Have I missed something who is this sikh dr who cut his beard

[BhForce]

1 minute ago, ChardikalaUK said:

Not cutting his hair was silly. What do you think Guru Nanak would say about such a thing. He taught us to be logical.

Really, so what indeed is "logic"?

 

[ChardikalaUK]

1 minute ago, BhForce said:

Really, so what indeed is "logic"?

 

Tell me this, if you had a child who needed a life saving operation on their brain would you not do it because it involves cutting their hair?

[BhForce]

Just now, ChardikalaUK said:

Tell me this, if you had a child who needed a life saving operation on their brain would you not do it because it involves cutting their hair?

No, bro, you claimed Guru Nanak ji taught us to be logical.

So I just asked you what you mean by logical.

Just answer the question and we can go on from there.

Obviously you had something in mind when you made the statement, so just tell us what you had in mind.

[ChardikalaUK]

Just now, BhForce said:

No, bro, you claimed Guru Nanak ji taught us to be logical.

So I just asked you what you mean by logical.

Just answer the question and we can go on from there.

Obviously you had something in mind when you made the statement, so just tell us what you had in mind.

No you answer my question. Then we will move on.

[BhForce]

Just now, ChardikalaUK said:

No you answer my question. Then we will move on.

What? You made the statement yourself.

I just asked you what it meant.
Instead of answering, you go off into something else.

I guess that means your statement (that "Guru Nanak ji taught us to be logical") means nothing at all.

All right, then, that's out of the way. Because you refuse to defend the statement.

So Guru Nanak ji did not teach us to be logical.

[ChardikalaUK]

34 minutes ago, BhForce said:

What? You made the statement yourself.

I just asked you what it meant.
Instead of answering, you go off into something else.

I guess that means your statement (that "Guru Nanak ji taught us to be logical") means nothing at all.

All right, then, that's out of the way. Because you refuse to defend the statement.

So Guru Nanak ji did not teach us to be logical.

Answer my question first, would you let your child die because you refused to cut their hair for a brain operation?

[Singh1989]

4 hours ago, ChardikalaUK said:

Ok that's very silly.

AH! being hardcore like that isn't for everyone. The more meditation, bania, sangat, simran and seva one does the easier it becomes to understand things better. 

[ChardikalaUK]

59 minutes ago, Singh1989 said:

AH! being hardcore like that isn't for everyone. The more meditation, bania, sangat, simran and seva one does the easier it becomes to understand things better. 

So tell me would you let your son or daughter's life to end if the only way to save them is to operate on their head and hence have to remove some hair?

[Premi5]

11 hours ago, ChardikalaUK said:

So tell me would you let your son or daughter's life to end if the only way to save them is to operate on their head and hence have to remove some hair?

That was not the original story of this thread.

he did not gave to do it. His religion should be more important to him than his work

God would always help pukka Gursikh find solutions.

in the case of child you are asking question about, would br best to seek advice of a religious leader if in that situation 

[jkvlondon]

On 5/12/2020 at 1:09 PM, ChardikalaUK said:

Not cutting his hair was silly. What do you think Guru Nanak would say about such a thing. He taught us to be logical.

I would think that someone who had Brahmgian would know much more than a worldly logician ...get some sikhi insight and crack some books. By your thinking all the shaheeds were illogical and therefore wrong but sikhi sees them upholding their principles instead of living life as slaves and husks of men. Standing up for your beliefs and remaining a person of your word is more important than mere logic and convenience to a gursikh , to follow the Guru Sahib whereever He takes you in life.