If your a Hindu be a good Hindu ,If your a Muslim be a good muslim

[Big_Tera]

I think we have all come across this quote from Guru Nanak Ji. " If your a Hindu be a good Hindu. if your a Muslim be a good Muslim".

But what is the true meaning of this quote? I've heard some say that this means Guru Nanak is saying all religions are good and lead to the same one God for all. Hence there is no need to convert to any religion . Just stay in your own one.

But I have also heard alternative meanings for the quote.

Some say it means Guru Ji is only saying be the best Hindu and Muslim you can be. Ie. follow your own religion correctly and not the first meaning I gave. 

So which is it? 

[californiasardar1]

It's "you're", not "your."

[dallysingh101]

6 hours ago, Big_Tera said:

I think we have all come across this quote from Guru Nanak Ji. " If your a Hindu be a good Hindu. if your a Muslim be a good Muslim".

From my recollection that wasn't a quote from Baba Nanak ji but Sant Jarnail Singh ji? 

[ChardikalaUK]

Wouldn't being a good Muslim endorse keeping prisoners of war as slaves and in the case of women sex slaves? 

Likewise being a good Hindu would encourage following the caste system. 

These things are explicitly mentioned in the Quran and Gita. 

[dallysingh101]

1 hour ago, ChardikalaUK said:

Wouldn't being a good Muslim endorse keeping prisoners of war as slaves and in the case of women sex slaves? 

Likewise being a good Hindu would encourage following the caste system. 

These things are explicitly mentioned in the Quran and Gita. 

You are right.

Maybe the implication is that they should be good Muslims and Hindus in light of Sikh values so no pedophilia, raping vulnerable women, untouchability, cow urine drinking etc. ??  

[Jai Tegang!]

7 minutes ago, dallysingh101 said:

You are right.

Maybe the implication is that they should be good Muslims and Hindus in light of Sikh values so no pedophilia, raping vulnerable women, untouchability, cow urine drinking etc. ??  

I think you're correct here. There is a redefinition of each religious group by Guru sahibaan in Gurbani. The new vision Maharaj offers, naturally and gently funnels them into a more Sikhi oriented way of life. The 4-doors-one-walkway metaphor.

[BhForce]

On 1/30/2023 at 2:59 AM, Big_Tera said:

I think we have all come across this quote from Guru Nanak Ji. " If your a Hindu be a good Hindu. if your a Muslim be a good Muslim".

There is no such quote. Not in Gurbani.

If you're talking about the Janam Sakhis, there it says that Guru ji said "Na ko Hindu na Mussalmaan", meaning No one is a Hindu No one is a Muslim.

On 1/30/2023 at 2:59 AM, Big_Tera said:

Hence there is no need to convert to any religion . Just stay in your own one.

There is only one dharam. Dhru was a follower of this Dharam, so was Kabeer ji and Namdev ji and Bhai Gurdas ji and all the Sikhs of Guru ji.

ਏਕੋ ