Gandhi Met Bhagat Singh And Left Non Violence!

[SSM]

No, Gandhi may not have wanted a divide but that's because he did not want hindus to lose land.

He was for the caste system, he called Dashmesh PitaJi something I don't want to type on this forum, and if you read up on some of his other ideas you realise that the only thing he was good at was.....tying a dhoti.

[pun9ab1]

Please refer to me the link where he says that and back up your argument. Yes, i am aware of his beliefs on him being a hindu but they re not anything what you would call "extreme."

And him not wating hindus to lose there land. that is untrue, If that was the problem then other hindus would not disagree with him for wanting to keep pakistan in India, Which they did and the reason he died.

[SSM]

Caste is a big problem in India where members of lower castes suffer daily at the hands of upper class hindus. Before you begin to support Gandhi could you tell us why he did not wish to see the abolition of the caste system?

That's just one point.

[jai_ho]

....this old fool said sorry to british on behalf of indian people whn udam singh shot dyar.

..if it wasn't for people like bhagt singh, india would still be colony of british.

..people say gandi got the independence, wot a joke, british had no problem will having little man power present in india as gandi told the people not to defend their self.

...today india got about 22 battialns of sikhs in army, & only this protects india, imgin the followers of gandi on the borders of india

[Balwinder Singh]

Caste is a big problem in India where members of lower castes suffer daily at the hands of upper class hindus. Before you begin to support Gandhi could you tell us why he did not wish to see the abolition of the caste system?

That's just one point.

I disagree with this statement about Gandhi. Can u prove ur allegation?

[Guest Narinder Singh]

Its funny but not surprising that in India; rich, and highly educated politicians, who belong to the "upper class", and rarely do anything for the nation are revered as liberators and hero's. Not the ones who willingly give up all comforts, and eventually their lives.

Oh Bharat, will u ever change?

Fateh.

[pun9ab1]

Umm, guys bhagat singh wanted India to become communist9 the reason communist party uses his picture all the time) and he also dianounced skihism in his later life.

my proof: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bhagat_Singh

if you look at the "Ideal and opnions" you will see his veiws on Atheism and marxsim.

I'm tring to make Bhagat singh look bad here but you must understand no great men are prefect, that's what makes them human.

oh and Narinder India will change. If you ook closely India is follwing the sae path United States followed many years ago.

[SSM]

Caste is a big problem in India where members of lower castes suffer daily at the hands of upper class hindus. Before you begin to support Gandhi could you tell us why he did not wish to see the abolition of the caste system?

That's just one point.

I disagree with this statement about Gandhi. Can u prove ur allegation?

You mean you need me to prove he agreed with caste?

[pun9ab1]

yes, you do. I have not seen written anywhere where it says he approved te caste system, and please provide a crediable source.

[SSM]

I don't know much about Gandhi but you obviously know only what his 'fans' wrote. Read this which I came across in my search on the net, of course if a quote by Gandhi is not enough I can't help you, not that I came on this site to help you.

http://www.bfg-muenchen.de/caste.htm