Is this immoral or righteous?

[Guest Dhan Sikhi]

On 9/9/2020 at 10:20 AM, Guest Guest 102 said:

The marriage was ordained by God for Prophet Muhammad (pbuh) and blessed by the father of Aisha (ra) to unite the Quresh

How does that justify the rape of a child?

[Singh1989]

WARNING! I AM NOT DEFENDING ISLAM. WARNING!

Muhammed's time was different and our time is different. 

BIG QUESTION! We know their age of marriage but do we know if he had sex with her at 9 or did he wait until she was 18ish???? If u thought... "Yes he had sex with her at 9!" Lol only cause YOU would do that if u were married to a child. Thas another thing that it's against the law today (but am saying IF - U were). 

So, three things have occurred here. 1. That time was a different time. 2. We don't know at wha age Aisha lost her virginity. 3. These scientific terms (DSM n Psychiatry) words are in the TODAY's world. 

[GurjantGnostic]

28 minutes ago, Singh1989 said:

WARNING! I AM NOT DEFENDING ISLAM. WARNING!

Muhammed's time was different and our time is different. 

BIG QUESTION! We know their age of marriage but do we know if he had sex with her at 9 or did he wait until she was 18ish???? If u thought... "Yes he had sex with her at 9!" Lol only cause YOU would do that if u were married to a child. Thas another thing that it's against the law today (but am saying IF - U were). 

So, three things have occurred here. 1. That time was a different time. 2. We don't know at wha age Aisha lost her virginity. 3. These scientific terms (DSM n Psychiatry) words are in the TODAY's world. 

Bro...marriage and the sex act were synonymous at that time...

[GurjantGnostic]

He had also murdered this childs family night before?  What exactly is there to defend and why would you @Singh1989?

[puzzled]

4 hours ago, Singh1989 said:

WARNING! I AM NOT DEFENDING ISLAM. WARNING!

Muhammed's time was different and our time is different. 

BIG QUESTION! We know their age of marriage but do we know if he had sex with her at 9 or did he wait until she was 18ish???? If u thought... "Yes he had sex with her at 9!" Lol only cause YOU would do that if u were married to a child. Thas another thing that it's against the law today (but am saying IF - U were). 

So, three things have occurred here. 1. That time was a different time. 2. We don't know at wha age Aisha lost her virginity. 3. These scientific terms (DSM n Psychiatry) words are in the TODAY's world. 

The sahih hadiths say they consummated the marriage when she was 9 years old and the prophet was in his 50s 

[Kaurr]

4 hours ago, puzzled said:

The sahih hadiths say they consummated the marriage when she was 9 years old and the prophet was in his 50s 

Why a nine year old?

I find it extremely disturbing cause she probably hasn't even gone through puberty and then.........

[Guest She was only 6!]

10 hours ago, Singh1989 said:

WARNING! I AM NOT DEFENDING ISLAM. WARNING!

Muhammed's time was different and our time is different. 

BIG QUESTION! We know their age of marriage but do we know if he had sex with her at 9

Well 1 billion Muslims are proud of Prophet Muhammad for having sex with Aisha when she was aged 9 (as the marriage took place 3 years earlier when she was 6)

 

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gFscwzMUglI

 

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ak0_UvzjgnU

 

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JuzZ16M3p4w&feature=emb_logo

 

[Guest Hang all Pedophiles]

7 hours ago, puzzled said:

The sahih hadiths say they consummated the marriage when she was 9 years old and the prophet was in his 50s 

But it was a divine marriage ordained by God 

3 hours ago, Kaurr said:

Why a nine year old?

I find it extremely disturbing cause she probably hasn't even gone through puberty and then.........

 

 

 

[puzzled]

15 hours ago, Kaurr said:

Why a nine year old?

I find it extremely disturbing cause she probably hasn't even gone through puberty and then.........

Everything the prophet did was according to Allahs instructions. The prophets says and doings are recorded in the hadiths, secondary Islamic texts. Everything he did and said was what Allah told him to do and say, so everything in the hadiths is considered sunnah or proper, including how Allah told the prophet to marry Aisha. 

As the prophet married a 6 year old, its sunnah and also proper for a Muslim man to also marry a 6 year old.

Even Ali Dawah the preacher guy, in a video he says if his daughter is ready to marry at 9 then he will get her married at 9!   For them its divine/ God sent! 

 

[Kaurr]

7 hours ago, puzzled said:

Everything the prophet did was according to Allahs instructions. The prophets says and doings are recorded in the hadiths, secondary Islamic texts. Everything he did and said was what Allah told him to do and say, so everything in the hadiths is considered sunnah or proper, including how Allah told the prophet to marry Aisha. 

As the prophet married a 6 year old, its sunnah and also proper for a Muslim man to also marry a 6 year old.

Even Ali Dawah the preacher guy, in a video he says if his daughter is ready to marry at 9 then he will get her married at 9!   For them its divine/ God sent! 

 

so allah told the prophet to marry kids?