Quran Found Before Prophets Time

[singh598]

The FACT is that the prophet stole something belonging to another and aothorizided it as the holy grail

Ha ha

That's why Sri Guru Granth Sahib says satgur Nina hor kachee he bani

[Guest Jacfsing2]

The FACT is that the prophet stole something belonging to another and aothorizided it as the holy grail

Ha ha

That's why Sri Guru Granth Sahib says satgur Nina hor kachee he bani

Gurbani is true, but just because something was found before actually being published doesn't make it false, not siding with them but even Muhammad said that Gabriel gave him the Qur'an he never claimed to make it himself.

[CanadianSingh]

So if the quran was before Muhammed, does that mean that Islam is a fake religion? Or what?

[Balkaar]

So if the quran was before Muhammed, does that mean that Islam is a fake religion?

That hasn't been proven yet.

Muhammad said that Gabriel gave him the Qur'an he never claimed to make it himself.

Him saying that proves nothing. He quite obviously issued his 'revelations' in order to advance his material objectives. It's no coincidence that his Surahs acquired such a bloody flavour when he became the conquering warlord of Medinah.

[Akalifauj]

How can a illiterate man steal something he doesn't understand. Muhammad would have trusted someone to read the koran for him. Without this there is no way he would have stole the Koran. Muhammad would have too put complete faith in the Koran without even knowing what is written in it. Would he be this wreckles before his master plan to start a violent and oppressive religion?

This idea seems far fetched and not very well thoughtout before presenting it. Since most of the world hate Islam. People will accept it without really thinking about it.

[Kira]

That hasn't been proven yet.

Him saying that proves nothing. He quite obviously issued his 'revelations' in order to advance his material objectives. It's no coincidence that his Surahs acquired such a bloody flavour when he became the conquering warlord of Medinah.

From what I know Muhammed only met Gabriel twice in person. afterwards it was what would appear in his mind, either Gabriel was whispering to him or God, one of those. Which I can't remember. The Quran was simply recited and memorized for years but it wouldn't be a stretch to assume that some devout follower of the Prophet might have written it down.

The problem with the recitation theory is that it would make changes less distinguishable. However I'll give kudos to whoever complied it afterwards. That task alone doesn't sound easy.

[StarStriker]

The amount of scientific mishaps and inaccuracies, its no doubt quran was NOT written by any enlightened soul, but by charlatans. Ive heard before that afta muhammeds death, there were 11 different versions of the quran were written. Also the fact that they dont even believe in the basic blatant n correct notion of reincarnation, in itself proves all u need to know.

Unlike other prophets of other religions, and especially our gurus, muhammed NEVER had direct contact with god, only mettings with gabriel the angel.

[Kira]

The amount of scientific mishaps and inaccuracies, its no doubt quran was NOT written by any enlightened soul, but by charlatans. Ive heard before that afta muhammeds death, there were 11 different versions of the quran were written. Also the fact that they dont even believe in the basic blatant n correct notion of reincarnation, in itself proves all u need to know.

Unlike other prophets of other religions, and especially our gurus, muhammed NEVER had direct contact with god, only mettings with gabriel the angel.

Bro you should listen to some of stuff Zakir Naik talks about. With all respect to him for preaching his religion his methods of justifying the scientific inaccuracies are worth a chuckle or 2.

[StarStriker]

Bro you should listen to some of stuff Zakir Naik talks about. With all respect to him for preaching his religion his methods of justifying the scientific inaccuracies are worth a chuckle or 2.

Mate hes the no.1 comedian going, absolute joker of a preacher.

[CanadianSingh]

Zakir Naik bashes other religions man. He mocks other religions for no reason.