1699 Vaisakhi-eye-witness Account By A Mughal Spy!

[Quantavius]

How about the accounts from the Panj Pyare themselves?

[Pakandi baba]

why have doubts on Guru ji ? mere Satguru maar jivaala ... so you guys are arguing for the idea that My Satguru is a liar and trickster by supporting the chatka of bakri story ?

what my Guru ji said , he did ...he took those sees given willingly ...

True believers need no accounts of the ability of the Guru Sahibs who were the formless God in each of the ten lives they came in. Satguru Nanak Nirankaar can make the Kaaba move, they can and DID bring the dead back to life.

[WaljinderSingh]

Im sure that story has been confirmed as made up/fake.

And your surety is based on what?

[luckysingh99]

On 5/8/2016 at 1:10 PM, InderjitS said:

To think that Guru Sahib did Jhatka of bakriaan is simply hilarious.

If anyone else tells me this kavi santokh version,  I'll jhatka them myself !

It's shocking that so many sikhs adhere to this version and reproach all that is sacred and divine.

[InderjitS]

41 minutes ago, luckysingh99 said:

If anyone else tells me this kavi santokh version,  I'll jhatka them myself !

It's shocking that so many sikhs adhere to this version and reproach all that is sacred and divine.

Precisely, don't recall anyone mention goats bleating in our ithiaas and secondly, if Guru Sahib wanted the head of a Goat he would have asked for one and we'd all be bakrian......oh wait some are