[New] Zakir Naik On Guru Nanak Ji Going To Mecca

[chatanga]

The sources were served among Sangat by Professor Himmat Singh at GNDU.

These sources will soon printed by GNDU.

That is reallyinteresting !

Please let us know as soon as these will be available.

[SantLUCIFER]

Don't believe what Naik says even the Muslims say he's potty and talks rubbish.

[Guest KopSingh]

Guru Nanak in Mecca. That is a subject, which can be debated and no answer will pursue. We need to look into history for an explanation but majority of the time it’s unclear and can confuse the subject matter.

We know from historical artefacts and number of writing by Sikh scholars and third party writings, Guru Nanak did go to Mecca but did Guru Nanak go to Mecca as a Muslim or a revolutionary?

Guru Nanak’s philosophical thought behind concept of God was a breath of fresh but during this era many would have regarded him as a insane.

Going back to the subject matter, Guru Nanak visited Mecca with a friend who was a Muslim and firm believer of Nanak philosophy, speaking to a Muslim historian, there is a belief during the era of Guru Nanak non Muslims were allowed to visit Mecca. There wasn’t a requirement like we have in the present day that only a person who follows the Muslim faith can visit Mecca. Mecca was the knowledge centre for Islam and many people from different faiths would go to Mecca to share ideas.

Could this be the case?

ive read somwehere before about emporor akbar saying theres nothing wrong with guru nanak going mecca because hes not an idol worshipper, nor does he believe in multiple gods, which is core belief to islam init!

maybe someone could get those links?