Jump to content
Sign in to follow this  
_!_GUPT_!_

It Guru Ji's Bana Not Nihang Bana!

Recommended Posts

there were only four major jathebandis which can be tracked from guru gobind singh jis time ...

1 nihung

2 taksal

3 nirmale

4 sevapanthi

all wear banna but they are different ... its almost 300 years taksal and nihangs never had fight over banna or dummala ...

now u said rajputs wearing banna is not related to topic but it is ... as its being falsely propagated that banna was given to sikhs only and it was becuase sikhs were hiding their identity as in first post ... but the truth is only dummala and kashera was given ...

now i have only three questions

why akj didnt wear any sort of bannas and dummalas before 1950s ???

if nihangs wearing banna cant be called nihang banna and is anti panthic ... why kirten done by akj is always called akhand kirten ???

if calling them nihang banna and taksali kirpan is division between sikhi ... then why not calling ourselves hindus sikhs muslims is division between humanity ???

ps - i have no problem anyone wearing banna ... but whats the problem in calling it nihang banna ... when it was only and only nihangs that kept it alive till today ... ???

and from the 1st post its clear its not about panthic unity etc ... its about akj is feeling down if some one say they are wearing nihang banna ... 'AKJ have taken the nihang bana'' ... it is insult to akj as if nihangs are untouchables ...

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

You lot can come up with as many excuses as you want. There is only 1 Khalsa. We should NOT label ourselves Taksali, AKJ or w/e. It just causes divisions in an already dividing panth...like JustME pehnj said...like caste wasn't a bit enough problem! Now we can't go to a reihnsbhai because our Taksali mates don't agree with it? We can't have Raagmala at an Akhand Paath because AKJ don't agree with it? I can't wear bana because I don't roam around like a REAL Nihang?

ARE YOU KIDDING ME? Like life isn't hard enough dealing with outer forces trying to divide us...

Start growing up, because I'm no Brahmgyani- but I'm pretty sure Guru Ji would be ashamed of us right now. :rolleyes:

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Ok calm down people

basically can everyone report this group please. majority people agree with me its NOT nihang bana.

Fateh Jio

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Ok calm down people

basically can everyone report this group please. majority people agree with me its NOT nihang bana.

Fateh Jio

majority of hindus also think sikhs are hindus ...

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

it was just to seek ur attention :rolleyes:

now plz reply to my questions

now i have only three questions

why akj didnt wear any sort of bannas and dummalas before 1950s ???

if nihangs wearing banna cant be called nihang banna and is anti panthic ... why kirten done by akj is always called akhand kirten ???

if calling them nihang banna and taksali kirpan is division between sikhi ... then why not calling ourselves hindus sikhs muslims is division between humanity ???

and add one more

u said akj is not a clan then why is it named akhand kirteni jatha ... jatha ... who is dividing sikhi now ????

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
it was just to seek ur attention :rolleyes:

now plz reply to my questions

now i have only three questions

why akj didnt wear any sort of bannas and dummalas before 1950s ???

Perhaps some individuals sikhi spiriti was reawakened like those youth in western countries who wear bana?

if nihangs wearing banna cant be called nihang banna and is anti panthic ... why kirten done by akj is always called akhand kirten ???

Because like an akhand paath it usually lasts for a long time and is good for your jeevan?

if calling them nihang banna and taksali kirpan is division between sikhi ... then why not calling ourselves hindus sikhs muslims is division between humanity ???

It IS a division of humanity but we follow Guru Ji's hukam and if they say it's ok to be sikh then it's ok...but I don't think they'd say divide the sikhs up with jathas...

and add one more

u said akj is not a clan then why is it named akhand kirteni jatha ... jatha ... who is dividing sikhi now ????

A valid point

Tried to answer as best as I could :p

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
why akj didnt wear any sort of bannas and dummalas before 1950s ???

do AKJ have to wear a bana all the tym to have to wear it now?

if nihangs wearing banna cant be called nihang banna and is anti panthic ... why kirten done by akj is always called akhand kirten ???

so if a taksali wears a big kirtan its calld a taksal kirpan? Akhand Keertani Jatha basiclly means constant keertan jatha and it isnt always call akhand kirtan!

if calling them nihang banna and taksali kirpan is division between sikhi ... then why not calling ourselves hindus sikhs muslims is division between humanity ???

the Khalsa have to stay together!

u said akj is not a clan then why is it named akhand kirteni jatha ... jatha ... who is dividing sikhi now ????

because they do constant keertan! and i am not dividing sikhi so don't use sarcastic remarks!

pul chuk maaf karni

Fateh Jio

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
do AKJ have to wear a bana all the tym to have to wear it now?

i never said that ... akj is always welcome to wear nihang banna ... my question was totaly different i just asked why didnt akj wore banna and dummala before 1950s ...

so if a taksali wears a big kirtan its calld a taksal kirpan? Akhand Keertani Jatha basiclly means constant keertan jatha and it isnt always call akhand kirtan!

no the kirpan made at taksal is called taksali kirpan

this is taksali kirpan

http://farm3.static.flickr.com/2392/154544...eca177e.jpg?v=0

is calling this kirpan taksali anti sikhi ... ???

the Khalsa have to stay together!

khalsa stayed together for all this time and would stay together for ever ... anek hai fer aik hai ... many khalsai jathebandis many khalsayi mareyadas ... many different paths ... yet they attain same thing and had unlimited respect for each other ... but the thing is keeping ur jathas thinking over others in what way this unity can be attained in 21st century ??? when u are not even ready to call ur banna nihang banna as if nihangs are untouchable ... and using thing associated to them is insult to u as u said in ur first post !!

because they do constant keertan!

exactly they do kirten thats why they are called akhand kirteni jatha ... what if some nihangs start doing non stop kirten ... do u accept them as akhand kirteni jatha to ????

