Jump to content
Sign in to follow this  
AryanRai

CLOSED TOPIC

Recommended Posts

Let me throw this in:

 

In all of the bull5hit about caste amongst our lot, how about this approach?

 

When you meet a next Sikh and get to know them, judge whether this person is an ar5ehole or not (this goes for both male and females), based on how they conduct themselves and live their lives. This doesn't mean we expect puritanical behaviour from them, just that overall - is this a good person or not? Is this person a liability to the quom or not? Is this a solid person or not? Don't worry about what job their ancestors have done. 

This fudhu obsession apnay have with trying to find some sort of greatness in their caste is such a waste of time when we have so many other real issues to deal with. I mean are people REALLY that insecure with being Sikhs that they have to dredge up extra crap to bolster up their self-image?

  • Like 4

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
1 hour ago, dallysingh101 said:

Let me throw this in:

 

In all of the bull5hit about caste amongst our lot, how about this approach?

 

When you meet a next Sikh and get to know them, judge whether this person is an ar5ehole or not (this goes for both male and females), based on how they conduct themselves and live their lives. This doesn't mean we expect puritanical behaviour from them, just that overall - is this a good person or not? Is this person a liability to teh quom or not? Is this a solid person or not? Don't worry about what job their ancestors have done. 

This fudhu obsession apnay have with trying to find some sort of greatness in their caste is such a waste of time when we have so many other real issues to deal with. I mean are people REALLY that insecure with being Sikhs that they have to dredge up extra crap to bolster up their self-image?

Some good points made there about seeing the person who they are and not their caste. When I read this topic I thought I was dreaming and thought did I actually read it.

6 hours ago, AryanRai said:

Genetically Chamars aren't a Low Caste,  like Shudra Dalits, they're Vaishyas who work with Animal Skin, personally I never considered Chamars a Low Caste, I've always thought they were a people of a respectable profession.

Leather Shoe-making is a very skilled profession in Britain and Europe, why can't it be respected in India too, just because Hindus worship cows. All the communities have something to offer-

Chamars- Cobblers

Jats/Gujjars- Farmers

Arora/Khatris- Accountants

Bhats- Tradesmen

Ramgarhias- Carpenters

Rajputs- Landlords 

Mazabhis- Cleaners

Chamars are skilled Labourers like Nai Sikhs, Tarkhans and Ramgarhias. They're said to be "Polluted" because they worked with Animal Skin, but I think they're Higher than Jats who often bully them based on Hindu sanctioning which they claim to not recognise seeing as the Hindus have given Jats the Varna status of Shudra.

The Bhatti Gotra comes from Rajput & Brahmins. Many people from other tribes joined the Chamar community, all Punjabi communities have common ancestries.

I think that the Communal Hierachy in Punjabi culture is as follows-

Khatris/Aroras

Rajputs

Bhatias

Mohyals

Chimbas

Kambojas

....and in the middle the Jats, Ramgarhias, Tarkhans, Chamars, Lubanas, Bhats, Sainis, Kalals, Chirs, Mahtons quarrel amongst each other. Although originating from the same stock.

Chuhras lie at the bottom of the barrel.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Who cares what hierarchy one is placed. Caste does not go with one's soul, but the actions and bhagti of a person do. All this caste talk isn't doing nothing for nobody and besides people's jobs have changed so what's the point in doing a hierarchy table of whose highest or lowest. For God there is no high or low caste. 

Sikhi does not promote caste. I'm surprised this topic hasn't been locked. 

  • Like 3

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

can u tell us wat, Khul karan di rasam & Mourvi makaan mean? An old poster on this site said these r 2 bhatra practices, but sisnt rveal wat they were, can u shed any light on this?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
21 hours ago, AryanRai said:

Veerji I'm not trying to "dredge up extra crap for anything" and neither am I "insecure," I've made it clear that I have made this topic for the sole purpose of dispelling rumours and vicious lies which circulate in the wider Sikh community.

Caste isn't an issue for me at all as I can defend myself, I only don't want it to be an issue for those who can't defend themselves. I have done intensive research for my community. I think I have a right to share it.

Thank You

I hear what you are saying but I can't help but think that these types of things are an (understandable) reaction to all the incessant outpourings of a particular group who are famous for never missing an opportunity to try and posture their own caste as some sort of 'superbreed' and either playing down or disparaging contributions from other groups.

 

The problem is that we all start doing it then. 

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest Jacfsing2

There is only one who is higher than anyone and that is Guru Sahib, if you do wish to make a hierarchy do it based on their character not caste.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

When bhatras say rajput this really confuses me, arent bhatras who say they are of rajput backgrounds actually KASHYAP Rajputs which is different from Rajputs who are not related to bhatra community at all? 

There are Rajput Sikhs and they are not bhatray, more similar to Khatri so I really don't get it when bhatray say they are rajput.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Sat Sri Akal Veerji,

When Bhats speak of Rajput heritage it originates from the Indo-Aryan tribes of Rajasthan and Central India.

Punjabi Rajputs are a Scythian branch of Kshatriyas related to Jatts

Rajputs are not a united community, people in all corners of India are Rajputs. 

