Jump to content

Indian Labor Migrants in Lebanon: A Comparative Study of Migrants from Punjab and Tamil Nadu. Seema Gaur, Prem Saxena


Recommended Posts

1 minute ago, dallysingh101 said:

Actually, try thinking about it. The brits did this to a certain group amongst us to devastating effect for a protracted period. They are on record saying they thought these people were docile and slow to learn. Maybe becoming engrossed/lost in perpetual self-adulation (via folksongs, modern songs, movies, and even back handed 'compliments' in written works), makes certain people blind to reality, and thus easy to manipulate? It's like keeping them permanently suspended in a false reality whilst you make moves to finally finish them off. So it would be in every enemy of the panths interest to encourage and facilitate the 'culture' (in a very loose sense of the word) that helps conjure this scenario/mindset. 

This would explain A LOT of what we are seeing.

And just to juxtaposition the current projection of a certain people with an older one, from within Sikh sources - have a look at a certain number of chariters that explicitly cover this community, and just see for yourself just how starkly different the Sikh representations are to the modern stuff. One is rooted in ground level reality and constructive criticism, the other is plain 'giving the pump' as Panjabis say.      

They still boast about how the Brits thought of them as a martial race(to fool them into fighting their wars) and to this day they continue to die in wars for others instead of doing something for their own people. India does the same when they want Sikhs to die on the border for them but unfortunately this group wants to so badly prove their worth to others that they will die for others instead of being loyal to their community.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Just now, proudkaur21 said:

They still boast about how the Brits thought of them as a martial race(to fool them into fighting their wars) and to this day they continue to die in wars for others instead of doing something for their own people. India does the same when they want Sikhs to die on the border for them but unfortunately this group wants to so badly prove their worth to others that they will die for others instead of being loyal to their community.

The same group then boasts about being part of a diminishing 1.6% community and making way more contributions than their population. Literally destroying themselves to please others. Ravi singh also belongs to such groups. No Muslim will care if Hindus hate them or not because they know they have power. Powerless Sikhs are always begging left and right for the approval of others.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

23 minutes ago, proudkaur21 said:

Have you observed this kind of materialism among pakistani punjabis? Since growing up I have noticed it among sikhs around me even the well off ones , this never ending greed for more and more and judging others based on how much expensive things they have. I observed it among my relatives all the times. This extreme jealousy at the thought of another family member buying something expensive. I dont understand this. I noticed this when my mom used to gather around with the family ladies and they would constantly stare at each other's clothes and purses and what not. Even growing up all I saw in the music videos was talks about cars, alcohol and expensive things. Just too much greed in the punjabi community. I see people going into debt to buy expensive cars just to show off. Such childish behaviour.

Their micro-managing religion is a stop-valve that curbs much of the excess that we succumb to. BUT there's aspects to their belief system which leads them down other rabbit holes that thankfully we mostly seem to have avoided (i.e. widespread sexual immorality sanctioned by a supposed divine figure).

I'm not saying Pakistanis don't get enticed by shiny baubles like ostentatious houses, cars, gadgets, etc., but it's obviously not at the level that we're motivated to obtain these things.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

56 minutes ago, proudkaur21 said:

They still boast about how the Brits thought of them as a martial race(to fool them into fighting their wars) and to this day they continue to die in wars for others instead of doing something for their own people.

 India does the same when they want Sikhs to die on the border for them but unfortunately this group wants to so badly prove their worth to others that they will die for others instead of being loyal to their community

They completely ignore the complete martial race theory, where they are also deemed to be docile and naturally subordinate to authority, and incapable of higher level organisation. 

But maybe this gross characterisation has some basis in reality, hence the constant need to be validated by outsiders?

Plus it should be patently obvious to even the dimmest amongst us now: they clearly don't see other Panjabi people outside of their biraderi as 'their own people'. Once we all get this, things will fall in place. That's why most aren't 'loyal to their community' as you mention above, because what you consider 'the community' is not what they consider as their own community.     

Jagjit Singh went into detail about these characteristics in his book. I have to revisit that soon.  

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, proudkaur21 said:

The same group then boasts about being part of a diminishing 1.6% community and making way more contributions than their population. Literally destroying themselves to please others. Ravi singh also belongs to such groups. No Muslim will care if Hindus hate them or not because they know they have power. Powerless Sikhs are always begging left and right for the approval of others.

How much of the 1.6 percent is destroying themselves to please others?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, MisterrSingh said:

Their micro-managing religion is a stop-valve that curbs much of the excess that we succumb to. BUT there's aspects to their belief system which leads them down other rabbit holes that thankfully we mostly seem to have avoided (i.e. widespread sexual immorality sanctioned by a supposed divine figure).

I'm not saying Pakistanis don't get enticed by shiny baubles like ostentatious houses, cars, gadgets, etc., but it's obviously not at the level that we're motivated to obtain these things.

The Pakistanis do enjoy themselves and are not averse to materialism.

There have been any conversations amongst our Sikh women how Pakistani women wearing lots of gold. 

Pakistanis also now drive better cars. You do tend see brand new Land Rovers parked ouside some chicken shop.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

49 minutes ago, Ranjeet01 said:

The Pakistanis do enjoy themselves and are not averse to materialism.

There have been any conversations amongst our Sikh women how Pakistani women wearing lots of gold. 

Pakistanis also now drive better cars. You do tend see brand new Land Rovers parked ouside some chicken shop.

Do we flaunt it more with the "balle, balle" mentality while they're content to just own those things?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

13 minutes ago, MisterrSingh said:

Do we flaunt it more with the "balle, balle" mentality while they're content to just own those things?

Depends which branch of us who does this more.