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

lol jatha-bashing logh... stop arguing over nothing, now you're arguing over opinions and not facts

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

After going through all the posts we have decided that everyone is a winner. Prize distribution ceremony will commence now...

jassa gets akj dastar as his prize.

_!_GUPT_!_ is being awarded the nihung bana.

From this day we pass a resolution that no nihung will ask an akj to take off their nihung bana because it belongs to the nihungs. Same applies to the akj dumalla, nihungs can wear it too without being asked to remove it by the akj.

Nihungs are Akjs pagg-vatt veers/bhens. Akjs are nihungs bana-vatt veers/bhens.

Taksalis still have monopoly over the kirpan :) , we'll decide about that as soon as a new group on facebook fights about its autheticity.

All other posters who contributed in this thread will get a kachera autographed by ANT4RJ4MI.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
All other posters who contributed in this thread will get a kachera autographed by ANT4RJ4MI.
:LOLz:

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
After going through all the posts we have decided that everyone is a winner. Prize distribution ceremony will commence now...

jassa gets akj dastar as his prize.

_!_GUPT_!_ is being awarded the nihung bana.

From this day we pass a resolution that no nihung will ask an akj to take off their nihung bana because it belongs to the nihungs. Same applies to the akj dumalla, nihungs can wear it too without being asked to remove it by the akj.

Nihungs are Akjs pagg-vatt veers/bhens. Akjs are nihungs bana-vatt veers/bhens.

Taksalis still have monopoly over the kirpan :) , we'll decide about that as soon as a new group on facebook fights about its autheticity.

All other posters who contributed in this thread will get a kachera autographed by ANT4RJ4MI.

all are my brothers akj taksal their chardikalla is chardikalla of panth khalsa ... but i still say the thing which hurt me ... it was like nihangs are untouchable ... wearing banna if its associated with nihangs that insult for akj ... jiddan kehnde aa dillch goli wajji ... anyways i m sorry if i said anything wrong or hurt anyone and everyone should wear banna nihangs dont have copy right for anything but they do deserve the respect for keeping it alive !!!!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
Sign in to follow this  



  • Topics

  • Posts

    • Yes, knowledge of different schools og thought in india and even in islam is very helpful for Gurbani. Good taksaals/vidhaalye and steeks/tikakaar will teach you the background of every shabad. As the gurujis had many conversations myriads of people from all schools. And some of gurbani is those responses, background is very important.  Even knowing the stories of Rama etc.
    • Actually islam means submission. Not peace.
    • Don't be suprised if alot of videos that exposed these people and things go missing. The so called protecting kids and hate speech is a sham its actually denying free speech and free expression of thought. Cos alot of mild videos with alternative views and thoughts are taken down and channels closed for no reason. There are some nasty racist and pedofiles that deserved their channels closed but those warning people about stuff and videos even featuring crimes by governments and groups they got taken down too. Yet they were important in highlighting the crimes of these people so people could see the truth about what they got up to.
    • Here is my list of current problems we face as a kaum.  Traveling around giving aid / langar to non-sikhs. This thought was put into Sikh psyche as a strategy to destroy Sikhs from within by the enemy who wanted to move Sikhs away from position of strength to weakness. Guru ka langar never went around the world helping non-sikhs like this. Guru Ka langar was based on giving langar to the local sangat community. However was the non-sikh poor masses who came to the Sikhs and gurdwara's to get langar and get parchar to convert to Sikhi that made non-sikhs want to be a Sikh. This current innovation which has been created and run by idiots and is wasting sangats money giving langar away for free with no benefits for the kaum. The biggest gift a Sikh can give to a non-sikh is parchar because by that parchar the Sikh too will have to reform their character to live by what they preach. Not having well armed sewadaar guards of Gurdwara's. Safety and security of guru's house and his congregation should be paramount yet what do we see today? any afghan ahmed abdali, isis salafi muhammad musin, mughal aurangzeb can walk in and kill without any hindrance like we seen recently. What is the fall out? Sikhs will stop coming to gurdwara's and thus gurdwara commitee's lose income and gurdwara shuts down eventually. The non-muslim hating conquest loving isis type jihadi mullah nutjob wins as sikhi is seen as weak and finished eventually because gurdwara's are no longer safe spaces for people wanting to worship and congregate.  Sikhs of sarbat da bhulla mindset. Well meaning humanitarian liberal Sikhs but very gullible very politically and religiously naive not understand the full context of meaning of sarabat da bhalla and when to apply it. perhaps most of them have a sort of stockholm sydromme imprisoned by cultures and ideologies that are against Sikh interests and prevent their own community to survive. Fake Sikh puppet leaders. They are only in it for their own power, fame/popularity contest or financial gain (eg recent akal takht jathedhars, sgpc leaders, DT harnaam singh, Badal dal, congressi captain amrinder singh, etc). We need to support leaders who openly fight for the interests of Sikhs without being shy about it. Not having our own sovereign state nation. To conduct our own economic, military, religious and political affairs is the very reason we have so many problems. But its not necessary for the community to survive and thrive if other problems are dealt with. Inter-faith marriages and lack of promotion of inter-caste or inter-race Sikh marriages. Sikhs should activity promote inter-caste marriages within punjabis at the very least and help promote those non-sikhs to convert to Sikhi to marry someone within the faith.  
    • The tell-tale sign of an appointed gatekeeper of public discourse. Guiding the narrative and traffic of discussion away from "dangerous" areas that might prove to be troublesome for those at the very top. Someone like that gets to that position usually through attendance and membership of lodges... You can tell we're under lockdown. The mind goes to strange places when all the work of the day is done, lmao.
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

Terms of Use