Jump to content
Sign in to follow this  
puzzled

Harmandir Sahib painting 1854

Recommended Posts

Painting of Harmandir Sahib by artist William Carpenter 1854,  looks like a watercolour.   It is quite a different looking isn't it compared to Harmandir Sahib today. There is a Singh doing prakash of Guru Granth Sahib Maharaj out in the open, a random bull in the parkarma, i guess it was drinking water from the sarovar, some pigeons drinking water from from big bowls. There is also someone with their top of by the sarovar, not sure if its male/female. Where Singh is doing prakash of Guru Maharaj there also are two Singh grinding something, bhang?      very different ...

cybn3y1l8yd41.jpg

Pin on Sikh Cultural Heritage

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

This is the version iv seen at peoples houses in India, they have edited the bull out lol    and also edited out the Singh doing prakash of Maharaj outside! 

Beautiful Painting of Harmandir Sahib (The Golden Temple) | Golden ...

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Flower sellers at Harmandir Sahib   by Edwin Lord Weeks 1890

b6cc0abe83b756a622c7c39720caced6.jpg

 

by the same artist     also a random dog sleeping by sarovar lol 

1200px-Across_the_Pool_to_the_Golden_Temple_of_Amritsar_by_Edwin_Lord_Weeks.jpg

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Scene at Harmandir Sahib, chromolitograph  by Willaim Simpson 1964  titled "seated holy man with figures"     still looks different to today, also another random dog sleeping at the back. 

Seated holy man with figures, Amritsar, Punjab. Chromolithograph ...

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Another painting by William Carpenter outside Akal Takt Sahib   a lot going on. Man selling flowers to lady, men inside Akal Takht chatting/socializing, and Singh doing prakash of Guru Granth Sahib ji out in the open outside Akal Takht Sahib. 

large.akalee1.jpg.bc6ca069b6ff5248659a7db566f51e6a.jpg

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

More by William Simpson

1864

Akal Boonga at the Golden Temple Umritsar, Panjaub" By William ...

 

1867   Chaur Sahib made of peacock feathers      on the floor theres a object that looks like a bell? 

Post image

WILLIAM SIMPSON, Golden Temple Interior, Amritsar. About 22 March ...

 

William Carpenter 1854    is that a pigeon on the floor?  

2006AY9113_jpg_l.jpg

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Harmandir Sahib entrance by Charles W Bartlett 

ESefnj9UUAE7YZ4.jpg

 

Sikhs- An occidental romance – MARIGOLDdiary

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
On 5/20/2020 at 9:52 PM, puzzled said:

This is the version iv seen at peoples houses in India, they have edited the bull out lol    and also edited out the Singh doing prakash of Maharaj outside! 

Beautiful Painting of Harmandir Sahib (The Golden Temple) | Golden ...

I have this one in my house. The bull was most likely edited out due to Hindu links and likewise the man with the Guru Granth Sahib sitting outside, it's too similar to what a Pandit does.

It's the same case with Guru Nanak's seli topi. Some Sikhs cannot fathom the idea that the first 6 Gurus wore a seli topi instead of a dastaar.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
17 hours ago, ChardikalaUK said:

I have this one in my house. The bull was most likely edited out due to Hindu links and likewise the man with the Guru Granth Sahib sitting outside, it's too similar to what a Pandit does.

But doesn't that make us look insecure the fact a painting had to be edited because it doesn't look Sikh enough? Guru HarRai Sahib ji kept loads of animals and fed them. Many Gurdware in India have stray dogs outside or within the complex.

17 hours ago, ChardikalaUK said:

It's the same case with Guru Nanak's seli topi. Some Sikhs cannot fathom the idea that the first 6 Gurus wore a seli topi instead of a dastaar.

Not sure about the earlier Guru Sahibs but didn't Guru Arjan Dev ji tell Sikhs to wear 2 Dastars because the Mughals had banned anyone from wearing Dastar in their own country, and then Guru Hargobind Sahib ji continued the tradition and kept horses and weapons too. I'm pretty sure in Gurbilas 6 says that Guru Hargobind Sahib ji ji told Sikhs to wear dastar and keep weapons and horses. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
1 hour ago, puzzled said:

But doesn't that make us look insecure the fact a painting had to be edited because it doesn't look Sikh enough? Guru HarRai Sahib ji kept loads of animals and fed them. Many Gurdware in India have stray dogs outside or within the complex.

Not sure about the earlier Guru Sahibs but didn't Guru Arjan Dev ji tell Sikhs to wear 2 Dastars because the Mughals had banned anyone from wearing Dastar in their own country, and then Guru Hargobind Sahib ji continued the tradition and kept horses and weapons too. I'm pretty sure in Gurbilas 6 says that Guru Hargobind Sahib ji ji told Sikhs to wear dastar and keep weapons and horses. 

https://www.sikhiwiki.org/index.php/Seli_Topi

According to that the first six Gurus wore Seli Topis.

