Is 'halal' Meat Really Halal?

[Jonny101]

I find it strange that fish are considered halal , when they die suffocating in nets

It is one of the many inconsistancies of Islam

[Balkaar]

It is one of the many inconsistancies of Islam

Can fish really be jhatka either?

[jkvlondon]

Can fish really be jhatka either?

unless you have a fishing pole and do it straight away after hooking I really cannot see it ...

[InderjitS]

If you use a gun or other firearms, is it Jhatka or Halal?

depends if the kalma was read over the bullet and whether the bullet was large enough to cleanly decapitate the creature after reading Chandi Dhi Vaar...sorry ignore me gotta laugh.

[MisterrSingh]

Can fish really be jhatka either?

I imagine it would be quite tricky to get a fish to lay still before doing jhatka. It would be flipping and squirming all over the place.

And now I can't stop laughing as I imagine a Singh trying to hold onto a fish in order to perform jhatka.

[jkvlondon]

I imagine it would be quite tricky to get a fish to lay still before doing jhatka. It would be flipping and squirming all over the place.

And now I can't stop laughing as I imagine a Singh trying to hold onto a fish in order to perform jhatka.

I must admit to grinning like anybody's business when I posted too ... it has now changed to giggling ....

[Pakandi baba]

If you use a gun or other firearms, is it Jhatka or Halal?

It's not halal obviously, could be jhatka as long as it died quickly