Trying To Organise A Debate: Katy Sian Vs Sas

[Guptsingh95]

Hi folks,

I have just been looking at this book by Katy Sian " Unsettling Sikh and Muslim Conflict: Mistaken Identities, "Forced" Conversions, and Postcolonial Formations". I understand that there has already been a discussion on this topic - http://www.sikhsangat.com/index.php?/topic/72489-pro-muslim-book-against-sikhs-being-published/

I am currently trying to organise a debate between Bhai Mohan Singh from the Sikh Awareness Society and her - which could perhaps be recoreded and put up on YouTube or the Sikh Channel.

I have just been looking at her twitter https://twitter.com/theculturecraft and she appears to have a very pro muslim agenda. If people of this forum could perhaps tweet to her - challenging her narrative - or promoting a debate - then that would be great.

Regards

[proactive]

That should be an interesting debate. Bhai Mohan Singh talking from experience and Katy Sian talking out of her backside. Bhai Mohan Singh talking the language of the common man and Katy Sian talking the language of out of touch left wing pseudo-intellectuals. Like I said should be a good debate.

[superkaur]

Hi folks,

I have just been looking at this book by Katy Sian " Unsettling Sikh and Muslim Conflict: Mistaken Identities, "Forced" Conversions, and Postcolonial Formations". I understand that there has already been a discussion on this topic - http://www.sikhsangat.com/index.php?/topic/72489-pro-muslim-book-against-sikhs-being-published/

I am currently trying to organise a debate between Bhai Mohan Singh from the Sikh Awareness Society and her - which could perhaps be recoreded and put up on YouTube or the Sikh Channel.

I have just been looking at her twitter https://twitter.com/theculturecraft and she appears to have a very pro muslim agenda. If people of this forum could perhaps tweet to her - challenging her narrative - or promoting a debate - then that would be great.

Regards

Shes been allegedly been having relationships with muslim guys while at university who brainwashed her with Palestine and pro-islamic nonsense. She calls herself a sikh but her name, her tweets, her book, her whole agenda and antics suggests otherwise. She has said nothing pro-sikh in her whole set up, she has no clue about grooming cases regarding muslim rape gangs that been caught few months back. The numbers of muslims caught grooming non-muslim girls for sexual exploitations is in the thousands....we need to ask ourselves why is it always or mostly the muslim males that are involved in this?

Why dont we see hindu rape gangs, sikh rape gangs, christian rape gangs, atheist rape gangs, buddhist rape gangs? Its always the muslims clubbing together and sexually exploiting their kafir girl victim for either love jihad or rape jihad or conversion jihad either way it a jihad against the kufr.

Katy sian would probably back out of the debate she is a politically correct liberal pro-islamo-fascist apologist and might aswell wear the burka over her head. She ignores the cases of countless Sikh female victims of islam... which are probably in their hundreds if we add them up from all the years this has been going on since the 1980s.

[Guptsingh95]

Does anyone know how I can get in touch with Bhai Mohan Singh or any respectable SAS member who would be willing to participate in this debate?

I can help decide on a venue. If she backs down from a debate then we shouldn't worry - after all we can brand it as our victory.

Please remember to tweet to her - https://twitter.com/theculturecraft so we can make this debate happen.

[Guptsingh95]

She's tweeting so much about this Palestine conflict - not once has she said anything about the minorities who are suffering under the caliphate. Islamist buffoon.

[superkaur]

She's tweeting so much about this Palestine conflict - not once has she said anything about the minorities who are suffering under the caliphate. Islamist buffoon.

Its sickening its like the jews out of fear or ignorance who were cheering hitler on not knowing hitlers real agenda of their extermination. Similarly we have these fools like katy sain and other islamo-fascist-apologists who cheer on islam and muslim causes because its trendy to jump on an oxymoronic leftist extremist siding with right wing pro-Islam-fascist bandwagon.

What about the Sikh's plight in afghanistan under persecution from muslim zealots? Surely thats a leftest cause, a human rights cause? A tweet about them would be nice to hear about katy you bafoon, what about countless Sikhs who were murdered by the Indian state in 1980s? not 1 word but slience from the .... what about Sikhs fighting for their right of self determination of Khalistan.... Katy sain claiming to be a Sikh seems to be silent on her own religious community#s freedom struggle.

Has she got some mental illness or something that she cant see the victims of islamo-facism? Does she not feel it her duty to look into Sikh history and see how Sikh women resisted Islamic tyranny paying a very heavy price..... no because sleeping around with non-sikh guys is more important to these witches than standing up for your own faith community.

http://www.jihadwatch.org/2014/01/highest-sikh-authority-expresses-concern-about-muslims-wooing-sikh-girls-to-use-them-in-jihadi-efforts

http://sikheducation.blogspot.co.uk/2010/07/love-jihad-or-reproductive-jihad-call.html

[Guptsingh95]

I sent a few tweets to her - and I got blocked straight away. I did not insult her - all I did was ask her for a debate. If you have any theory or a hypothesis - you should allow it to be challenged, so I really do not understand why she's backing away from it. If she is so confident in her theory - she should have actually take the initiative to have dialogue with SAS, as opposed to delivering lectures at Islamic book stores.

I would still encourage forum members to write and or tweet to her at twitter.com/theculturecraft

Regards

[13Mirch]

Shes going to vilify any debate as being anti-Islamic and you know it.

[Sewadar]

Sent the tweet.

[13Mirch]

Sent the tweet.

image.jpg

This will probably be an excuse for some individuals to try highlighting the so called right wing sympathies in Sikhi.