Balanced View of Hindu-Sikh Shaster Vidiya

[THE WARRIOR]

Er……Sorry to spoil the “Great Slap your own back Seva” that you Godly and lovely people are doing, I hope some remotely intellectuals amongst you hearty bunch have realised that the so called letter of excommunication is a fake …..apologies again for spoiling the party however the few days of Super Seva Banter by the Panthic Police Force has been most amusing for this I Thank you! God bless you all and keep up the good work.

[THE WARRIOR]

There seems to be bugs on the forum Sorry to spoil the Great Slap your own back Seva that you Godly and lovely people are doing I hope some remotely intellectuals amongst you hearty bunch have realised that the so called letter of excommunication is a fake apologies again for spoiling the party however the few days of Super Seva Banter by the Panthic Police Force has been most amusing for this I Thank you! God bless you all and keep up the good work.

[Babbar_Singhsta]

have you got proof it's fake?

[THE WARRIOR]

Well rather than shaming people here on a public forum which is the usual manner in which business is conducted on SS, I suggest contacting any of the co-signers of the letter or just wait for the excommunication to happen or not be it in this case.

Laughable and shameful

[Babbar_Singhsta]

interesting.... would be easier just for a jathedar to be on tv and set the record straight either way.

[Into the Light]

I'm sure the the publishers of the letter can reply to this.

However, with regard to the ludicrous yet laughable claim that Niddar 'thinks' he is the 'last warrior'...please have a read of this:

http://akalinihang.blogspot.co.uk/2009/11/baba-giana-singh-shastarvidiya.html

[THE WARRIOR]

Sure the platform is there, this has been said for many years now but no one else has come forward to say they know the Vidya. There are a few Singhs who clearly say they know but don’t have the Full Vidya and of course there are also those that copy from the Akara and pass it off as their own. Anyhow it matters little.

[THE WARRIOR]

We can’t clearly live peacefully together so live each other alone and let people choose what path suits them. At the end of the day the arguments are just about definitions and nothing else.

[kullykhalsa]

agree with the above everyone has there own views on sikhi you can hardly change them and this thread has kinda turned into a bashing thread!

Original OP asked for balanced view but we have only got one side (although this is the side i agree with) without the other this is pointless

[Cisco_Singh]

Fact is most of these people making noise don't actually have any martial arts knowledge, they're primary issue is with The teacher and his views.

If for example Niddar Singh, conformed to their own view of Sikhi and the pentras etc in the shastar vidiya system had neutral names instead of names based around avtars from Hinduism.. these same people would be raving about Niddar Singh and singing his praises...