Who Is Responsible For The Hate Towards Dasam Granth?

[khalsaman1]

In other news:

http://dailysikhupdates.com/missionaries-target-bhai-pinderpal-singh-usa/

Nindak Missionaries hate Giani Pinderpal Singh because they taught and trained him but Giani Ji is not towing the party line.

[jkvlondon]

I am currently reading Bhai Sahib book...a little information about his area of study Dasam Granth Sahib

http://www.sikhnet.com/news/dr-kamalroop-singh-dasam-granth-interview

[Guest]

In other news:

http://dailysikhupdates.com/missionaries-target-bhai-pinderpal-singh-usa/

Nindak Missionaries hate Giani Pinderpal Singh because they taught and trained him but Giani Ji is not towing the party line.

He never studied at missionary college. He studied at Jawaddi taksal and the sikh missionary college in ropar. That college has no affiliation with the missionary college that makes people into the likes of dhunda.

[khalsaman1]

He never studied at missionary college. He studied at Jawaddi taksal and the sikh missionary college in ropar. That college has no affiliation with the missionary college that makes people into the likes of dhunda.

I don't care what missionary college he studied at. It is well known that Giani Pinderpal Singh and the late Sant Singh Ji Maskeen both had similar views to the Dhunda crowed at one point.

Maskeen Ji has some recordings from the late 80s in which he questions Dasam Granth. Thankfully Maskeen Ji found the light and corrected their parchar on a going forward basis to become one of the greatest parcharaks of our time. Bless their soul.

[Guest]

I don't care what missionary college he studied at. It is well known that Giani Pinderpal Singh and the late Sant Singh Ji Maskeen both had similar views to the Dhunda crowed at one point.

Maskeen Ji has some recordings from the late 80s in which he questions Dasam Granth. Thankfully Maskeen Ji found the light and corrected their parchar on a going forward basis to become one of the greatest parcharaks of our time. Bless their soul.

And what proof do you have that gyani pinderpal Singh had the same views as dhunda? He studied at Jawaddi Taksal as well which is pro dasam granth.

[khalsaman1]

And what proof do you have that gyani pinderpal Singh had the same views as dhunda? He studied at Jawaddi Taksal as well which is pro dasam granth.

What kind of proof are you looking for? I'm sorry I don't have access to his transcripts.

Giani Pinderpal Singh Ji attended the Sikh Missionary College in Ropar before spending time at Jawaddi Kalan.

http://www.sikhiwiki.org/index.php/Bhai_Pinderpal_Singh

All Missionary Colleges are the same whether you want to accept it or not.

[Jonny101]

What kind of proof are you looking for? I'm sorry I don't have access to his transcripts.

Giani Pinderpal Singh Ji attended the Sikh Missionary College in Ropar before spending time at Jawaddi Kalan.

http://www.sikhiwiki.org/index.php/Bhai_Pinderpal_Singh

All Missionary Colleges are the same whether you want to accept it or not.

Not the same. The ropar one is better. They havnt gone to the heretic side 100% like the Ludhiana one. The Shaheed missionary college in Amritsar is probably the best one. They even study Sri Dasam Granth and even Sooraj Granth.

[WaljinderSingh]

What kind of proof are you looking for? I'm sorry I don't have access to his transcripts.

Giani Pinderpal Singh Ji attended the Sikh Missionary College in Ropar before spending time at Jawaddi Kalan.

http://www.sikhiwiki.org/index.php/Bhai_Pinderpal_Singh

All Missionary Colleges are the same whether you want to accept it or not.

Not all missionary colleges are the same. You should look at their curriculum.

You are making stuff up.

[khalsaman1]

Not all missionary colleges are the same. You should look at their curriculum.

You are making stuff up.

Are you going to provide a link to their curriculum from the time that Giani Pinderpal Singh was a student there?

[khalsaman1]

Not the same. The ropar one is better. They havnt gone to the heretic side 100% like the Ludhiana one. The Shaheed missionary college in Amritsar is probably the best one. They even study Sri Dasam Granth and even Sooraj Granth.

And this was the case in the 80s/90s?

I don't know why people are getting to upset over this.

Don't know why people are so defensive about Giani Pinderpal Singh. I want to make it clear that he is a great parcharak...today. He was not always a great parcharak. His views were anti-Sikh, but at one time so were the views of jewel of the panth Sant Singh Ji Maskeen.