colonel Steinbach on sikh diet in 1846!

[shastarSingh]

https://archive.org/details/in.ernet.dli.2015.502825

colonel Steinbach wrote a book in 1846 which can be downloaded at above link. He wrote about the sikh diet in the book.

[S1ngh]

Same as today any writer can write about general majority of Sikhs being non-turbaned, drinking or some smoking. 100 years later we cannot simply believe that they were the actual Sikh. Just like in past there were actual Sikhs who followed guru path and some who were on and off that path with their weakness. Maharaja Ranjit is the perfect example of a Sikh who was not a Sikh in our guru eyes with his lifestyle. 

[BhForce]

On 1/20/2020 at 2:40 AM, shastarSingh said:

colonel Steinbach wrote a book in 1846 which can be downloaded at above link. He wrote about the sikh diet in the book.

What's your deal, bro?

You seem to like to post a whole bunch of quotations from various sources without any sort of context.

OK, so Col. Steinbach wrote a book. What's your point? What do you make of it?

Are you saying that because Steinbach wrote a sentence regarding some things he saw, that applies uniformly to all Sikhs? Secondly, are you making a religious point about Sikhs and meat? If so, state it explicitly.

Thanks for the link to the book, though. Very interesting.

Also regarding the fact that Maharaja Ranjit SIngh was a profligate drinker, again, what are you trying to prove? That Sikhs should be drunk out of their minds?

You do realize that the Sikh kingdom was totally destroyed, and the foundations for its destruction were laid during the Maharaja's time because he failed to set things up like he should have. Does that have anything to do with being a drunkard?

Perhaps you ended up proving the exact opposite of your intended point.

Thanks for that.

[jkvlondon]

just because a goray wrote something doesn't make it true Ernest Trump wrote Guru ji was repetitive , irrelevant and not worth reading , that It is NOT divinely sourced , did that make the A right and Sikhi wrong. The whole machine of British invasion was designed to trash every aspect of Sikh kingdoms life, political and administrative might , truth was it was reknowned worldwide as being the most rich kingdom with peaceful, effective administration with protections against famine , illiteracy, inumeracyfor every citizen, religious harmony and tolerance .

[shastarSingh]

https://archive.org/details/punjaubbeingbrie00stei

The second edition of this book can be downloaded at the above link. 

Another quote from this book

 

[Babbar_Singhsta]

100%

[IshR]

On 1/20/2020 at 9:53 PM, S1ngh said:

Same as today any writer can write about general majority of Sikhs being non-turbaned, drinking or some smoking. 100 years later we cannot simply believe that they were the actual Sikh. Just like in past there were actual Sikhs who followed guru path and some who were on and off that path with their weakness. Maharaja Ranjit is the perfect example of a Sikh who was not a Sikh in our guru eyes with his lifestyle. 

This 

100% true

[S1ngh]

On 1/21/2020 at 9:14 AM, shastarSingh said:

https://archive.org/details/punjaubbeingbrie00stei

The second edition of this book can be downloaded at the above link. 

Another quote from this book

 

Wow... This is pure hatred. 

[genie]

When you read these old books written by white european colonalists in punjab you see the true racial bias, hatred they have and not forgetting the jealousy they had of the Sikh and punjabi natives who created a mighty empire and army to rival any european white nation of the day. You then realise the invasion and conquest of Sikh punjabi empire aswell as other non-white lands around the globe was done on a racial superiority complex basis to prove that they have the right to rule over the non-white indigousness natives because of their conquest over them (similar mentality of the muslims). It's only since ww2 with rise and defeat of nazi far right Aryan fascism and rise of the left in politics that these views once openly expressed decades ago are more underground and covert.

[genie]

35 minutes ago, S1ngh said:

Wow... This is pure hatred. 

probably talking of the nihungs and akali's who were the fiercest warriors not yet willing to submit to foreign racist white british rule over them and their lands even after both anglo-sikh wars had concluded in defeat of sarkar-e-khalsa.