If Khalistan Was Given Next Week Would It Last

[GurburAkal]

How about a voluntary society? Then no one will ever be able to control the Panjab

[Guest Jacfsing2]

How about a voluntary society? Then no one will ever be able to control the Panjab

As great as that sounds a voluntary society can only be possible if everyone else is in a similar society, (also it would be negative in an international stage and we'd be in constant war from attackers).

[KhoonKaBadlaKhoon]

We choose the National Punj Pyare in the same way the Gurdwaras choose Punj Pyare, if you remember the Akal Takht opposed the SGPC Jathedars, so clearly they weren't servants of the Jathedars. Bureaucracy only leads to corruption, any nation will show you that, (what makes you think elected leaders of an independent Khalistan won't be corrupted?)

Im not actually aware of how a gurdwara chooses its Panj Pyare, could you explain it please or show me where I can find the info?

Bureaucracy is needed for any modern nation, im not 100% sure what your views regarding politics in Khalistan, but surely we both agree 5 people alone cannot deal with issues such as banking, infrastructure, education, foreign affairs, military and so on. Considering how complex modern nations are I think you will need bureaucracy and elected officials. Maybe have Panj Pyare act as the final say, signing off on bills/legislations etc.

[Guest Jacfsing2]

Im not actually aware of how a gurdwara chooses its Panj Pyare, could you explain it please or show me where I can find the info?

Bureaucracy is needed for any modern nation, im not 100% sure what your views regarding politics in Khalistan, but surely we both agree 5 people alone cannot deal with issues such as banking, infrastructure, education, foreign affairs, military and so on. Considering how complex modern nations are I think you will need bureaucracy and elected officials. Maybe have Panj Pyare act as the final say, signing off on bills/legislations etc.

Most Gurdwaras pick Punj Pyare on, first being an Rehitwale Amritdhari, (based on interpretation), and someone who's in the Sangat and does Sewa often, (from the Gurdwaras I've been to), also considering that Ranjit Singh's empire collapsed almost immediately after he died, eventually with the last king just giving all the land without consulting anyone was just awful. I can agree to a legislative branch acting as advisors to the Punj Pyare, but ultimately all power should be given to the 5.

[S4NGH]

Given? No one is going to give khalistan to anyone. Which fool in the right mind would cut out one of its most prosperous states ever?

All this silly talk needs to end. Khalistan zindabad etc oh give it a rest. How many of us are willing to leave behind our lives of pure comfort here in the west and return to our homeland to free it from the dushts? Forget khalistan, what effort have we made to free punjab from badal et al?!

Khalistan is but a dream. Our shaheeds did their bit. Is anyone willing to do theirs? Nope. Thats me included. We're too comfortable. It pains us to see punjab in its current state but we're not willing to take any action.

[GurburAkal]

As great as that sounds a voluntary society can only be possible if everyone else is in a similar society, (also it would be negative in an international stage and we'd be in constant war from attackers).

If there is shastardhari Khalsa, then no one should be able to invade? If there isnt khalsa then why khalistan in the first place

[Guest Jacfsing2]

If there is shastardhari Khalsa, then no one should be able to invade? If there isnt khalsa then why khalistan in the first place

People don't just fight on land anymore, there's also air strikes and drones. We should still keep Shastars, but also being practical about the Shastars in the present time as well.

[GurburAkal]

People don't just fight on land anymore, there's also air strikes and drones. We should still keep Shastars, but also being practical about the Shastars in the present time as well.

I heard that tarna dal has a few tanks ??

[genie]

Whether we like it or not Khalistan is a reality on ground level in punjab and will become a overt reality in the near future in terms of government level.

Already Hindu brahmin extremists are crapping in their pants and making all kinda anti-sikh propaganda on facebook and youtube because they know Khalistan is deep within the hearts of most Sikhs so its very difficult to remove even after years of genocides and anti-sikh hate speeches it only increases the strength of Sikhs because persecution helps us to be militant and strong otherwise become liberal and sleepy.

A viable Khalistan can easily work within the Indian union as a small regional religious autonomous area with a Sikh government without most of the dangers of right independence carries for both Sikhs and the Union.

If however the Indian union central govt in delhi are not wise and chose to block this very reasonable step then when or if war with pakistan or china ever comes. Sikhs will definitely take full advantage by working with the enemies of India and be the rebel army that destroys the union.

[singhnihk]