Who Is Responsible For The Hate Towards Dasam Granth?

[khalsaman1]

Allegations?

Giani Ji attended a Missionary College.

Anyone that wishes to watch Darbar Sahib on television can tell you that Giani Ji appears on PTC every day.

Anyone with interest in Sikhi knows about the Mata Khivi controversy. Youtube it.

I've seen people get defensive on this message board but nothing quite like this.

[WaljinderSingh]

Allegations?

Giani Ji attended a Missionary College.

Anyone that wishes to watch Darbar Sahib on television can tell you that Giani Ji appears on PTC every day.

Anyone with interest in Sikhi knows about the Mata Khivi controversy. Youtube it.

I've seen people get defensive on this message board but nothing quite like this.

Khalsaman1, I am keen to see you provide the evidence to the allegations you have have smeared on them. Till now you have miserably failed in doing so.

[WaljinderSingh]

Few posts back you actually were praising Bhai Pinderpal Singh for being a good Sikh preacher. Now you are making a U turn on that statement as well.

The truth is that people like you can't tolerate his firm stand against the anti-dasam group.

[Guest]

Few posts back you actually were praising Bhai Pinderpal Singh for being a good Sikh preacher. Now you are making a U turn on that statement as well.

The truth is that people like you can't tolerate his firm stand against the anti-dasam group.

He wants to smear gyani pinderpal Singh.

[jkvlondon]

Allegations?

Giani Ji attended a Missionary College.

Anyone that wishes to watch Darbar Sahib on television can tell you that Giani Ji appears on PTC every day.

Anyone with interest in Sikhi knows about the Mata Khivi controversy. Youtube it.

I've seen people get defensive on this message board but nothing quite like this.

brother , there is missionary and missionary ...for example sikh missionary centre in Southall is true blue Gursikh outfit from way back ...they have nothing to do with Gurnindaks . Same way specific to missionary College Ludhiana all the gand koord parchaar is being spread only by its alumni ... if you look at the sponsors of that establishment it is clear it has definite links to anti sikh elements where as no other colleges have such a reputation . Jawaddi kalan taksal is foremost in gurmat sangeet parchaar and is a shining beacon of new raagi jathey in puraatan saaz . Know the person by the actions and fruit ...

[khalsaman1]

Few posts back you actually were praising Bhai Pinderpal Singh for being a good Sikh preacher. Now you are making a U turn on that statement as well.

The truth is that people like you can't tolerate his firm stand against the anti-dasam group.

Giani Pinderpal Singh's current parchar is very good. However, as I've now stated multiple times...his parchar has not always been such. I have merely outlined other red flags surrounding this preacher.

-Again, I've provided an online source which indicates he attended a Missionary College.

-I've outlined that he appears on PTC every day, during an era where Badal and Makkar have removed many who have spoken the truth (Baldev Singh Vadala, Harcharan Singh Khalsa and many other ragis). If you don't have a television, I cannot help you.

-There is a video on youtube of Giani Pinderpal Singh addressing the Mata Khivi allegations.

As for the anti-Dasam group take....that is weak brother. Take a look at my post history. I absolutely support Dasam Granth as the bani of the 10th master.

[khalsaman1]

brother , there is missionary and missionary ...for example sikh missionary centre in Southall is true blue Gursikh outfit from way back ...they have nothing to do with Gurnindaks . Same way specific to missionary College Ludhiana all the gand koord parchaar is being spread only by its alumni ... if you look at the sponsors of that establishment it is clear it has definite links to anti sikh elements where as no other colleges have such a reputation . Jawaddi kalan taksal is foremost in gurmat sangeet parchaar and is a shining beacon of new raagi jathey in puraatan saaz . Know the person by the actions and fruit ...

A reasonable response. Thanks for providing this information.

Do you know why PTC continues to show Giani Pinderpal Singh's katha when other parcharaks and ragis (who speak the truth) have been banned from appearing on television? There is a long list of people that remain employees of SGPC that are not allowed to be on the live broadcast of either kirtan at Darbar Sahib or katha at Manji Sahib.

Yet, Giani Ji's katha appears daily.

I don't want to get too deep into the alleged remarks about Mata Khivi. Giani Ji has defended himself but his opponents are sure that he made the comparison between Mata Ji and the dead Mrs. Badal. This could be a case of slandering a good parcharak or there could be truth to this.

[Guest]

his parchar has not always been such.

Again please do show proof.

Also in the 1990s the missionary college in Ludhiana was pro dasam GRANTH. They have gutkey and other stuff that promoted dasam Granth.

[jkvlondon]

A reasonable response. Thanks for providing this information.

Do you know why PTC continues to show Giani Pinderpal Singh's katha when other parcharaks and ragis (who speak the truth) have been banned from appearing on television? There is a long list of people that remain employees of SGPC that are not allowed to be on the live broadcast of either kirtan at Darbar Sahib or katha at Manji Sahib.

Yet, Giani Ji's katha appears daily.

I don't want to get too deep into the alleged remarks about Mata Khivi. Giani Ji has defended himself but his opponents are sure that he made the comparison between Mata Ji and the dead Mrs. Badal. This could be a case of slandering a good parcharak or there could be truth to this.

think about PTC this way, what is the only way they can look 'normal' or pro-sikh to naive sangat ...show a popular rehitvaan parchaarik such as Bhai Pinderpal SIngh ji just to lull them into believing the anti-sikh news and views on other shows . His point is to get the parchaar out , they have bought rights to the films and he probably cannot do anything about it . Back in the day they used to show 'gyan da sagar' which was Giani Sant SIngh Maskeen ji's parchaar programs ...when he died they refused to show repeats or release the dvd set of the series for the sangat to get laha of the deep gyan. They are just sitting on top of it . I know that Bhai Pinderpal Singh ji has been bullied about the subject of his parchaar by Badal's stooges so I do not believe he is their chamcha.

[jkvlondon]

Kamalroop veer ji's talk on Dasam Granth and sikh literature historical sources: