Should General Brar Be Charged With Crimes Against Humanity

[joker]

During the attack on the golden temple, civillians and surrendered prisoners were summararily executed with bullets and grenades.There are many witnesses to these atrocities, so why has no sikh organisation tried to prosecute General Brar in the west.General Brar waltzes around the west as a hero.But little do they know he was a blood thirsty army commander.

On a side issue, if people want to know how RAW(research and analysis Wing) agents behave, read their books on indian intelligence involvement in the creation of Bangledesh.Raw used the tactics in Punjab.Surjit singh , raw agent , was caught planting bombs in pakistan during the 1990s. If Surjit was stirring up communal trouble in Pakistan . What were other Raw agents doing in Punjab.

If James Bond has a licence to kill, Raw agent agents have a licence to massacre

[Sikhistan]

before we do that why not first take out who actually helped these forces to come in (sgpc, akali etc).

[Nalwa]

Yes Brar should be charged just not him all army men who participated in it should be charged and what about KPS Gill why we dont talk about him ? Every second day we hear Punjab police officers charge for fake encounters but why not gill ? On other he is given new jobs as adviser in other states . Do we dont enough evidence to take him to court .

[cool water]

Not just brar but all those who took part in the attack on sri harmandir sahib.

Chiefly responsible is RAW research and analysis wing agents and heads. They supplied the false intelligence to the indian govt for the army to launch their attack, they spearheaded attacks against innocent punjabis to create the false pretext and narrative that Sant Bhindranwale's Sikhs were killing hindus when in fact it was the Indian state killing hindus and sikhs (indiscriminate police firing and killing peaceful sikh protests, narankari-ajk clash 1978 13 sikhs killed, hit and run attacks against hindu punjabis and low caste hindu migrants by RAW terrorist agents) alike to create a situation for the state to use its massive war machinery against a totally ill prepared and unexpecting innocent punjabi Sikh community.

Also responsible for war crimes is those who supplied the Indian govt with military plans to attack Sikhs (ie USSR soviets,UK tory thatcher govt and Israeli govt)

[chatanga]

most definitely.

[guruvah]

Forget charges...

The fact this maggot has still not been killed is a big stain on the dignity of the Panth.

look at his audacity in media nowadays, where he can be seen as blatantly lying and spread "positive" propaganda of the Satanic indian Army attack in 1984.

[Deletedkp]

Why should this General be charged, they were taking orders from their superiors. As you do, if you are in the army.

[chatanga]

Why should this General be charged, they were taking orders from their superiors. As you do, if you are in the army.

the shooting of civilians/non-combatants could still have been avoided, by the general. the witch was in delhi, and she's dead now, so thats a dead end.

[singh135]

Why should this General be charged, they were taking orders from their superiors. As you do, if you are in the army.

That logic is widely considered to be quite retarded following the 1940s Nuremberg trials.

[Ranjeet01]

Why should this General be charged, they were taking orders from their superiors. As you do, if you are in the army.

Kphull

How come General Sinha disagreed with the attack, he chose not to follow orders.

What about Jallianbagh massacre, were the troops not following orders?