Slander Of Dasam Bani On Spn

[Inder Singh]

.

The Guru Kian Saakian by Bhai Swaroop Singh Kaushish

Guru Kian Sakhian is said to be largely based on Bhatt Vahis which the author has got from his ancestors. Originall;y he wrote it in Bhattakri, a peculaiar form of Devanagri without vowel symbols. In 1868 Chhajju Singh, a descendant of the author converted it into Gurmukhi. However, the original in Bhattakhri and its second version in Gurmukhi are no longer extant, which put a big question mark on the very origin of this document. The present version in circulation is a copy which Giani Garja Singh has made from another copy (of Sant Gurdit Singh).

This is is the source you talk about yes? If so, can you apologise for this?

When people fall short of raesoning they accuse other side of being arrogant etc etc. i did not use bad language for dal singh ji otherwise filter would have been activated as had happened in his case.

Let us take the real issue. I was talking about same guru kian sakhian about which you seem to be knowing now. In which Gurudwara you found those? These are printed in book form by Piara singh padam.What makes to label those as unreliable?

Dr Piara singh Padam had done extensive study on Guru kian sakhian . Guru kian sakhian are considered to be very reliable account of Guru period by eminent writers of sikhism such as Harnam singh shan.

Will you please share with us your research that made you to reach your decision. i have a few books with me.

Inder Singh ji, if you cannot sense the amount of hankaar that you are projecting, then it is your own issue. A little humility on your part would do the cause to you are pursuing a world of good.

I apologise if i sounded to be full of ego.Let us continue the topic.

Regarding any other poster on any other site. I am not here to answer things on others behalf. You can communicate with them directly for that instead of being a drama queen about it. You have issues with a poster, take it up with them. Don't try and drag all and sundry into it. lol

Have you noticed your humility that is reflective in your language? try to come to earth. You defended SPN in the beginning saying you are a moderator there. Hence the above for your notice.

SPN has no Kala Afghana links. Views posted are the the opinions of those who posted them. No one is conspiring against you....you seem a bit paranoid at times.

You have two mentors who are hard core kala afghanis. MOst probably they are the only two mentors over there, I have indulged in discussions with these gurnindaks on may other sites. So i know them better than you.

Any good you can do is largely negated by the hot headed delivery of your points brother.

For blasphemic people sometime one has to be a little bit agressive.

Have you heard

Gur ki nida sunne na kan-----------

[Inder Singh]

So you are implying that Guru jee was so full of haumai that he actually meant Guru maneo dasam granth.... and not Guru maneo Sri Guru Granth Sahib jee ...?

both granths are written by guru sahiban. We consider SGGS as our Guru. Dasam granth is not Guru but equally important. Your hate for Dasam granth will amke sure it comes back to our Gurudwaras.

Why are you demeaning the power of Sri Guru Granth Sahib Jee?

Nobody is demaening SGGS ji. But mANY WHO DO NOT FOLLOW dASAM GRANTH ARE NOT sikhs even. Have no sikh identity.They follow only SGGS ji. Typical examples are sindhis. Advani says that he is a sikh. He believes only in SGGS ji.

people like Inder singh are best to be ignored Dal Singh.

They are lost in their own implications and will actually have NOTHING the way they want....they can keep posting befaltu bakwaas on forums..as this should be this..that should be that

.THE SANNTS know A TADD BIT MORE ABOUT SIKHI THAN YOU

The Brahmgyanis, whenever approached ask you to go and do ardaas to the Guru ji, because all around them is the parkash of Sri Guru Granth Sahib ji.

They never tell you to go read charitropakhiyan or Dasam Granth ji.

The loving bani of Jaap Sahib is well in everyones Nitnem and every Gursikh chants it with love....that is not even IN QUESTION....but to elevate your stupidity by saying ena da parkash ethe hone chahida uthe hona chahida....dont utter such blashphemy and weigh down your soul...

.. The Guru's decided everything....

BEEE CLEAR...tere kaen nal the sannts are not gonna change their Guru.

No wonder your/such dumb arguments are deleted/banned on all other sites except here.

I will request moderators to watch this man as he is saying that sants say do not raed charitropakhayan.

He should support his post by refrence whcih sant say this.

