Sahib Singhs'S Gurbani Viakaran

[Bijla Singh]

The books I mentioned including Prof. Sahib Singh's book teach you the meanings of maatran not how to pronounce them. Bhai Randhir Singh explains the meaning of each aunkar and sihari and why they don't appear at some places.

[jaswinder singh]

Simple question:

Is Sahib Singhs's Gurbani Viakaran available online?

it is available in market , published by khalsa Brothers Amritsdar

[alias]

If you really want to learn Gurbani viyakaran then I'd recommend Gurbani Dian Laggan Matran Di Vilakhanta by Bhai Randhir Singh which is much better than work of Prof. Sahib Singh. Prof. Ji didn't follow grammar rules at many places in Gurbani. Also read Gurbani Viyakaran Saral Bodh by Joginder Singh Talwara and work of Pandit Kartar Singh Dakha. These provide correct interpretation of Gurbani according to Gurmat.

is it possible for you to upload a downloadable version of Bhai Randheer singh Jis book?? on scribd or somthing?

[alias]

The books I mentioned including Prof. Sahib Singh's book teach you the meanings of maatran not how to pronounce them. Bhai Randhir Singh explains the meaning of each aunkar and sihari and why they don't appear at some places.

i have a question, the word rid with the soft dada ( tata tha tha dada) has a sihaari in some places, even wen the word mehi comes after it...

how can this be possible?...

plus, the existance of the word 'pistol' in siri sarabloh granth for another name for a gun.. i seriously dought that this word pistol existed... im gona make a new poste regarding this so i hope this is k!!

[alias]

Proessor Sahib Singh Ji's Gurbani Viakran can be obtained online from http://www.jsks.co.i...ani_viakran.htm .

thats not what i mean..

a digitalised verson please.. this is the same site that somone else tried promoting on this forum website before...

[AmarjitKaur]

http://www.gurugranthdarpan.com/darpan2/0001.html

Prof. Sahib Singh's teeka.

[Bijla Singh]

i have a question, the word rid with the soft dada ( tata tha tha dada) has a sihaari in some places, even wen the word mehi comes after it...

Post in Gurmukhi so I can understand your question. Sarbloh Granth is not the work of Guru Sahib.

[alias]

http://www.gurugrant...rpan2/0001.html

Prof. Sahib Singh's teeka.

thanks for ur daya on ma post!!

but thats the teeka... the viakaran book, like gurbani grammer book is what im looking for... iv got talvaras book both parts... im looking 4 a online verson pdf, or foto pdf, of bhai randhir singhs book.

i dont know which bhai randhir singh it is, it may be THE bhai sahib bhai randhir singh.. but somone posted here that 'bhai randhir singh' has got a book on vikaran. so thas wot im afta.

btw the guru granth darpan, effectively the whole site is available in pdf format..

[alias]

Post in Gurmukhi so I can understand your question. Sarbloh Granth is not the work of Guru Sahib.

irid ibgwsu jwigE AliK kl DrI jugMqir ] this is fine i understand this.

bcn gur irid Drhu...] this is fine i understand this.

gur aupdys prvys irid AMqir hY] but this and the duhrw from the ending of bhai nandlaal jis rehetnama i do not.

dohrw ]

vwihgurU gur jwpeI vwihgurU kir DÎwn ] mukiq lwB mo hoie hY gurisK irid mih mwn ]23]

it was from this rehetnama that get me thinking that, from the standard viakaran, whenever ‘mih’ comes after the word, the ishwrI goes away on the previous word.. but here, the ishwrI is still there... I was thinking that this may have been a mistake in the printing. but, then I cam across > irid AMqir hY <. I guess my basic question is y is this dohrw say irid mih.

[alias]

as the gurmukhi dint turn out, iv pdf't what u see as my previous post.

also, i aint talking about the ridh as in ridh sidh....

'rid' as in hirda is wot im on bout.. the 'soft dada' rid as i put it before in my post that u dint understand..

soz bout the english punjabi btw...

the word rid.pdf