Sant Bhindranwale Did Nothing Wrong By Defending The Golden Temple

[AJ111]

Imagine if J.S.Bhindranwale had allowed the innocent pilgrims to leave before the battle commenced or better still curtailed his ego and surrendered to the army.

All the bloodshed and carnage could have been avoided.

[Jonny101]

Imagine if J.S.Bhindranwale had allowed the innocent pilgrims to leave before the battle commenced or better still curtailed his ego and surrendered to the army.

All the bloodshed and carnage could have been avoided.

On the contrary, the Indian army attacked without warning. Even before the actual attack by the army, they began pumping 10,000 bullets into the Harmander Sahib complex in order to provoke a response from the Sikhs. They did this in order to see the positions of the Sikh defenders. But Gen Shabeg Singh knew this and ordered the Sikh defenders to keep silent and not respond. But it is the Indian army which did not once think that it might hit some pilgrim (which it did). Even before the attack, they did not once warn the pilgrims so they could leave. They attacked without any provocation or warning. This is according to eye witness accounts of the pilgrims themselves who survived the attack.

And why should Sant Jee surrender? He was in the house of his Guru. Who is she to tell a Sikh to leave the house of his Guru? It was the ego of Indira Gandhi that was inflated. She could not handle the fact that there was someone who was standing up to her 'highness'. She wanted to teach the Sikhs a lesson they would never forget.

[Cisco_Singh]

Imagine if J.S.Bhindranwale had allowed the innocent pilgrims to leave before the battle commenced or better still curtailed his ego and surrendered to the army.

All the bloodshed and carnage could have been avoided.

What makes you think Bhindranewale had any say on who entered or left the Harmandir Sahib complex ? He wasn't controlling who entered and who left, he wasn't forcefulky holding anyone in the complex.

This was a delibrately timed attack by the Indian government at a time when they knew the complex would be full of pilgrims so that they could inflict maximum casulties to teach Sikhs a lesson and gain popularity at the votes at the next election for Indira Gandhi by falsely labelling a minority as terrorists.

It was the Indian army that didn't allow pilgrims to leave the complex and murdered hundreds of innocent men,women and children.

[Mehtab Singh]

Please run a search on YouTube videos of Dr. Udhoke explaining clearly the Sikh philosophy behind warfare, and also every reason why Sant Jee did what he did, and did it all exactly based on the Sikh warfare philosophy of our Shaheed Singhs.

[lsingh]

Let's go back to the root cause. What if Indira and her group had been a honest and wanted the development of all citizens instead of coming up with barbaric genocidal policies against the Sikhs. Most Indians also say she was a corrupt ruler. None of the bloodshed would have happened.

[S1ngh]

Imagine if J.S.Bhindranwale had allowed the innocent pilgrims to leave before the battle commenced or better still curtailed his ego and surrendered to the army.

All the bloodshed and carnage could have been avoided.

Genuinely brother, there are two types of person who can write above. 1. You have absolutely have no knowledge on what happened there in Amritsar and relies on biased news and fabricated history fed by mahan Bharat. OR 2. You know exactly what happened there but are doing nothing but a troll

[dashmesh1984]

ignore that troll aj111 look at his post history he is clearly anti sikh

[BobbyMann75]

In reply to AJ as quote doesn't show,

You really have swallowed probably the most ridiculous query churned out by the Indian propaganda merchants.

Do you really think they wouldn't have attacked if Bhindranwale wasn't inside, when they had been planning the attack for 18 months, even constructing a replica Harmandir Sahib.

Bhindranwale was the bait, the attack wasn't to eliminate ''Terrorists'', if Sant Ji was a terrorist simply for being pro-Sikh rights, then I and millions of others are as well.

The attack was to strike a blow directly at the heart of every Sikh living in the fascist Hindutva Empire called India.

Watch Rajoana TV, Buy ''Dioalogue with millitants'' etc.

Don't swallow lies and think because the Indian GOVT/Military are saying it, that its true, they are only comprised of people, and people lie, and people will hurt people to get their way, They would gladly kill every Sikh In Punjab if it meant keeping Punjab as part of India.

Thank God we had brave Shaheeds like Sant Ji and Subeg Singh, ask yourself why General Subeg Singh who put his life on the line for India many times, why did he join the Sikh freedom movement ?