We read chartiropakhayan composition everyday in Nitnem.

explain what? my comment isnt exactly worthy of its own encyclopedia page, just a little sense or intelligence is needed to actually grasp what it means. unless of course you have spent most of your life locked up in a bedroom or basement, in which case i can completely understand why you are embarrassing yourself by asking stupid questions. its is pretty funny how you misinterpreted it in your posts earlier and made yourself look like a complete lunatic. well done.

when are you going to stop threatening me and start explaining?

FYI your comment: "some id1ots say the SGGS ji is all they need in life......... i imagine most of that life will be spent inside a bedroom then."

He is not threatening you. You are making an issue out of nothing. Your purpose is to spoil this thread.keep quiet if you have nothing to contribute.

[Inder Singh]

HSD ji

Anti dasam granth people are trained in psychological warfare. She knows she has no point but she will distract attention by useless ramblings.That is their main aim. They know they are wrong but they have to conduct propaganda.

[Inder Singh]

Dalsingh101 writes

SPN has no Kala Afghana links. Views posted are the the opinions of those who posted them. No one is conspiring against you....you seem a bit paranoid at times.

SPN has become a mouthpiece of kala afghana sect. Persons like khalsa fauj use obscene language for Dasam granth sahib and t Aman singh tolerates that. Is aman singh not the owner of that site. please do not try to sell me propaganda.

[Inder Singh]

Dalsingh101 writes

SPN has no Kala Afghana links. Views posted are the the opinions of those who posted them. No one is conspiring against you....you seem a bit paranoid at times.

SPN has become a mouthpiece of kala afghana sect. Persons like khalsa fauj use obscene language for Dasam granth sahib. Aman singh tolerates this. Is aman singh not the owner of that site.

[Inder Singh]

Jarnail singh Giani aka arshi is a mentor of SPN. Following is very amusing about this duplicate character.

(IMG:http://www.sikhawareness.com//style_images/1/spacer.gif)

. As for Jarnail Singh Arshi, that guy is a Naastik Kala Afghanist. A while back he was on Tapoban forum. At first Arshi used to believe in Naam Simran, Gurmantra, reincarnation etc, but as time went on slowly his views would seem to be tilting towards Kala Afghanist philosophy. until a point when he eventually left the Tapoban forum for SPN which is basically Kala Afghanist/Ghagha forum. That man is full of hate, anger. He uses intimidation against Sikhs who do not agree with his views. Moreover, he also uses deception. He will post under multiple names just to pretend he has more people supporting him. I remember him posting under his daughter's name just to make it appear he has more support. But it was so obvious that it was him. He has a very annoying way of writing, with every other word or every 3rd word he writes in capital letters.

[Mehtab Singh]

He has a very annoying way of writing, with every other word or every 3rd word he writes in capital letters.

You are ABSOLUTELY RIGHT. I read him LONG ago on Tapoban FORUM, and even THERE he used to write like THIS.

I can't stop laughing now!!!!!

[dalsingh101]

Anti dasam granth people are trained in psychological warfare.

Who teaches them? lol

This is actually nuts.

[Inder Singh]

Anti dasam granth people are trained in psychological warfare.

Who teaches them? lol

This is actually nuts.

Dalsingh101 ji

Nuts for you but not for others. There is something called sam,dham, dand and bhed in manu smriti. This is a long subject and you being ignorant of that may not follow.We can start a new thread for that.

But the subject post was not addressed to you. Let us not digress from the subject. You had something to show us about Dasam Granth authenticity question. Will you please let us know about that?

[lodi_my_dodi]

>>>>>>>>>>Dhan Dhan Sri Guru Granth Sahib ji Maharaj!<<<<<<<<<<<<

>>>>>>>>>>>>>>Dhan Dhan Sri Gur Dasam Darbar!<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<

Sikh Sangat doesn not allow discussion on Gur Dasam Darbar as per the Hukamnama from Akal Thakt. Ahem Ahem.

Please can we stick to talking about the !@##$% that are actively trying to destroy Sikhi rather than fighting over who is right and who is wrong. If SPN are saying that they dont support the lalloo and panjuus so be it, lets move on. If you dont like it boycott it, Simple but DONT stand for any beadbi of Guru Maharaj or Gur Dasam Darbar.