Nanak Shah Fakir Needs To Be Banned

[GurburAkal]

Whats wrong with that?

Unless it is like a documentary style show, then it wouldn't be right to display our Gurus with any actors like they do in some other shows with other religions

[hsingh8963]

Unless it is like a documentary style show, then it wouldn't be right to display our Gurus with any actors like they do in some other shows with other religions

NO good to display Gurus with actors in any type of film.

[jkvlondon]

One wonders where exactly does someone like Sikka get 35 crores to invest in this movie , plus Modi seems to have been very helpful too ... the English translations of shabads are off in trailers and posters , the visualisation of gagan mein thaal has made it into a happy clappy outdoors aarti party for hindus... so sad

[MisterrSingh]

One wonders where exactly does someone like Sikka get 35 crores to invest in this movie , plus Modi seems to have been very helpful too ... the English translations of shabads are off in trailers and posters , the visualisation of gagan mein thaal has made it into a happy clappy outdoors aarti party for hindus... so sad

Hmmm. Sounds a bit fishy.

[hsingh8963]

2 month hold on movie has been made in PUNJAB...

It's not enough of course...

[jkvlondon]

is it just me or does this seem like a twisting of the message ?

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fL6HyZR0DsA

[hsingh8963]

Check out the movies Facebook page... The film is completely against sikhi.

[hsingh8963]

Yeah sad to see so much support from Sikhs...

[jkvlondon]

Yeah sad to see so much support from Sikhs...

they know nothing about sikhi , they have been arguing that everyone has photos of Guru ji so what's the difference , when I point out that no-one can draw down the true Guru and capture his essence in even the slightest way they just don't get it and they started cussing me down as a stupid woman , wow Sikho what good students you are..LOL

[Jonny101]

No idea.. are they trying to show that at Sri Jagganath they do they same aarti? Because I don't think they do the same aarti as us.

as the sakhis go, Sri Guru Nanak Dev Jee uttered the famous Shabad when he went to Jaganath puri. There the Hindus were doing aarti in front of moortis using their thaal with the Divaa and all the stuff they put in the thaal. Then Guru jee began singing the shabad Gagan Mai Thaal ...and showed them that the real aarti of God is happening in his creation/nature.

they know nothing about sikhi , they have been arguing that everyone has photos of Guru ji so what's the difference , when I point out that no-one can draw down the true Guru and capture his essence in even the slightest way they just don't get it and they started cussing me down as a stupid woman , wow Sikho what good students you are..LOL

The worst thing is, they call those who disagree with them as 'extremists'. Recently went to India and talked to many people there on this issue(mostly Monas) and not one Mona I have seen that is supportive of this movie because they showed Guru Sahib in motion/moving which goes against our traditional respect for Guru Jee. Now will they start calling the Monas as 'extremists' as well?

Right now they are not showing Guru Jee but it's just a matter of time before they show actors playing Guru Jee. The thing is, the film industry in India is taking baby steps towards that direction. This movie may not seem that bad to some Sikhs who are defending it. Right now they are doing small things like showing Guru Jee from the back. Then they will show the sides, then finally in future they will show the front and face and even an actor playing the role of Guru Jee. We may think this is unthinkable but that is where this is going.