Is Bhangra Acceptable

[Amrit79]

Is bhangra acceptable in sikhi... I don't really care because I'm not amritdhari but I'm just asking.

[Guest shastr]

this topic has been discussed on the forum many times. dont be lazy singho, the search feature works wonders

[Guest shastr]

here are some previous theards:

http://www.sikhsangat.com/index.php/topic/3114-bhangra-hindi-movies-hindi-songs/page__p__29306__hl__bhangra__fromsearch__1entry29306

http://www.sikhsangat.com/index.php/topic/7930-is-listenin-2-bhangra-music-bad-in-sikhi/page__p__42396__hl__bhangra__fromsearch__1entry42396

http://www.sikhsangat.com/index.php?showtopic=28709&st=0&p=269816&hl=bhangra&fromsearch=1entry269816

http://www.sikhsangat.com/index.php?showtopic=36517&st=0&p=342093&hl=bhangra&fromsearch=1entry342093

http://www.sikhsangat.com/index.php/topic/39639-sikhi-dancing-bhangra/page__p__370329__hl__bhangra__fromsearch__1entry370329

http://www.sikhsangat.com/index.php/topic/42655-bhangra-and-sikhi/page__p__392430__hl__bhangra__fromsearch__1entry392430

[TheSuperbell]

It’s acceptable, just don’t let anybody see you doo it.

[Amrit79]

It's acceptable, just don't let anybody see you doo it.

thats pointless then....

[TheSuperbell]

It's acceptable, just don't let anybody see you doo it.

thats pointless then....

Seriously 'Amrit79' brighten up, it was only a joke fa cryin out loud.

[Starscream]

I love to get down to some bhangra!!!

[Papi]

As exercise it's okay. But when done where you show your "skills" to others, it is not good for one's spiritual journey. But we can easily say the same to stuff like the local tabla player playing some crazy composition during a shabad, or a kirtni playing a vajaa piece during kirtan...etc. It's a fine line which one must tread carefully.

[Only five]

As exercise it's okay. But when done where you show your "skills" to others, it is not good for one's spiritual journey. But we can easily say the same to stuff like the local tabla player playing some crazy composition during a shabad, or a kirtni playing a vajaa piece during kirtan...etc. It's a fine line which one must tread carefully.

Now that's a bad comparisons. A guy playing tabla with kirtan and a person 'dancing' like a moorakh on stage, which is highly likely degrading music. It's like comparing a whale to a dog and calling them the same.

Sorry I had to be harsh here, but in a way you asked for it.

[Papi]

^ i diot, way to miss the point