Jump to content
Sign in to follow this  
sikhiseeker

A Woman As A Panch Pyara?

Recommended Posts

Seva is a route to cleansing the genderless soul of its previous Karam through service of other people and honest causes.

Mata sahib kaur added the sweet pataashe to the holy nectar while Shiri Guru Gobind Singh stirred the shakti of Akal Purakh within the nectar creating the stainless khalsa, my mother also drank the nectar and became khalsa. What is the difference of gender in khalsa, maybe we should of explained that to dhan dhan Mai bhago, that as sikhs,men and women have their set roles as per gristi, so carry on making the rotia? I don't think so sikhi, As rightly said, Mai bhago stayed in the company of Shiri kalgidhar mahraj, as khalsa!

LoL. So ?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Wajinder Singh ji, is there any written hukam that a female khalsa is still not equal enough in comparison to a male khalsa and cannot do amrit sanchar or represent a panj pyara? Or is it us still as males, that we cannot disassociate ourselves with our ahankar of being a male in a male dominant world, where we have lost the understanding of a genderless atma and attach gender on the courageous act of the original panj pyare setting the 5 characteristics of the genderless khalsa of Shiri Guru Gobind Singh, created to instill courage and grant mukhti to the atma, to become sant saphae!

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Wajinder Singh ji, is there any written hukam that a female khalsa is still not equal enough in comparison to a male khalsa and cannot do amrit sanchar or represent a panj pyara? Or is it us still as males, that we cannot disassociate ourselves with our ahankar of being a male in a male dominant world, where we have lost the understanding of a genderless atma and attach gender on the courageous act of the original panj pyare setting the 5 characteristics of the genderless khalsa of Shiri Guru Gobind Singh, created to instill courage and grant mukhti to the atma, to become sant saphae!

next you will ask why were the 10 Gurus male and none of them women! Where does this end??

The truth is that 5 Male passed the test the Guru gave...

Sikhiseeker, you will not get anywhere by arguing why this why that. There are other things we can use our energy like Naam Simran, Amrit Vela, Reading Gurbani, listening kirtan and doing Sangat at the Guru...

and doing seva of course

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

next you will ask why were the 10 Gurus male and none of them women! Where does this end??

The truth is that 5 Male passed the test the Guru gave...

Sikhiseeker, you will not get anywhere by arguing why this why that. There are other things we can use our energy like Naam Simran, Amrit Vela, Reading Gurbani, listening kirtan and doing Sangat at the Guru...

and doing seva of course

Dear brother,

I have not asked why the gurus were all male. This has no relevance to our previous posts to one another. Our debate, not argument is based on women becoming a panj pyara for nagar kirtans. As you asked me a question on the definition of seva, I answered, I asked you a question as you sound to be a intellectual Sikh if there is any written hukam from the guru or one of the scholars that a female who has been initiated into the Khalsa Panth cannot serve as a panch pyara, you never answered yet you are adamant that they cant? You put emphasis on gender, but gender in this life is irrelevant. We all have the same purpose of remerging with Akal purakh waheguru as by the Sikh path, mukhti is granted once the Khalsa is adopted and followed. The original panj pyare set the character of what the Khalsa represents. We all strive to follow that character, male and female alike. If male and female have the same Amrit sanchar, drink the same holy nectar through the same sarbloh, have the same initiation and told to recite the same words, then are gifted with the same panj kakkar and are instructed to live life as per the same gurmat, where is gender actually mentioned my brother?

Again is it our own ahankar of being male in a male dominant world, as our Guru never stopped our mothers and sisters fighting on a battlefield with men, the Amrit is for the atma of a human. What "other" seva would you permit our grandmother mata gujri to do? How was the shaheedi any less or anymore from bhai mati das to that of bibi charan kaur? None rite, so why shouldn't a female who is pure guru roop Khalsa not have the opportunity to serve as a panj pyara.

The word Khalsa derives from a Arabic word Khaal-saa which means pure and free, it is us who don't understand the equality what the guru set. Someone also on this topic asked me how far does my equality go, my answer is 100 % because we do not understand the meaning of atma, we only understand our physical roop. Look at the term sant siphae, it is you Mann what becomes shaanth and your soul becomes sant, your body becomes siphae? Does this transformation have Gender in its essence?

Also thank you for the suggestions on how I can spend my time, I am trying to advance my spiritual growth via the paths you kindly mentioned, also I'm trying to understand the gian, within the gian to further understand the limitless actions of our Gurus, our Shaheed and the granths and obviously the Shiri Guru Granth Sahib itself.

