What Does Khalistan Mean To You

[Singhstah]

Though I do agree it will not be a normal nation, but a spiritual Khalsa Raj instead.

yes a spiritual khalsa raj. not physical.

and yes Vaheguu Ji is here and everywhere else aswel. but as in Karninama and Rajnama, He will take physical form and sit at the throne at Dehli.

He already has one eternal form, that is Guru Granth Sahib Ji+ Khalsa, this can NEVER change. If this new form is gonna come, then whats the point of Guru Mahraj creating khalsa? Is Guru Granth Sahib Ji Maharaj not powerful enough? I do not doubt Gurbani, but many sau sakhi have been adultered (eg. pro namdhari ones, pro british ones), so you have to take sources like this with a pinch of salt.

[satpunga singh]

Though I do agree it will not be a normal nation, but a spiritual Khalsa Raj instead.

yes a spiritual khalsa raj. not physical.

and yes Vaheguu Ji is here and everywhere else aswel. but as in Karninama and Rajnama, He will take physical form and sit at the throne at Dehli.

He already has one eternal form, that is Guru Granth Sahib Ji+ Khalsa, this can NEVER change. If this new form is gonna come, then whats the point of Guru Mahraj creating khalsa? Is Guru Granth Sahib Ji Maharaj not powerful enough? I do not doubt Gurbani, but many sau sakhi have been adultered (eg. pro namdhari ones, pro british ones), so you have to take sources like this with a pinch of salt.

he can change. if HE wills it.

Guru Granth Sahib Ji is powerful enough, but can u not see people turning away from Guru Ji?

we are not missionaries who go running after people who turn away. this is what Guru Ji has taught us.

i do not believe that Karninama and Rajnama are innaccurate.

[Bijla Singh]

Do you really think kalki will come? Chaubis Avtar is based on mythology and kalki avtar is mixture of Hindu and Muslim mythology. No one will come since greatest of all Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji is already here. Even if any avtar comes, he will bow down to Satguru. Khalsa Raj will come for sure.

[Himat408]

lets not make this a debate about dasam granth or sau sakhi. remember guru ji told not to sit around waiting for kalki avtar

[Koi]

Do you really think kalki will come? Chaubis Avtar is based on mythology and kalki avtar is mixture of Hindu and Muslim mythology. No one will come since greatest of all Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji is already here. Even if any avtar comes, he will bow down to Satguru. Khalsa Raj will come for sure.

Of course Kalki will come. <_<

[satpunga singh]

if chaubis avtar wasbased on mythology (hindu and muslim mixture), then it would not be 100% true. therefore Guru Gobind Singh Ji wouldnot have put it in Sri Dasam Granth Sahib Ji. it would have no use for us.....

[Bijla Singh]

Chandi Di Vaar, Chrittars, Chaubis Avtar are all based on mythology. Guru Sahib's purpose was to use these stories and give us morals not to authenticate these stories. There is nothing wrong with using a fake story to deliver the message. Gurbani and Vaars do the same. Purpose of kali avtar story is that no matter how powerful one becomes at the end they will be destroyed by kaal. It is a mythical belief amongst Muslims that Meer Mehdi will come before the Day of Judgment and convert everyone to Islam and destroy non-Muslims. Clearly, Sikhi rejects judgment day and relying on any future prophecies. I find it ironic that a hindu deity will come and then a Muslim warrior who will rule for thousands of years but if it is all true then where does that leave Khalsa and Khalsa Raj? I suggest you read kalki avtar in proper context.

[satpunga singh]

o well different views. but i dont think that khalistan will be achieved anytime soon.

whereever we are in the world we can promote it, but its the peple living in punjab that will have to stand up.

[Bijla Singh]

Only Guru Sahib knows when it is the right time for Sikhs to have their own country. It could be tomorrow or in 100 years.

[citizen_soulja]

Khalistan to me mean the ancestral land of the Sikhs - Punjab being liberated from the grip of India and Pakistan.

true only Vaheguru can decide when...

but what about the borders..??

I've seen a few pictures:

map_of_khalisatan.pdf