Muslim Blog Debate Bbc Asain Network

[Avastha]

firstly theres a big problem with terminology our community keeps using

FORCED conversions hardly happen in the Uk, however conversion by grooming does

secondly grooming isn't exactly a crime, simply because its very difficult to prove and there is consent involved.

so we can't rely on the police for 'evidence'

nihal picked on these points and used them against the Sikh callers

I agree

Maybe if Sikhs on the whole nowadays stopped doing so much dikhaavaa and *edited* and concentrated on their education, we would have some excellent modern day young Sikh scholars like we did in the past and have at the present in our older generation.

[Into the Light]

anyone got a link to the recording?

[Singhson]

If they can groom people into extremists then I don't see how they would have any problems grooming these girls.

There's a man from the Sikh Missionary Society that goes to Gurdwaras up and down the country (UK) showing slide shows of girls etc that have had this done to them. Some of the cases are shocking

[raagiwannabe]

http://www.bbc.co.uk/radio/aod/asiannetwor.../asiannihal_wed

is there anybody able to get an mp3 version of this?

I appaud the sikh girls who rang in with their stories, this is the only real way of showing that its not just paranoid sikh guys.

[SaRpAnCh]

http://www.bbc.co.uk/radio/aod/asiannetwor.../asiannihal_wed

is there anybody able to get an mp3 version of this?

I appaud the sikh girls who rang in with their stories, this is the only real way of showing that its not just paranoid sikh guys.

bbc radio ripper

http://www.bbc.co.uk/radio/aod/asiannetwor.../asiannihal_wed

is there anybody able to get an mp3 version of this?

I appaud the sikh girls who rang in with their stories, this is the only real way of showing that its not just paranoid sikh guys.

bbc radio ripper is a download progrmme

[Akritghan]

for those of u lot that dont believe that there arent forced conversions in the uk

they are...i know lots of such families....they just wont talk about it because the families feel ashamed of everything

[Khalsa04]

What a lot of people don't realize is that Nihaal as a media personality has a duty to stay impartial, just because he comes from a Sikh background doesn't mean he has to have the same views as the rest of us.. And maybe he believes what we do to but has to stay impartial as a professional?

As for forced conversions, we all know they happen what needs to be done now is girls who have been victim to these must come forwards and share their stories to help other girls.. because silence is deadly..

As the saying goes, committing a sin is a sin, allowing a sin to be committed is an even bigger sin..

But who am I to talk, im a hypocrite..

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa

Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh

[SaRpAnCh]

What a lot of people don't realize is that Nihaal as a media personality has a duty to stay impartial, just because he comes from a Sikh background doesn't mean he has to have the same views as the rest of us.. And maybe he believes what we do to but has to stay impartial as a professional?

As for forced conversions, we all know they happen what needs to be done now is girls who have been victim to these must come forwards and share their stories to help other girls.. because silence is deadly..

As the saying goes, committing a sin is a sin, allowing a sin to be committed is an even bigger sin..

But who am I to talk, im a hypocrite..

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa

Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh

Im sure nihals a tamil sri lankan

[BABBAR KHALISTANI]

What a lot of people don't realize is that Nihaal as a media personality has a duty to stay impartial, just because he comes from a Sikh background doesn't mean he has to have the same views as the rest of us.. And maybe he believes what we do to but has to stay impartial as a professional?

As for forced conversions, we all know they happen what needs to be done now is girls who have been victim to these must come forwards and share their stories to help other girls.. because silence is deadly..

As the saying goes, committing a sin is a sin, allowing a sin to be committed is an even bigger sin..

But who am I to talk, im a hypocrite..

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa

Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh

LOL....u must be kidding mate...Nihal's a Srilankan

[Parm Singh]

What a lot of people don't realize is that Nihaal as a media personality has a duty to stay impartial, just because he comes from a Sikh background doesn't mean he has to have the same views as the rest of us.. And maybe he believes what we do to but has to stay impartial as a professional?

As for forced conversions, we all know they happen what needs to be done now is girls who have been victim to these must come forwards and share their stories to help other girls.. because silence is deadly..

I agree khalsa04 he has to stay impartial he can't be one sided but hes sri-lankan. The website was wrong but we cant blame all Muslims for the actions of the few.

The blame either falls on our parents or sikh community maybe they havent us enough about sikhi? Or the children for being weak minded and letting lust take over?

Remember the hard times Sikhs both men and women went through, we gave our heads but not a sikhi.