Jump to content
Sign in to follow this  

Recommended Posts

waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh

Question for the Raagi Gyanis and Ustaads: I am trying to differentiate between the main raag keertan styles.

In the big Gurdwaras, the tanti saaj Raagis sing in a sing-a-long fashion (repeating melody, rapid progress through the shabad). However there is another rarely heard style where the singing is very different: substantive vibrato/voice echo, slow progress- once verse may be chewed upon for a very long time with great emotion and improvisation. Listen to the following two clips which demonstrate this (Man Japoh Ram Gopal - 1 in 'sing-a-long' style and 2 in the 'slow tempo' style).

-Are there any names to describe these two types of vocalisation? Is it correct to say that the vocalisation of the latter is a genre such as Dhrupad?
-In simple terms what is the difference between the two? Do they have the same core basis?
-Can all ustaads teach the second type?

Sample 1-Raag Kanra- Man Japo Ram Gopal-Prof Surinder Singh.mp3

Sample 2-Raag Kanra- Man Japo Ram Gopal-Ustad Harbhajan Singh, Balwant Singh Namdhari..mp3

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

I've been told that the latter slow tempo style is classical/dhrupad/semi-dhrupad but the question remains whether they have the same core basis and whether all ustaads can teach the second type?

Any assistance will be greatly appreciated.

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Sign in to follow this  

  • Topics

  • Posts

    • Stand for righteousness yes. Only thing we can do is neutrally speak out against injustices against innocents when we see them not be partisan in our approach. In practical sense different times different era's different approach is needed. Sikhs need to learn to adapt or get vanished for their petty virtue signalling. End of the day try wielding a kirpan against an evil doer and you'll be arrested and in jail faster than you can put it away. The Sikhs of era we are inspired by were sovereign sikhs in their own area of control and laws and rules. If we try to be wonna be modern day sant saphi's mowing down every rioter or criminal we come across we'll just get rolled over by the state and its own huge numbers of modern weaponised fully armed personnel. The so called khalsa warriors of today are not able to match even a tiny percentage of the calibre of purataan Sikhs of era's past nor modern day warriors of 1980s/90s. We learn't the hard way how real world politics works and which communities had our back, which we found out were none.  
    • It goes under a lot of names. Imperialism is a sickness of those who were always sick. Don't let it make you ill. 
    • That was written by some who was against the Nazis and it was a warning for people not to be complacent to the threat of a totalitarian, fascist ideology.... which in the modern world goes by the name of the religion of 'peace' 
    • Bloodshed happen Again.  Did not certain jathas hide during blue star?  Each with their own list of wrongs or reasons? Weren't the great Shaheeds, Sants, and Sadars of the past known for their rightousness period? These types of actions can not be allowed ever against any or they will consume us all. 
    • this is what I am thinking they, the BJP have already attacked and removed sikhs from their paid for and cultivated land and businesses of decades if not century whereever they have got in , Rajasthan , Gujarat etc  the amount of robbery and looting is in the ten of CRodes but these guys somehow staying quiet they will be spared of a similar fate to Jains and Buddhists , its just a matter of time . If people don't fight this law change on a whim , they will revoke sikhs citixenship too ...in fact the RSS mouthpieces have hinted similar bloodshed for us is waiting .
  • Create New...

Important Information

Terms of Use