Hanji I’m pretty sure they do breathing simran too.
Such things were secretly infiltrated into Sikhi by our enemies. They created naam dhir, then said follow breathing simran to make Sikhs as weak as possible. Don’t underestimate how badly some people want to destroy Sikhi.
(Really sorry for long replies. But I know people will click onto this thread in few years time searching for truth about breathing simran. So I want to leave good quality answers for them)
2 more examples of how breathing simran is not the correct technique;
1 - Gurbani says the baby does simran in the womb. Well there is no breathing in the womb, oxygen comes from the umbilical cord. So a baby’s simran (which is so powerful it protects from fire of womb) must be happening another way? The answer is Surat
2 - Gurbani says Prabh bhavai bin saas te rakhai ~ if it pleases god without breath you remain alive. When Baba Deep Singh Ji’s head was separated, or Bhai Mati Das Ji’s body in 2 pieces there was no breath. So how did their simran remain unaffected? Because they were doing it with Surat
In a modern day Singh Sabha movement, would the Dal Khalsa retake Akal Takht after being removed by the previous Singh Sabha which is now represented by SGPC? Would Dal Khalsa (budha dal tarna dal) be given more control like they had pre-colonial times?
Would we reintroduce more Dasam Granth readings which were stopped by previous Singh Sabha?
I definitely don't think Naam Dhrir was given by original panj pyaras and I don't think dal Khalsa practised this either.
I actually just wanted to find out that jathas who practise Naam Dhrir, do they also practise this breathing thing?
I don't agree with Naam Dhrir myself, I don't see it as a neccsity for Sachkhand and actually see it as a beadbi to Amrit Sanchar!