Jump to content
mahandulai

SikhSangat.com not fit for purpose?

Recommended Posts

On ‎10‎/‎24‎/‎2018 at 12:55 PM, jkvlondon said:

the anwers are in the threads but you need to be spoonfed like a baby because you don't have the wherewithal to type in search terms

not everyone has the time.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
23 hours ago, PranaamShaheedaNu said:

I agreement that you posts are absurd. I have reviewed some of your yourtube content also - if you do not agree with the way in which the faith is and the way in which the faithful practice the faith do not comment on them.

I am at a disbelief that someone who has Kesh and ties a Dastar is questioning the very purpose of the identity that he is keeping - its Ludacris. We have enough people trying to tarnish our community as it is without requiring for members of the community themselves try and tarnish us!

You don't have faith - that's fine

You need evidential proof - that's fine.

Tell me this - can you prove that your mother is your mother and your father is your father? Have you ever questioned your father if he is your father? No you wouldn't because you have faith in his word - it is akin to questioning the purpose of the Kakkar - and the purpose of Dhan Guru Granth Sahib Ji - my Guru gave us a hukam - there is no need to question. Aap Guru Kartar - The Guru himself is the All Prevading Being.

You need a tight slap - someone born of the Sikh faith is referring to the Guru as just poetry - the Gian that Guru sahib gives us is immeasurable. Its time for indioviduals like you / and others to stop trating Maharaj as an idol, if you pick the Rumalla up just once and take a glimpse of the Guru and Read and Vichaar on its word maybe just maybe your eyes will open!

the point I am trying to make, none of can provide evidential proof, and our sikhi shouldn't be based on quoting words said 300 years ago. 

You are of lower intelligence, for not understanding, this simple fact - if I disagree with something, I will MOST DEFINITELY tell everyone about it.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
19 minutes ago, mahandulai said:

the point I am trying to make, none of can provide evidential proof, and our sikhi shouldn't be based on quoting words said 300 years ago. 

You are of lower intelligence, for not understanding, this simple fact - if I disagree with something, I will MOST DEFINITELY tell everyone about it.

LOL ok then - because you have full Gian of everything going on. Go troll on another site.

Sorry but I don't need evidential proof of what my Guru said - if you don't believe it then fine - move on mate - you are actually getting boring now.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
36 minutes ago, PranaamShaheedaNu said:

LOL ok then - because you have full Gian of everything going on. Go troll on another site.

Sorry but I don't need evidential proof of what my Guru said - if you don't believe it then fine - move on mate - you are actually getting boring now.

ok as long as you know you are. IF it was 2000 years ago would u be more sketpical?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Perhaps playing the devils advocate but feels like some of you have taken a personal approach to addressing this person instead of providing him with an answer to his question.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
On 10/25/2018 at 12:19 AM, genie said:

Mahan dulai you seem like a guy lost in various ideologies, I personally dont think your a troll. Maybe because you didn't come from a religious family that didnt teach you real sikhi from early age so your questioning stuff and trying to rationalise it in your mind now?

I just wanted to chime in with my 2 cents on what you've just said here. Lets assume he didn't. I think such a person is in a better position because he will be coming in with a much more open empty mind rarther than the brain wash that some Sikh families have been raised through. I welcome a continous challenge to learn and rationalise and undoubtely such duty is what led Guru Nanak Dev Jee to challenge the society and belief system he was surrounded by.

Those posessing long term experience/"refined"/experienced interpretation of a passed on mindset will always be threatended and uneasy and not flexible in accepting that perhaps their way of thinking and understanding anything not just Sikhi may be outdated or interpreted incorrectly by those they learnt off.

Edited by Jaggaa

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...



  • Topics

  • Posts

    • Just to give you an example of Iceland where everyone has to scrub themself before using their hot springs. The reason Icelanders are so adamant is, in fact, purely hygienic.
    • Guest harleen
      the first time I took Amrit, I was 5 years old. After plenty of mistakes and growing I had taken it again at the age of 12 from pressure (not all of it was bad but some auntiyan were really urging me to just do it even though my family was warning me of all my responsibilities) and just pure desire to want it. It was at a camp and they really motivate you well. I kept it up for a while and ended up doing many wrongful things afterwards. I’ve plucked my eyebrows because I started getting insecure and ashamed, and just some of my facial hair in general after I got judgemental comments even from my own mother who is Amritdhari, I’ve removed a small amount from legs a couple times where my leg was exposed, once even because I childishly wanted to see what a razor feels like (not sure if this was before or after I took it again). But I’ve had my fair share of mess ups. I kissed a boy and once he took Amrit we never did again and are on a better path now where we don’t even see each other in real life. I feel like I have to confess to that and I’m not sure how. The worst one for me is confession removing pubic hair a few times for comfort purposes especially during period a few times. I just can’t find any way to do that so simply. I know I have to confess everything I can remember because if I don’t then I will be punished after I leave this world so I might as confess now and take the tankha especially because I do very much feel guilty for it all. I don’t know what I was thinking. But I’m terrified of how to say all this. Like wording-wise and just bringing it up in general. 
    • Guest guest
      you sound hysterical.   again, why do you keep mixing brown with blacks? - if small pox was stolen, why did they record where they originally got it from?  i don't think you understand the concept of theft.  immunisation is not the same as variolation.  its an improvement upon it.  would you rather receive variolation or immunisation. -picasso did not "steal" his art.  its well known he was influenced by the african masks he saw at the paris world show. so if an african plays guitar, does that mean he 'stole' the instrument from the west?  stop being stupid. i think you should look up the world 'steal'.
    • Guest guest
      the concept of zero is an intellectual idea.  why should they pay for it?  do you seem modern mathematicians 'patenting' their work? they got via the arabs anyway.
    • Guest guest
      they left india over 73 years ago!   thats not an excuse for todays poverty.   what have punjabis done?  just laced panjab soil and water with toxins to make money, imported foreign livestock and run off to europe/north america en masse? yes theres ALOT of bad stuff.  but what about good stuff?  you can research infant mortality before and after to get an idea.  or deaths from diseases like malaria etc  or number of women forced into sati against their will.   who exactly should feel remorse or shame?  how many of these people were actually there at that time?  why should they feel remorse or shame for what their grandparents did? "take em for wat u can get. they deserve no sympathy." ^this sounds like the kind of cruelty you accuse them of.
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

Terms of Use