Dasam Granth

[GavinSingh]

What's people's opinion on the author of the Dasam Granth? I read the english translations of the charitropakhyan and I've been immensely distrurbed. The stories are totally pornographic in detail. I'm really struggling to believe that Guru Gobind Singh would have the time, energy and need to translate such pornographic material. 

[Akalifauj]

2 minutes ago, GavinSingh said:

What's people's opinion on the author of the Dasam Granth? I read the english translations of the charitropakhyan and I've been immensely distrurbed. The stories are totally pornographic in detail. I'm really struggling to believe that Guru Gobind Singh would have the time, energy and need to translate such pornographic material. 

First you triggered the Guru maneyo Granth crowd on this website and now you are going after Sri Dasam Granth Sahib ji.   Which missionary branch do you belong too?  

[GavinSingh]

1 hour ago, Akalifauj said:

First you triggered the Guru maneyo Granth crowd on this website and now you are going after Sri Dasam Granth Sahib ji.   Which missionary branch do you belong too?  

I'm doing exactly what every Sikh should do - learn, discuss and understand.  

I suggest less triggering would be beneficial to everyone. 

Do you have an opinion on the Dasam Granth or on Guru Maneyo Granth Gurdwara?  - would love to hear your opinion. 

[GurjantGnostic]

57 minutes ago, GavinSingh said:

I'm doing exactly what every Sikh should do - learn, discuss and understand.  

I suggest less triggering would be beneficial to everyone. 

Do you have an opinion on the Dasam Granth or on Guru Maneyo Granth Gurdwara?  - would love to hear your opinion. 

I like your posts Veer Ji.

The way you phrased that is obviously contoversial though. You know it was.

I'll read these sections and get back to you. 

[GavinSingh]

12 minutes ago, GurjantGnostic said:

I like your posts Veer Ji.

The way you phrased that is obviously contoversial though. You know it was.

I'll read these sections and get back to you. 

Thanks - well noticed . Yes indeed it was meant to be controversial but once you've read that part you will realise the controversy. 

[GavinSingh]

Here have a read of Chritar 3 - let me know what you think? 

 

[jkvlondon]

31 minutes ago, GavinSingh said:

Here have a read of Chritar 3 - let me know what you think? 

 

Which book is this because it could be any author's work , besides you have not provided the supposedly translated gurbani text

[GavinSingh]

42 minutes ago, jkvlondon said:

Which book is this because it could be any author's work , besides you have not provided the supposedly translated gurbani text

http://www.globalsikhstudies.net/pdf/chritro pakhyaan (vol 1) complete book.pdf

Its a real eye opener. Yes i don't have the original translation but everyone always says you can't read this section of the Dasam Granth. 

[Dsinghd]

Nihangs (who remain celibate) read  Charitropakhyan.

For me this section (one third of Sri Dasam Granth) is the play of Maya which ends with Benti Chaupai.

[GavinSingh]

2 hours ago, Dsinghdp said:

Nihangs (who remain celibate) read  Charitropakhyan.

For me this section (one third of Sri Dasam Granth) is the play of Maya which ends with Benti Chaupai.

So do you believe/ agree with this section and that the author is Guru Gobind Singh Ji