People who tend to be more recently arrived are more materialistic or people who have never seen or had consumer goods in their lives are far more materialistic. 

Those amongst our people who have lived with materialism for decades tend to be less balleh balleh. 

Like the bhangra music videos. In the old days of the 80's and 90's, twhen it was the UK that dominated the scene you would not hear about the flaunting of this wealth.

Now bhangra music scene is dominated by Punjab and recent Punjabi migrants to Keneda  and it is the particular demographic that flaunts the wealth and does the balleh balleh.

It is this particular section that dominates the narrative particularly in the diaspora. 

But I find that we should be careful not to necessarily extrapolate this section of our community on the rest of us.

There is a lot of jealousy within the Pakistani community, it's just that we don't hear about it.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, Ranjeet01 said:

Depends which branch of us who does this more.

People who tend to be more recently arrived are more materialistic or people who have never seen or had consumer goods in their lives are far more materialistic. 

Those amongst our people who have lived with materialism for decades tend to be less balleh balleh. 

Like the bhangra music videos. In the old days of the 80's and 90's, twhen it was the UK that dominated the scene you would not hear about the flaunting of this wealth.

Now bhangra music scene is dominated by Punjab and recent Punjabi migrants to Keneda  and it is the particular demographic that flaunts the wealth and does the balleh balleh.

It is this particular section that dominates the narrative particularly in the diaspora. 

But I find that we should be careful not to necessarily extrapolate this section of our community on the rest of us.

There is a lot of jealousy within the Pakistani community, it's just that we don't hear about it.

I think the trend of British-born Sikh guys marrying Punjabi brides has died down now. It needed to happen. Those brides of the 90s (later, mothers) passed on that greedy mentality (having come from literal huts and villages) to their offspring, which is probably why much of that generation (now in their late teens / early 20s) are still expounding caste-related nonsense, and seem to be completely unhinged when it comes to accumulating objects and flashing their wealth. The fathers (Gen X-ers) are clueless British fudhoos as one would expect, so most of this behaviour is inherited from the overly bhukki mother.

The post-2005 Indian arrivals who came via Italy, Portugal, Spain, Bulgaria, etc., are something else, lol. They have a commendable work ethic (to a degree), but they have zero desire to pay their dues. Very impatient. They see what our elders worked 30,40,50 years to build, and these clowns want it all in 3 years. They have no idea how our elders put in the graft and sacrificed so much. In some ways their greed is greater than anything we've ever seen over here. Their entitlement is off the scale. But, strangely, they're also a little more aware of the Indian state's shenanigans, and therefore slightly more politically aware. But it's all very superficial and ultimately it's still that old Punjabi thing of waiting for Superman to descend from the clouds and provide a solution to the bigger problems. Their religiosity is also a load of posturing. It's very insincere.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
 Share


  • advertisement_alt
  • advertisement_alt
  • advertisement_alt


  • Topics

  • Posts

    • Russistan Zindabad! 😅
    • https://www.bbc.com/news/world-europe-63072113 Russia's Vladimir Putin will hold a signing ceremony on Friday to annex four more areas of Ukraine after self-styled referendums condemned by Ukraine and the West as a sham. Russian-backed officials had earlier claimed the five-day exercise secured almost total popular support. So-called votes were held in Luhansk and Donetsk in the east, and in Zaporizhzhia and Kherson in the south. The Russian president will make a major speech at the Kremlin. A stage has already been set up in Moscow's Red Square, with billboards proclaiming the four regions as part of Russia and a concert planned for the evening.  The event echoes Russia's annexation of Crimea in 2014, which also followed a discredited referendum and was heralded by a Kremlin signing followed by a presidential victory speech in parliament. That initial annexation has never been recognised by the vast majority of the international community, and nor will this.  Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky said the "pseudo-referendums" were worthless and did not change reality. "The territorial integrity of Ukraine will be restored. And our reaction to recognition of the results by Russia will be very harsh."  No independent monitoring of the Russian process took place and election officials were pictured going from door to door escorted by armed soldiers. "Tomorrow at 15:00 (12:00 GMT) in the St George Hall of the Grand Kremlin Palace a signing ceremony will be held on incorporating the new territories into Russia," said spokesman Dmitry Peskov. Separate agreements will be signed with the two Russian-backed separatist leaders from the east and the two Russian-appointed officials from the south. As with Crimea, Russia's two houses of parliament will formally ratify the annexation treaties next week. The Russian president is expected to address to the upper house of parliament on 4 October, three days before his 70th birthday.  The US has said it will impose sanctions on Russia because of the staged referendums, while EU member states are considering an eighth round of measures, including sanctions on anyone involved in the votes.
    • ਨਾਮਧਾਰੀ ਠਾਕੁਰ ਦਲੀਪ ਸਿੰਘ  ਨਿਹੰਗ ਸਿੰਘਾਂ ਦੇ ਜੱਥੇਦਾਰ ਸਰਦਾਰ ਮੇਜਰ ਸਿੰਘ ਜੀ ਨਾਲ ਨੇ ਸਹਿਮਤ । VID-20220929-WA0000.mp4
    • You really are full of nonsense. The reason the Gujaratis came to Britain after being expelled from Africa was because they had British citizenship, no other reason. Many of them had to live in detention camps when they arrived! They did not uplift the image of Indians by selling saris and owning corner shops, something that Punjabis were doing where they were a majority anyway. 
    • Because Naamdharis are absolute masters at kirtan. Simple. On the topic of Akal Takht, it doesn't really hold the same authority as it did in the past. Just look at the people running it and you'll get what I mean. Most the panth, outside of stuff like Tankhaya, don't care about anything they have to say. 
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

Terms of Use