Jump to content
Sign in to follow this  
japjeev singh

Was Bhagat Singh An Atheist?

Recommended Posts

communism does not work

only way in india it would of worked is if state owned all assets for generation giving everyone in india an equal shot at education and prosperity and then slowly move towards a free market system and give more and more private ownership to people

cause sadly after Britain left the people who were in the middle class and upper class were the once loyal to the british and ruled india for the british n they continued to exploit india but now kept the british cut when it came to the money

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

simply...yes He was atheist but not pagan. another one was Khuswant singh (great indian poet ).

BUT............wait........

They always loved the way as Gurus told us ...They always loved What gurus have given us...

They always tried to maintain Gurus look....Sikh sardar..........

(sikhi is not forced on someone,its all about sharda..but If someone sikh can't follow the Gurbani or paadth,,atleast he should maintain the roop of Gurus.......but even if he can't handle it as well,,Then he/she should live according to manmat..

But later, In order to get any credit of sikhism in hi/her life,, They should not be Hypocrites...

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

simply...yes He was atheist but not pagan. another one was Khuswant singh (great indian poet ).

BUT............wait........

They always loved the way as Gurus told us ...They always loved What gurus have given us...

They always tried to maintain Gurus look....Sikh sardar..........

(sikhi is not forced on someone,its all about sharda..but If someone sikh can't follow the Gurbani or paadth,,atleast he should maintain the roop of Gurus.......but even if he can't handle it as well,,Then he/she should live according to manmat..

But later, In order to get any credit of sikhism in hi/her life,, They should not be Hypocrites...

no , please read jail chittiyan bhai randhir singh

bhagat singh was a normal person , even though he was born in sikh house hold.

he was a complete athiest

and he purposely cut his hair to let indian media to show him as hindu to obtain fame ,

its all in jail chittiyan please read

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

no , please read jail chittiyan bhai randhir singh

bhagat singh was a normal person , even though he was born in sikh house hold.

he was a complete athiest

and he purposely cut his hair to let indian media to show him as hindu to obtain fame ,

its all in jail chittiyan please read

Well said, brother.

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

bhagat singh did not cut his hair for fame or to win over the hindus

he cut his hair cause he no longer believed in god along with his friends

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

no , please read jail chittiyan bhai randhir singh

bhagat singh was a normal person , even though he was born in sikh house hold.

he was a complete athiest

and he purposely cut his hair to let indian media to show him as hindu to obtain fame ,

its all in jail chittiyan please read

I m not saying he was not atheist .. but being mona he was loved by hindus more...but he realized it later. but what did he do right or wrong I don't know but

at last he realized his faults and started keeping his kesh again in jail... and we know it was a good thing...

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

bhagat singh did not cut his hair for fame or to win over the hindus

he cut his hair cause he no longer believed in god along with his friends

He cut his hair because british police came to know that someone sikh guy had killed their police officer and it was bhagat singh and In order to escape and in order to protect other freedom fighters who were with him..He decided to lose his sikh look..

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
Sign in to follow this  



  • Topics

  • Posts

    • Ok, I think hadiths play a role in the conflict too because they reject each others hadiths. They  basically arguing over one matter but each using a different set of books with different narratives lol  Cant see them reaching a conclusion with that any time soon!   Shias dont like Aisha the child bride. Sikhs are really lucky that we dont have major differences in Sikh sects like muslims and Christian's do. The worst I can think of is the nirankaris and their on going line of gurus but they are pretty much are out of the fold of Sikhi now and did whatever damage they wanted to back in the 80s. 
    • Yes, @MuslimNeighbour, please do enlighten us on this (and other questions we have).
    • That's not entirely true. There is a Hadith (and I'm paraphrasing here as I don't remember all the details) when the prophet initially invited all the quresh tribes to dinner to invite them to Islam. He asked the question, who will be my brother (in faith), my friend and my successor (khalifa). Imam Ali immediately stood up. The prophet asked him to sit down (as he was still quite young, though extremely loyal to the prophet from day one). The prophet asked the question again, and again the same thing happened. On the third time, when Imam Ali stood up, the prophet said, very well, you will be my brother, my friend and my successor. This hadith is found in both sunni and shia books. There is also a verse in the quran (and please correct me if I'm wrong) where Allah says that he chooses his khalifa. Depending on the context of this verse, this could invalidate the khalifate of Abu Bakar and validate the divinity of Ali being the khalifa. There is also a "Hadith-e-Noor" (found in both sunni and shia books) in which the prophet says, Me and Ali are created from the same light. These (and many others) are just some of the points which could point to the divine claim that Imam Ali was indeed the divine successor to the prophet.  But yes, there was plenty of killing of the family of the prophet. And many battles ensued, which resulted in parts of the quran being lost. But...that's a different topic entirely....
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

Terms of Use