Why Guru Sahibaan's Had Multiple Wives, Truth Or Made Up Stories !

[simran345]

See this is what I am saying, that children vardhans are given and will continue to be given if a GurSikh asks.

Only within Gods Will, hukam.

[Kira]

So basically now Our Resident brahmgyani here claims to know what our Guru Sahib did and the sort of relationship they had with their Wives. There's no evidence to substantiate any of her claims, other than the fact that what she claims must be true because she is infallible. KAAM is obsession with sex or anything. Sex isn't "evil", children aren't conceived due to "evil/sin" it's a natural biological process, in fact arousal can occur without lustful thoughts, there's plenty of scientific research on this, not that it means anything to her as It's all "false" since it conflicts with her twisted version of stories. The amount of sin in sex is the same as going to the toilet.

ON topic.

There's way too speculation about how many wives certain Guru Sahib had, Historical dates and names being mixed up are a massive cause of this. I did remember seeing an old extract from a book from the 1700s, just a couple of decades after Guru Sahib's departure, the mention was of Mata Sahib Kaur and Mata Sundri Ji, no mention of Mata Jito Ji. Though the text did get the date of Guru Gobind Singh Ji's departure as being incorrect so you could cast doubts on that.

Even Macleod mentioned that Mata jito/Mata Sundri may have been the same thing. The fact remains there's too much distortion going on, Guru Gobind Singh Ji was extremely popular with non-sikhs along with Sikhs. His opposition could easily have tried to tamper and try to shed negative light on his character

[Sikhvibes.com]

Tampering with our rich SIKH history did not just happen during our gurus times but up until this day TODAY and will continue to happen.

Our historical texts, documented scripts are all being destroyed, youth are being manipulated, MULTIPLE HISTORICAL texts are being created to cause confusion within the panth.

THINK EVERYONE.... if you read this discussion thread from the beginning, one has said 1 wife, other has said 3 wives, next has said 5... what next 7? Or will we eventually wrongfully declare in the near future that Guru Nanak Dev Jee had multiple wives with kids?!?


Our history has been tampered with since the days of the mughals to this present day!

[Guest Teri Chachi]

Reply to OP,

Singhbj

Let's say for arguments sake that Dasmesh Pita had more than one wife.... the Guru is perfect, why question their actions, decisions?

The Guru's are not like us Moorkhs, subject to Kaam, Krod, Lob, Moh and Hunkar, so they didn't marry out of Lust.

The Guru's, I understand, married more than 1 wife out of a. Seva (to the Panth, and Humanity) and b. out of Daya (compassion) marrying more than one wife out of compassion. For normal Sikh isn't not allowed (as a rule of thumb) But the Gurus? Come on mate, their God themselves!!! Everything they did was perfect / pure, complete.

My 2 cents. All the best.

[Guest mughals+pandits]

Mughals and Pandits made up the multiple wives stories.

Edit Niddar Nangs and Dear Jhoota Sauda promote these lies.

Its our job as Sikhs not to believe these anti-Sikh lies which claim multiple wives when Gurmat and Gurbani clear that marriages are between one male and one female

[singhbj singh]

What is the point of such stories ?

What wisdom & inspiration do this story give to readers ?

"Means should justify the ends"

[Guest Jacfsing2]

Like Sri Krishna ji, Gorakhnath ji, and many other people blessed children vardans on people without obvious physical relations. I am sure that some of our Sri Guru jis have also blessed devotees with wishes like these too.

? Do you believe other religious leaders are equal to Guru Sahib himself? Jesus, Muhammad, Gurbachana, Ram Rahim, or many others?

[Guest Jacfsing2]

Reply to OP,

Singhbj

Let's say for arguments sake that Dasmesh Pita had more than one wife.... the Guru is perfect, why question their actions, decisions?

The Guru's are not like us Moorkhs, subject to Kaam, Krod, Lob, Moh and Hunkar, so they didn't marry out of Lust.

The Guru's, I understand, married more than 1 wife out of a. Seva (to the Panth, and Humanity) and b. out of Daya (compassion) marrying more than one wife out of compassion. For normal Sikh isn't not allowed (as a rule of thumb) But the Gurus? Come on mate, their God themselves!!! Everything they did was perfect / pure, complete.

My 2 cents. All the best.

Agree