Jump to content

Taking Amrit

Guest GK

By Guest GK,
in GUPT FORUM

 Share

Recommended Posts

sikhiseeker Grand Master

sikhiseeker

Posted
Posted

WJKK WJKF

IMHO, you will touch meat every day of your life. You yourself are simply meat. A sikhs life is within gristi. We are not vaishnav. Are you going to refrain from learning the tabla as it's made from goat skin? Are you gona stop purchasing animal by-products like leather?

Living beings are everywhere and everything is living. Also congrats for when you accept amrit.

WJKK WJKF

1
Link to comment
Share on other sites
Guest Guest

Guest Guest

Posted
Posted

To disagree with the above, no you should not, because selling people meat (the product of murder of neglected animals) is not really proper Kirt Kamai. Could you imagine giving Dasvandh to the Panth of earnings made in this way?

0
Link to comment
Share on other sites
sikhiseeker Grand Master

sikhiseeker

Posted
Posted

To disagree with the above, no you should not, because selling people meat (the product of murder of neglected animals) is not really proper Kirt Kamai. Could you imagine giving Dasvandh to the Panth of earnings made in this way?

WJKK WJKF

When Shiri guru nanak dev ji pressed the roti earned from honest/dishonest earnings blood and milk poured out. Blood from out a roti?

Also how do you then justify beating a tabla brought from sangat money to the shabad of gurbani. Is the skin of goats used for our musical instruments any different to the goats meat? Do you think it's justified for those goats to be killed for the production of our musical instruments, aslong as us sikhs dont do the killing and the bad Karam goes on to the killer?

WJKK WJKF

1
Link to comment
Share on other sites
Deletedkp Mentor

Deletedkp

Posted
Posted

WJKK WJKF

When Shiri guru nanak dev ji pressed the roti earned from honest/dishonest earnings blood and milk poured out. Blood from out a roti?

Also how do you then justify beating a tabla brought from sangat money to the shabad of gurbani. Is the skin of goats used for our musical instruments any different to the goats meat? Do you think it's justified for those goats to be killed for the production of our musical instruments, aslong as us sikhs dont do the killing and the bad Karam goes on to the killer?

WJKK WJKF

So, If SIkhs don't do the killing then its justified. How is that justified? Let someone else do the dirty work on your behalf and then reap the rewards.

To the original poster, if you need to work and pay the bills then this what you have to do. In our current climate, It very difficult to find jobs.

My grandfather was an Amritdhari and worked at our local butchers because that was the only job he could find at the time.

0
Link to comment
Share on other sites
sikhiseeker Grand Master

sikhiseeker

Posted
Posted

So, If SIkhs don't do the killing then its justified. How is that justified? Let someone else do the dirty work on your behalf and then reap the rewards.

To the original poster, if you need to work and pay the bills then this what you have to do. In our current climate, It very difficult to find jobs.

My grandfather was an Amritdhari and worked at our local butchers because that was the only job he could find at the time.

WJKK WJKF

I agree with your statement about your grandfather, however I think you have misunderstood my point above about the justification of killing. I meant it as a question to the sikh I posted it to in exactly the way you just wrote back to me lol.

WJKK WJKF

0
Link to comment
Share on other sites
Deletedkp Mentor

Deletedkp

Posted
Posted

WJKK WJKF

I agree with your statement about your grandfather, however I think you have misunderstood my point above about the justification of killing. I meant it as a question to the sikh I posted it to in exactly the way you just wrote back to me lol.

WJKK WJKF

I apologise, I have misunderstood lol :stupidme: . Yeah, It's a very good question and no one has answered it.

0
Link to comment
Share on other sites
Guest amritdhaari singh

Guest amritdhaari singh

Posted
Posted

No offence to anyone but can't believe some of the responses on here.

Of course its not OK to be handling meat like that once you're amritdhaari. Once you take amrit you become one of the fauj. Could you imagine Guroo Gobind Singh Sahib or a Sahibzada working in that kind of environment.

As for your grandfather, no offence, but that it awful. An amritdhaari working as a butcher. Dhan Vaheguroo.

If still unsure please take a hukamnama.

0
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
×
 Share
Go to topic listing
  • advertisement_alt
  • advertisement_alt
  • advertisement_alt


  • Topics

  • Posts

    • Singh1989
      Sant Kartar Bhindrawale on Raags

      By Singh1989 · Posted

      Was listening to Sant Ji's katha on youtube.  Sant ji stated apart from the traditional raags, there is nothing wrong if Kirtan is sung in other NON - Raags set up by our Guru Ji's.  His example: Think of poison in a bowl.  Drinking the poison then blaming the bowl is silly. The poison is bad not the bowl. Likewise, we will never call a bowl Amrit once it contains Amrit init. Sameway it's not the raags being good / bad... it's WHAT we put into those raags. How many times Kirtan was sung but on a track of sum Bollywood tune? It is happening in Gurudwara by Raagis! Youtube also has Kaweshri jatha singing history of 1984, on Dr Dre's - Still Dre track.  Rap instrumental/ Bolly tunes stand neutral. We can either put bad things and sing with our own remixes and lyrics... or we can recreate to sing Shabads of Gurbabi, kirtan and Sikh Prachaar over them. 
    • MokhamSingh
      Who is Ragunath in gurbani

      By MokhamSingh · Posted

      Everything in Gurbani points us towards the Atma. Atma and Parmatma are the same… Atama and Parmatma is the source that creates and causes everything… What have the following items got in common? A fan. A television. A fridge. A radio. A computer..? These things are powered by electricity. Without electricity these things are lifeless. It’s the electricity that causes these things to function… Atma is the source of energy that allows everything to happen.    without Atma, we are lifeless… Call this Atama RAGUNATH…call this Atma by any other name…the fact remains that it’s the life force energy… Dieties also have the same Atma as humans, but they still part of the creation, and not the creator…  
    • Pallav2015
      Who is Ragunath in gurbani

      By Pallav2015 · Posted

      Hi I want to know who’s ragunath in gurbani Hindu claim this word appear for ram chandra if we read guru teg bahadur maharaj salok maharaj clearly rejecting ram gayo ravan geo but at the last pangti Kahu naanak īh bipaṭi mai tek ēyk ragɦunaaṭɦ ॥55॥ Says Nanak, in this calamity, the Lord alone is my support who is this ragunaath why would maharaj use ragunath as refrence for god?
    • realist17
      The Show Must Go On....

      By realist17 · Posted

      Throughout history we have been tested and tried. We remained steadfast and resiliant. The events that took place in Punjab and outside of Punjab in the past years made it quite clear we are big players in the game which kept the world powers on edge. It started off with the drug pandemic in Punjab, to the uproar by Bhai Amritpal Singh to the Farmer's protest. Outside of Punjab the deaths of Avtar Singh Khanda (UK) and Hardeep Singh Nijjar (Canada) created a stir within our community. This was probably our first real opportunity to establish something but how quickly members of our own community forget history. We have been a threat to civilization in the past and this is probably what the world powers are concerned about. However, may we continue grow and learn through Gurbani and like Jaswant Singh Khalra said: 'May the spirit of equal rights Punjab continue to kindle'. 
    • dharamyudh
      I Have Had Pre-Maritial Sex, Help!

      By dharamyudh · Posted

      This is why people used to get married earlier in puratan times. Think about it, nowadays you legit have to be brahmacharya at ages when you're supposed to be married and producing children, which historically speaking, is unprecedented outside of the Sants in Indic tradition. 
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

Terms of Use

  I accept