do not trust Brahman and do not eat Muslim meat

[shastarSingh]

dhadi nath mal was a sikh of Guru Sahib and he wrote a granth in Farsi in 1708 called amarnama .He says that Guru Sahib told not to trust Brahman and not to have Muslim halal meat in line no. 132.

[shastarSingh]

it's punjabi translation can be bought at

https://www.jsks.biz/amarnama

and English translation at 

https://www.amazon.in/Amarnama-Perspective-Phase-Gobind-Singhs/dp/8190402188

[shastarSingh]

also read this

clearly meat is a warrior's food and allowed in Sikhi.

[WaljinderSingh]

8 hours ago, shastarSingh said:

also read this

clearly meat is a warrior's food and allowed in Sikhi.

You are wrong.

A Sikh should not eat meat and believe the sin of killing of animals for the sake of one's taste buds can be washed away so easily - every action has a reaction.  Remember these animals are in the cycle of 8.4 million joons - they take their revenges in another form of life.

Guru sahib has taught us to be compassionate (Dayawaan) towards every living creature. 

I am not going to debate whether jhatka should be banned or not but the notion of every Sikh should eat meat (for whatever reason) is completely wrong and uncalled for, offensive statement.

[shastarSingh]

9 hours ago, WaljinderSingh said:

You are wrong.

A Sikh should not eat meat and believe the sin of killing of animals for the sake of one's taste buds can be washed away so easily - every action has a reaction.  Remember these animals are in the cycle of 8.4 million joons - they take their revenges in another form of life.

This is the fear tactic used to scare non vegetarian Sikhs.

There is tons of evidence and even eyewitness accounts(example dabistan I mazahib) that non- halal meat is allowed in sikhi.

[WaljinderSingh]

1 hour ago, shastarSingh said:

This is the fear tactic used to scare non vegetarian Sikhs.

There is tons of evidence and even eyewitness accounts(example dabistan I mazahib) that non- halal meat is allowed in sikhi.

A Sikh should believe in Karma, if you don't , how can you claim to be a guru ka Sikh. 

 

My question is : why do you need to eat meat? Are you born a carnivorous ? If not , there are tons of other options. 

[shastarSingh]

10 minutes ago, WaljinderSingh said:

My question is : why do you need to eat meat? Are you born a carnivorous ? If not , there are tons of other options. 

dear veer

There are millions of people on this planet who live on non veg food due to climatic or geographical conditions. They don't have much options.

[shastarSingh]

globalization has killed the planet.So God wants a localized world and economy.

In a localized world , people living in cold climate or islands will find it very difficult to give their bodies proper nutrition without meat.

.

[jkvlondon]

better link for english translation if in Uk:

https://www.amazon.co.uk/Amarnama-Perspective-Phase-Gobind-Singhs/dp/8190402188

[ipledgeblue]

On 3/13/2020 at 1:32 PM, shastarSingh said:

dhadi nath mal was a sikh of Guru Sahib and he wrote a granth in Farsi in 1708 called amarnama .He says that Guru Sahib told not to trust Brahman and not to have Muslim halal meat in line no. 132.

 

also In Asa Di Vaar, Guru Nanak talks about Brahmins eating abakhya ka kuttha (halal) from the Malesh, whilst they did pakhand about impurity.