Why do most Sikhs that eat meat not eat beef?

[ScHayer]

Last time i checked only hindus don't eat beef, there's no bani that specifically says beef is not allowed. I did hear there was some lines in Aggardanti bani where Guru Gobind Singh Ji speaks about cow slaughter, but i've been told the context is different. 

[Guest]

The cow is also respected in sikhi as a giver of milk and cause of ghis she is also regarded as a mother figure. Not completely like a mother how the hindus do but the cow is still respected. There other other banis such as karninama that also gives respect to the cow as well as rehitnamey

[ScHayer]

1 minute ago, Singh123456777 said:

The cow is also respected in sikhi as a giver of milk and cause of ghis she is also regarded as a mother figure. Not completely like a mother how the hindus do but the cow is still respected. There other other banis such as karninama that also gives respect to the cow as well as rehitnamey

So it's wrong if i or Sikhs that eat meat have beef?  

[Guest]

7 hours ago, ScHayer said:

So it's wrong if i or Sikhs that eat meat have beef?  

Again there is nothing wrong but a lot of singhs from the nihang sect or hazur sahib refrain from eating it

[BhForce]

9 hours ago, ScHayer said:

Last time i checked only hindus don't eat beef, there's no bani that specifically says beef is not allowed. I did hear there was some lines in Aggardanti bani where Guru Gobind Singh Ji speaks about cow slaughter, but i've been told the context is different. 

Forget Sikhs, even some Hindus outside India who eat meat, also eat hamburgers (beef).

[ipledgeblue]

See 2 different areas in Uggardanti which seem to be against cow killing.

ਯਹੀ ਦੇਹ ਆਗਿਆ ਤੁਰਕਨ ਗਹ ਖਪਾਊਂ
ਗਉ ਘਾਤ ਕਾ ਦੋਖ ਜਗ ਸਿਉਂ ਮਿਟਾਊਂ

[ Command me to kill and destroy the Turks. Eliminate the killing of the cow from the entire universe.

https://www.scribd.com/document/50629845/Uggardanti-Punjabi-and-English-Translation-Thanks-dalsingh101-Veerji

XhI bynqI Kws hmrI suxIjY ]Asur mwr kr r`C gaUAn krIjY ]

ieho myrI Kws Arz suxo [rwkiSSW (AsurW) nUM mwrky gaU (grIb) dI rkSW kro [

Kindly adhere to my specific request.Annihilate the evil demons and safeguard the cow (destitute).

[garch]

Prob many reasons.. 

One being cows are domesticated animals in punjab.. my families cows in punjab are surprisingly intelligent and have great personalities and given names.

Your question is similar in principle to asking why do meat eating brits not eat dog or cat meat.

[Guest]

It's talking specifically about killing of cows, once the soul is gone the body doesn't matter. It's the soul that matters.

Eat it or don't eat it whether you are amritdhari or not, what's it to me?

[BhForce]

15 hours ago, ipledgeblue said:

[ Command me to kill and destroy the Turks. Eliminate the killing of the cow from the entire universe.

https://www.scribd.com/document/50629845/Uggardanti-Punjabi-and-English-Translation-Thanks-dalsingh101-Veerji

Brother, assuming that you have this PDF, can you just upload it to Sikhsangat in a new topic?

Thanks.

(Scribd is highly annoying for charging money for downloading PDFs that people uploaded for free.)

[ScHayer]

18 hours ago, BhForce said:

Brother, assuming that you have this PDF, can you just upload it to Sikhsangat in a new topic?

Thanks.

(Scribd is highly annoying for charging money for downloading PDFs that people uploaded for free.)

 

Uggardanti.pdf