Did Giani Gian Singh Change The Dhora 'guru Granth Ji Manyo Pargat Gura Ik Deh'

[1013GURUJI]

Does anybody know if this correct: Giani Gian Singh Change the Dhora 'guru granth ji manyo pargat gura ik deh' from 'Guru Khalsa Manyo Pargat Guru Ki Deh'

[Pargaas]

It was always "Guru granth ji maneyo pargat guran ki deh".Nobody has changed it .It is as such .

[1013GURUJI]

Please see the of Bhai Prahlad Singhji , line 24

https://archive.org/details/RehatnamaBhaiPrahladSingh

Guru Khalsa Manney Pargat Guru Ki Deh

Jo Sikh Mo Milbe Chahe Khoj Enhe May Layho

[chatanga]

Does anybody know if this correct: Giani Gian Singh Change the Dhora 'guru granth ji manyo pargat gura ik deh' from 'Guru Khalsa Manyo Pargat Guru Ki Deh'

In one of the rehatnamas, the line is written as you have posted above. There are one or two rehatnamas which give slightly differing lines. Gyani Gyan Singh wrote his own.

It was always "Guru granth ji maneyo pargat guran ki deh".Nobody has changed it .It is as such .

This line was written in the 1880s. Since the Singh Sabha Lehar it has been adopted as part of the Ardas Dohra. So it has only been part of prayer for about 100 years give or take a decade.

[NaamTiharoJoJape]

Any vichaar on authenticity of rehitnamay?

From my personal point of view, I accept bhai nand lal jis rehitnama to be of greatest authenticity, and perhaps bhai daya singh rehitnama following but I am not sure of any rehitnama other than bhai nand lal ji 

Any thoughts on rehitname by bhai desa singh, bhai chaupa singh, bhai sahib singh, bhai prahlad singh? Any others I am missing? 

[intrigued]

Bhai Jaita has Sri Gur Katha

[NaamTiharoJoJape]

1 hour ago, intrigued said:

Bhai Jaita has Sri Gur Katha

Isnt that one super controversial 

There are folks who says it's an product of 19th century literature 

[intrigued]

4 minutes ago, NaamTiharoJoJape said:

Isnt that one super controversial 

There are folks who says it's an product of 19th century literature 

To my knowledge Bhai Jaita was a low caste Sikh who wasn't as influenced as some high caste Sikhs, like Chaupa Singh I think

[intrigued]

 

[intrigued]

https://www.patreon.com/posts/43263260 - Review of Granth