Amrit

[simran345]

Can somebody only shak Amrit, if they do nitnem, or get up at amritvela, or tie a dastaar, (being female)? If one is unable to do nitnem, or get up at amritvela or tie the dastaar, can one still shak Amrit? sorry i dont know much, but i know some elders shak Amrit and not doin nitnem as such, because of reading problems, but what if somebody is physically unable to do what is required by rehat maryada would they not be able to shak Amrit?

[gurdeepsinghjohal]

Dastaar for female is not mandatory.

If for sake of health or your professional reasons you cannot wake up in amritvela it is not a problem, but you should do nitnem or sahaj paath daily, if cannot do paath because of health reason, atleast one can get audio of baani, play and recite with it.

You can take khandey di pahul/Amrit, Akaal purakh is always with you, don't think of this and that.

[GurujisDaughter]

1. Can somebody only shak Amrit, if they do nitnem,or get up at amritvela, or tie a dastaar?

Can somebody be a good students if they don't do their homework, study for test?

2. i know some elders shak Amrit and not doin nitnem .
Even I know elders who do that, but they will not go to God when they die. They have taken admission in the school, but stopped attending it. So they arent learning much.

3. because of reading problems, but what if somebody is physically unable to do.
Unable to read? - listen to audio. Unable to hear? - read it.
It dosnt apply to all, but I came across an aunty who calls herself amritdhari. After I asked why she dosnt wear kakaars. She said - no keski, kirpan cuz they are heavy and she has backbone problem; no kara cuz she is too week and old; no kanga cuz dosn't have a place to put it. In my mind I just said HA! WHAT A JOKER, get out of my way!

But if there is a really good reason of not following rehet like... had an opperation, people still get pesh then!
And, oh Dastaar is important for girls (Many opinions ), but u cant meet god without it

[Guest dasguruka]

Yup. Just listen to it after doing 5 ishnaana. And do.WaheGuru jaap throughout the day

[gurdeepsinghjohal]

And, oh Dastaar is important for girls (Many opinions ), but u cant meet god without it

U need dastaar to meet god, interesting fact, please explain.

[GurujisDaughter]

U need dastaar to meet god, interesting fact, please explain.

I have had sangat with really high Gursikhs. They talk about Sachkhand and also say some of them can go to Sachkhand in Surti. They were talking about the kakaars and described how Guru Sahib first checks your kakaars when you go in.

Also, Bhai Surjit Singh from Toronto, a highly respected sikh also talked about this.

Guru Sahib knows more.

Sorry I do not want to turn this post into a battleground. I respect everybody's opinions

[gurdeepsinghjohal]

I have had sangat with really high Gursikhs. They talk about Sachkhand and also say some of them can go to Sachkhand in Surti. They were talking about the kakaars and described how Guru Sahib first checks your kakaars when you go in.

Also, Bhai Surjit Singh from Toronto, a highly respected sikh also talked about this.

Guru Sahib knows more.

Sorry I do not want to turn this post into a battleground. I respect everybody's opinions

People who talks like this are not high gursikhs but confused sikhs.

Gurbani says "Karmi Karmi hoye vichaar" never read in gurbani "dress ka hoe vichaar".

You need to look into Guru Granth Sahib and then listen to anyone else.

[gurdeepsinghjohal]

This is the way you should be.

ਹਰਿ ਜਨੁ ਐਸਾ ਚਾਹੀਐ ਜੈਸਾ ਹਰਿ ਹੀ ਹੋਇ ॥੧੪੯॥

Har Jan Aisaa Chaaheeai Jaisaa Har Hee Hoe ||149||

The humble servant of the Lord should be just like the Lord. ||149||

[GuptUnknown]

Guru Maharaj speaks to people differently, there's no one linear, black white path. Gurbani shouldn't be constrained to ones own interpertation and everyone else is wrong. Just ask Bhai Vir Singh ji . Waheguru.

[gurdeepsinghjohal]

Please prove this according to Gurmat.

I have had sangat with really high Gursikhs. They talk about Sachkhand and also say some of them can go to Sachkhand in Surti. They were talking about the kakaars and described how Guru Sahib first checks your kakaars when you go in.

Above quote says Guru Sahib checks the 5 K's and below one says another thing.

There is another video posted in a thread where Prof. Dhunda talks about a Baba ji had darshan of shaheed singhs they told baba ji that Guru Gobind Singh Sahib have given duty to take Amrithdahari gursikhs who dies, with them.

http://www.sikhsangat.com/index.php?/topic/70592-sarbjit-dhunda-mocks-sant-gurbachan-singh-and-giani-preetam-singh/?hl=dhunda

Which version we should believe.

All the Baba should sit together and should make a single thought of school so that people does not get confused.

And Manmukh like me does not ask a question