Yes it's not good that we had to edit the painting. I don't know who makes these decisions. Hindus are always saying that we are a Hindu sect and that is the most likely reason we have tried to distance ourselves from things associated with them.

A cow is very linked to Hinduism, it's different to a small wild dog.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
Sign in to follow this  



  • Topics

  • Posts

    • It's true. And something most Sikh parents ignore because most Sikh parents themselves think it's cool and modernable to dress our children like that. I remember my niece on her first birthday was dressed up like a barbie by her parents. Thats where it starts.  If I ever had a daughter I wouldn't let her be semi nude like this. And be available for men.  Sikh parents of girls act like pimp nowadays 
    • Honestly, thank you from the bottom of my heart. Your reply has really brought peace to my mind. Yes you're right, professional support is out there but I think this journey is difficult but will build me as an individual. I've always tried to live to make others around me happy which kind of left me unknown of my own identity. I really want to build myself, understand my needs and wants.... And mostly importantly recognise my weaknesses and faults so I can be a better person. Confidence and having high regards of your own well being attractive I guess. It sets a bar and people know not to cross it which keeps relationships healthy and fair. With waheguru jis mehar I really want to improve myself so that when my marriage is fixed I can move forward. You're right, I know I want quick results but on the other hand 8 months of no communication feels like a life time.... However like you said it is better to wait and have problems resolved.  I definitely need to research some techniques and see which suit me best.... It's my sister's wedding in a few weeks which is great happiness for us as a family but a constant reminder for me. It's really hard but the more I'm trying to be happy for her and plan things for her the more peace I feel.  Once again thank u sooo much, your response has really settled my mind.
    • I'm not trying to be rude but most of you guys on here talking about "women these days" sound like incels. I don't know why some people are so obsessed with what women are doing, go out there be the alpha male and any girl will like you. It's very simple Singhs need to man up. Most Singhs want a pretty and feminine girl so similarly girls like confident manly men, alot of Singhs are not up to scratch its simple as that.    There is alot of incel like <banned word filter activated> shaming going on - you can not hope to know what someone is like from a Facebook post or photo, hell even the people you see up close like those in school, you don't know the full story.   What makes me laugh is how quickly people think they can sum up the complexities of someone else's life. On top of that you guys aren't even happy when a girl moves on and criticisize when they do finally settle down as covering up or whatever - it's called growing up and developing as a person, quite a normal thing.   Maybe if we the kaum wasn't full up of people who have nothing better to do than discuss other people's supposed love lives on the internet and actually understood normal human behaviour of making mistakes, being immature and developing, we actually wouldn't have people looking elsewhere.   Finally, there never was this "ideal respectable woman", not in any era. Hanky panky has been going on since the beginning of time, read charitrpakhiyan.
    • I am really glad you are doing better. That you know your worth and keep striving everyday. What you said about no one having the time to listen to ur priblems and emotional issues, really resonated. That is why in these times therapists and counselors are such high paying jobs. People need to pay someone to listen to them and just offer sympathy. Used to be what families and neighbors did for free. About your hukamnamas. You should take heart that they are positive. That there is hope and Rabb is on ur side. But the hukamnama does not mean that it will solve things instantly. It takes time. Like they say, Rabb de Ghar Der Hai Per Haner Nahi. Meaning it takes time but God doesnt abandon ppl who believe in him. Also your adaas is pretty big. You not only want your husmand back but stronger and more into naam. That will take time. He has to fight his anxiety, relatives, doubt etc to become a better person. So now that you know, that the outcome will be positive, but you dont know how long its gonna take or when its gonna happen. What will you do? You can either have faith and say God has said to me again and again that my marriage will be saved so i will believe him and not torture myself with imaginings. Just have faith and try to enjoy life. Or you can keep being in doubt and keep asking for more hukamnameh, which you wont believe and will keep taking new ones. And be in unsettled stressful mindset.  All will be well. God has stated. So why not enjoy life. Leave the hows and why to him  Our mind is tricky. It wont be quiet and restful. So try simran and meditation. And try CBT, which is cognitive behavior therapy that if you control your thoughts you can control your behavior. For example, if you stop having sad thoughts you will stop crying and being depressed. So what you do is whenever a negative though comes. You push it out of you mind and refuse to think it. And take ur mind to other directions . You can also wear a rubber band and snap it on your wrist so that it hurts when negative thoughts come. To train your mind not to go there. 
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

Terms of Use