Chaupai Sahib

[The Khalsa Fauj]

They are not questioning Akaal Ustat. Just those shunds about Durgaa which were added by Sukha Singh granthi of Patna Sahib. He was a devi Bhagat. Original Akaal Ustat doesn't have those. The one in Gulab Singh bir doesn't have the shund sin Akaal Ustat. Yes you are right about Guru Ji's bani and translations. That is what we are saying, keep the GuruBani and forget about the translations. Translations weren't done by Guru Ji, as stated in the work itself. E.g. 24 Avtaar.

Poet Shyam is mentions himself.

E.g. Kirpaa Kur Shyam, mohay ehai bur deejai.

E.g. In tria chariters it is mentioned

says Raam, says Kal, etc.

We only belive in reading and doing kirtan from Sri Mukhvaak bani. Not translations.

Thank You!

[The Khalsa Fauj]

So no more Deh Siva, no more Binti Sun Leejai, No more Joree Jeo Jug Chaar Tehaaree which is from a chariter about krishan. Since you admit that some of the stuff is translations, isn't it beadbi to put translations with Gurbani?

[palamrinder]

What about Chaupai sahib? its not translation.. Should it be omitted too.... and as far as i know part of it are recited in rehraas sahib... even at shri darbar sahib... what is sgpc's stand on that?

[JSingh]

Sorry folks, I am stuck on something really really important that I have to complete and will get back to this and other thread as soon as I get done... may take a while.