever gives me a chance like he gave the sikhs in 1984' i would leave my family and people to step up and fight for my religion ..so maybe u will not be bale 2 do that but i will...and dont even try saying stuff about me if u dont noe me ...and yes just to mark it u may be fake but me --IM NOT...sorry for bein a bit mean' but u jus pushed me too hard...gurfateh!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
Sign in to follow this  



  • Topics

  • Posts

    • It's a woman even if she returns and claims to be a male to discredit my judgement. It's a woman. Only a woman objects to a light being shone on the unflattering and rarely mentioned aspects of her sex's psychology and habits. When I've dragged Sikh males over the coals on this forum, not one guy ever objected to me doing so. Neither did any Sikh females interestingly enough. Nobody said, "But not all Sikh males are like that." You all quietly accepted my assessment of the situation. Your silence meant you agreed. As for Ajeet, I castigated him in the past for not having the courage to spurn marriage. He only got married to get his parents off his back. He's deceived a woman into a lifelong union that should never have happened. He tried arguing in the past that what he'll provide for his wife will be no less than what a hetero husband would do for her (and therefore, in his mind, that makes it morally acceptable), which he feels is difficult to refute, yet I believe had the girl known about his orientation there is NO way she would've agreed. She deserved to know.  Despite all this, he asked for advice, and I gave him my take on the situation. I gave him an unpleasant and stark take on his problem. I won't grind my gears and shower this place with empty platitudes that are useless and impractical. I told him what MIGHT happen based on a few variables in play. I didn't bother softening or sugar coating what he needed to hear.
    • this seems a spurious sakhi because Amar Das ji's mind was won over by the singing of gurbani by Bibi Amro ji , he had no NEED to test the Guru , he was totally overjoyed to finally find his Guru ji  ever read 1st pauri of Anand Sahib ?
    • what makes you think it is a lady , could be a clean hearted youth ? ... anyway it is unreasonable to assume that his(Ajeet's)  wife will cheat on him as she has much more to lose than him as she has a child , a home and the respect of his family name . Maybe he is still mentally troubled by his own kaamic thoughts and is projecting , best solution is to let her use her talents in a safe arena so she feels happy and heard  and he works on being close and loving as a family man . This allows him the monetary support he feels he needs and perhaps the lessening of his mental stress but only if he will be able to stop overthinking and imagining calamity at every turn . Remember this is the guys who was insisting on aborting his child because his wife had a fever .
    • Wonderful women. Nothing like the ones we decry, hence why some of us are able to discern the quality women in our lives versus the devious, one-dimensional trash trying to gaslight society into believing they possess any virtues whatsoever. Which category do you fall into?
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

Terms of Use