Ragi jatha singing a sufi song?

[gurdssingh]

Where was the panthic police, rehit nama enforcers division when bhai maradanas MUSLIM desendants performed kirtan at darbar sahib?

Just singing some songs! Singer23 that is manmat they should be summoned before akal takht.

[N30S1NGH]

Panthic police may also have problem with guru ki maseet - muslim mosque managed by nihangs

http://www.sikhiwiki.../Guru_ki_maseet

[Singh559]

Where was the panthic police, rehit nama enforcers division when bhai maradanas MUSLIM desendants performed kirtan at darbar sahib?

Just singing some songs! Singer23 that is manmat they should be summoned before akal takht.

They were singing Gurbani. They have utmost respect and satkar, more so than many Sikhs who needlessly spread manmat and further cause division among Sikhs by causing arguments.

There is nothing in Rehitname or anything that condemns Muslims or even Atheists coming into Sangat and singing Gurbani.

Not sure why you would say such a thing. This kirtan really strikes the chords how they are supposed to be - sung with piyaar and sharda regardless of being Muslim.

Waheguru

[gurdssingh]

They were singing Gurbani. They have utmost respect and satkar, more so than many Sikhs who needlessly spread manmat and further cause division among Sikhs by causing arguments.

There is nothing in Rehitname or anything that condemns Muslims or even Atheists coming into Sangat and singing Gurbani.

Not sure why you would say such a thing. This kirtan really strikes the chords how they are supposed to be - sung with piyaar and sharda regardless of being Muslim.

Waheguru

Go and read all the posts again. My comment was in response to the quote aboute only Gursikhs can perform kirtan. i am against any form of discrimination and don't like it one bit when some one justifies something by bringing religion into it, anyone should be able to perform kirtan. I think you may have misunderstood what I said.

Hence the term panthic police. BTW I meant to rehat maryada not rehitnama. My bad.

Why would you make the above comment and then also like the comment about Tony in which he quotes the sgpc rehit maryada in which it states only a sikh can perform kirtan in congregation? Please answer this as you can't have it both ways.

[Singh559]

Go and read all the posts again. My comment was in response to the quote aboute only Gursikhs can perform kirtan. i am against any form of discrimination and don't like it one bit when some one justifies something by bringing religion into it, anyone should be able to perform kirtan. I think you may have misunderstood what I said.

Hence the term panthic police. BTW I meant to rehat maryada not rehitnama. My bad.

Why would you make the above comment and then also like the comment about Tony in which he quotes the sgpc rehit maryada in which it states only a sikh can perform kirtan in congregation? Please answer this as you can't have it both ways.

Did not notice that was written. I'm set aback. I never knew there was such a rule.

I mainly focused on part c.

[curioustoknow]

Know that muslims fought sikhs in the name of Allah, but out does not mean that it was approved of by Him...why is it so hard to believe that there were many other enlightened people than just those directly associated with or religion? Are you going to tell me that before sikhism, the people had no guidance? There are more great people than just those recently that came...not to downplay our overcast the gurus or the martyrs associated with sikhism...this is not my intent...I promise. :-)

[mohinder pal]

"Jbb and Tabb ki......Baat Karon Mein Abb ki......Agar na Hote GURU GOBIND SINGH.....SUNNAT HOTI SABB KI" from Baba Bhulle SHah