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Dear brother,

I have not asked why the gurus were all male. This has no relevance to our previous posts to one another. Our debate, not argument is based on women becoming a panj pyara for nagar kirtans. As you asked me a question on the definition of seva, I answered, I asked you a question as you sound to be a intellectual Sikh if there is any written hukam from the guru or one of the scholars that a female who has been initiated into the Khalsa Panth cannot serve as a panch pyara, you never answered yet you are adamant that they cant? You put emphasis on gender, but gender in this life is irrelevant. We all have the same purpose of remerging with Akal purakh waheguru as by the Sikh path, mukhti is granted once the Khalsa is adopted and followed. The original panj pyare set the character of what the Khalsa represents. We all strive to follow that character, male and female alike. If male and female have the same Amrit sanchar, drink the same holy nectar through the same sarbloh, have the same initiation and told to recite the same words, then are gifted with the same panj kakkar and are instructed to live life as per the same gurmat, where is gender actually mentioned my brother?

Again is it our own ahankar of being male in a male dominant world, as our Guru never stopped our mothers and sisters fighting on a battlefield with men, the Amrit is for the atma of a human. What "other" seva would you permit our grandmother mata gujri to do? How was the shaheedi any less or anymore from bhai mati das to that of bibi charan kaur? None rite, so why shouldn't a female who is pure guru roop Khalsa not have the opportunity to serve as a panj pyara.

The word Khalsa derives from a Arabic word Khaal-saa which means pure and free, it is us who don't understand the equality what the guru set. Someone also on this topic asked me how far does my equality go, my answer is 100 % because we do not understand the meaning of atma, we only understand our physical roop. Look at the term sant siphae, it is you Mann what becomes shaanth and your soul becomes sant, your body becomes siphae? Does this transformation have Gender in its essence?

Also thank you for the suggestions on how I can spend my time, I am trying to advance my spiritual growth via the paths you kindly mentioned, also I'm trying to understand the gian, within the gian to further understand the limitless actions of our Gurus, our Shaheed and the granths and obviously the Shiri Guru Granth Sahib itself.

Q. Can there be a woman in Panj pyare

A. No

Q. Reason.

A. Because as from Guru Nanak Dev ji a test was given to the Sangat, one Sikh (male) passed during that time- Bhai Leina ji or Guru Angad Dev ji.

In the case of Sri Guru Gobind Singh ji's test - 5 Sikhs (again male) passed. There were women in the congregation but none of them stood up. Guru ji asked a head of a Sikh not a 'man'.

So from that day (April 1699), 5 Nitnemi Amrtidhari Singh( baptised male Sikh) take part in the Amrit Sanchar in the form of Panj Pyare. As to Rehit nama - they are for the code of conduct of a Sikh as to how to lead the life as per the hukam - which is not as a Panj pyara. Did Guru ji advise or give HUKAM to a Sikh to be a Panj pyara once in their life?

What they did advice, is what I wrote above in the previous post.

Do you want to accept it is as an answer? If no, Its your choice.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
Sign in to follow this  



  • Topics

  • Posts

    • I hv it downloaded I can send u via whatsapp. message me ur no.
    • Anyone have this not on scribd?
    • It goes both ways. If you hear the Islamic narrative they also prob up Islamic invaders and rulers as benign. You should hear what they say about an invader like Muhammad Bin Qaasim who is hailed as a hero and who they claim just came to save a few Muslim women while the defender Raja Dahir is portrayed as an evil scheming, degenerate pervert. But historic Muslim sources like the Chachnama convey a different story and testify how the invading Muslim Arabs had taken thousands of Hindu Sindhi women back with them.    Or look at how they view Aurangzeb. They shamelessly justify his hate  and war crimes against the Hindus and Sikhs. Many even call him a Wali of Allah or a great saint much like how the Buddhists view King Ashok. He is universally respected by Sunni Muslims. He is basically the main reason why most Punjabi and Mirpuri Rajputs and Jatts are Muslims in Pakistan today.   The Hindu and Muslim grand narratives are very different. The Sikh grand narrative can best be read at the starting of Bhangu's Panth Prakash. Bhangu very elaborately explains the condition of India before Guru Nanak Dev ji took avtar and then what followed and how Sikhs got raaj by Vaheguru
    • see doing stuff like that is just stupid! but then again you cnt expect anything else from india.  marathas were deafed by afghans    but eventually without a doubt they took over india and made it into a hindu state again      iv heard that captain amrinder wanted to remove sikh ithiaas from punjab txt books? 
    • i really liked this movie    the last scene gave me goosbumps!        i wanna watch ajay devgans tanhaji next   
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

Terms of Use