Bhats are a Conglomeration of Clans.

On 29 December 2016 at 5:54 PM, TuhadaDaas said:

When bhatras say rajput this really confuses me, arent bhatras who say they are of rajput backgrounds actually KASHYAP Rajputs which is different from Rajputs who are not related to bhatra community at all? 

There are Rajput Sikhs and they are not bhatray, more similar to Khatri so I really don't get it when bhatray say they are 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
7 minutes ago, AryanRai said:

I agree Veerji. Casteism will eventually end in the next few generations, as our descendents learn that Caste is one of the most ridiculous concepts devised by our ancestors. 

 

I think that will happen in the diaspora. Panjab itself - a different story. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
Sign in to follow this  



  • Topics

  • Posts

    • A couple months back I was at a grocery store in Delhi. The guy at the counter seemed to be a bhaiiya but was trying to speak Punjabi with me since I'm visibly a Sikh. He wasn't too bad at it but you could clearly guess that Punjabi was not his mother tongue. I was responding to him in Punjabi as well. Meanwhile, some auntie in her 40s who was clearly not Sikh (could be Hindu) was overhearing and interrupted him and said why are you speaking Punjabi when you can't. The guy was in his own zone and didn't care for the lady lol. I could feel the hidden contempt in her voice towards the Punjabi language. I'm pretty sure the guy had just watched some Punjabi movie or had been listening to Punjabi songs.
    • Punjabi culture may have had some good aspect because it was based off Sikhi teachings say 50 years ago. To say the erosion had not set in even then is an understatement. punjabi culture is evolving and it is completely unrecognizable from where it started. There is no platform to hold it from changing. Take the example of a punjabi women covering her head because it's a sign of respect to God and demonstrate the integrity of the family. Today this concept is completely lost in punjabi culture. The women are not even aware such a practice existed. This virtues teaching has been replaced with flaunting the hair with various designs to express the individual personality and draw attention from others; not to mention to attract the opposite gender. There is no actual true identity for punjabi culture. Today it's what you see in punjabi movies because that's what the punjabi youth are following and tomorrow it will change as well. The colors of punjabi culture are based on flaunting your wealth and sexual appeal today. The way the punjabis carry themselves is a small difference than the whites of the west. All these changes are not harmless. They have completely left self respect behind among punjabi men and women. Punjabi culture held the women of the household as their integrity. Today the punjabi women are giving this integrity away on dance floors, in hotel bathrooms, clubs and beaches. Had a punjabi women even batted an eye at a man or vice versa all hell would have broken loose. Not today, some punjabis, started with the urban parents, encouraged dating to their daughters or allowed it by being silent as it was flaunted in the house. Alcoholism goes hand in glove with this so called harmless colors. The newer generation have left female foeticide and dowry behind, but not foeticide because when punjabi women have multiple partners. They are bound to make mistakes. But what did they take up in place of it. A drunk wife and wasting there parents money on lavish weddings and purchases. Give up two wrong things and take up another two. This is not improvement by any standards. Drunk men and women, prime reason to live is accumulate wealth, and open display of sexual appeal. These are the main problems facing the Sikhs today. Bhangra has aggravated all these issues and is driving punjabis further into the pit of hell. Bhangra created today's youth. All the hall parties blasted bhangra music and decade by decade the tunes became more lustful, and egotistical. The bhangra parties gave the punjabi youth a venue where they can mingle with the opposite gender and destroy the punjabi family integrity. This is no secret but punjabis will deny it because that's what they are good.  Chamkila had already started the trend for lustful music for the older generations.   So the effect of bhangra was already seen.  But like a good slave, let's ignore this and continue down the path to say its harmless colors. If anyone is serious about reviving punjabi culture. Than Sikhi teachings have to be implemented. And this means getting rid of bhangra; the vehicle that started this mess. Alcohol plays a key role in this as well. And it's not about banning bhangra. It starts by recognizing the damage this so called harmless color has done to the punjabi people. Have you seen the punjabi women puking because they are so drunk at bhangra parties? Ever heard about letting multiple guys make a train out of her because she is so drugged up she doesn't even know what she is doing. What about punjabi parties where the guys and girls are all on drugs and nude photos of them are being passed around? On the ground level all this is happening and some clueless people are calling it harmless colors.  
    • What we are essentially missing is the fact that Bollywood and Indian TV is created for the masses who consist of low income daily wagers who want to escape their daily realities hence why the over the top sequences and repeated images to make a point. The writers of these serials and movies tend to be males and have no understanding of female perspectives. This is why probably every Bollywood movie has a rape scene and the female characters are portrayed as in the first instance hating the hero and then when he pays some ruffians to fake an attack or rape attempt against the female and he rescues her, she falls instantly in love with him! Can you imagine how traumatised a female would be from such an attack and in the real life would need counselling but in Bollywood Bullshyt land she's happily singing and dancing a few seconds later! 
    • Please create account. Such posts do not need the user to be anonymous ji. This way - no waiting
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

Terms of Use