Rehraas Length Question

[samosasingh]

I was listening to a video from taksal who say that the rehraas they read is the final version as passed down by Bhai Mani Singh Ji. Then what about the Hazur Sahib and Nihang Singh rehraas, they also claim to be as passed down by Guru Gobind Singh ji....can anyone give some more info on this?

Thanks,

[simran345]

http://gurmatbibek.com/forum/read.php?3,720

 

 

[samosasingh]

Can someone with a background or affiliation with a samprada etc answer this question. The above information is ok but I need someone who has sampradaic knowledge.

The question and answer Derby thing is not very in depth and is heavy on SGPC's marayada. I find some of stuff they say is laughable. The guy in the grey pug says people don't have enough time so that is why they made it shorter. He says people in the deras are free so can read as much as they want.....the Jagjit Singh person says sampuran is just the name as its given by the dera? Is Taksal a dear? I dont think so...........I need someone who has real knowledge and depth.

[simran345]

38 minutes ago, samosasingh said:

the Jagjit Singh person says

*It's Jagraj Singh, not Jagjit Singh. 

[samosasingh]

Just now, simran345 said:

*It's Jagraj Singh, not Jagjit Singh. 

I am talking about the Q&A Derby video and its Jagjit Singh starting the rehras topic...thank you

[simran345]

Just now, samosasingh said:

I am talking about the Q&A Derby video and its Jagjit Singh starting the rehras topic...thank you

Oh ok, I thought you meant Basics of Sikhi paji. No problem.