The Best & Easy Japji Sahib Santhiya | Vyakaran | Grammer

[baljinder_s]

The best & easy Japji Sahib Santhiya/Viakhya by Giani Sahib Singh Ji & Prof. Maninderpal Singh ji.

Link to the playlist(all parts):

http://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLwakOQS9VUsYaGV1JgDrGMb87-u_Cd5Jp

[ssinghuk]

If you scroll down the list of the videos posted by "Sikh Wisdom", who have uploaded this Japji Sahib "Viakhiaa" you'll notice videos of Sarabjit Dunda have been uploaded as well. I've not listened to this "best and easy" series but already I'm concerned that this set of videos could support Mr Dunda's heretical views.

So please be warned before watching them.

[savinderpalsingh]

gurbani is not dependent on viakran , viakran is dependent on gurubani , viakran was made from gurubani

Sant jarnail singh ji

[jasvendrasingh]

Should we suppose that Grammer didnot exist before Sri Guru Nanak DevJi?

[savinderpalsingh]

to answer that, i would say "who created gurmukhi"

your answer lays in that questions answer

[JSINGHANANDPUR]

Saviderpalsingh , please come to sense , please differentiate between Language & script , kyoon , ustoon pehle punjab de lok koi boli nahi see boldey ? I see you always get personal very easily , before responding please always have a relook at your response

[savinderpalsingh]

Saviderpalsingh , please come to sense , please differentiate between Language & script , kyoon , ustoon pehle punjab de lok koi boli nahi see boldey ? I see you always get personal very easily , before responding please always have a relook at your response

i am in senses , its only logical Guru Angad dev ji, the second Sikh Master, invented the Gurmukhi script.Guru Nanak dev ji named Guru Angad dev ji to succeed him as the Guru for the Sikhs in 1539. Gurmukhi means “from the mouth of the Guru.”

people spoke hindi , arabi and other languages mixed punjabi is gurmukhi , and no it wasnt spoken before

pick up work from previous puratan singhs and it contains mixture of hindi and gurmukhi

it prooves that before them only hindi was spoken,

even sant jarnail singh ji has told in katha that

viakran is dependent and came from gurbani

not the other way around !!

[JSINGHANANDPUR]

I feel you have not read Baba Farid JI, and his language

[savinderpalsingh]

it is also possible guru wrote , baba farid ji's bani with gurmukhi dialect

as i said, taksal belives it and sant jarnail ji also did
so do i that viakran came after gurmukhi ,

[baljinder_s]

If you scroll down the list of the videos posted by "Sikh Wisdom", who have uploaded this Japji Sahib "Viakhiaa" you'll notice videos of Sarabjit Dunda have been uploaded as well. I've not listened to this "best and easy" series but already I'm concerned that this set of videos could support Mr Dunda's heretical views.

So please be warned before watching them.

Khalsa Ji, I don't know why some people are bothered by Sarbjit Singh Dhunda. The only reason I can see is, that the one who criticizes Dhunda are the ones who are trapped in Dera Culture.

WHATEVER BHAI SARBJIT SINGH TALKS, HE TALKS & PREACHES IN THE LIGHT OF GURU GRANTH SAHIB JI.

You can question Sarbjit Singh, but can you also question Guru Granth Sahib Ji?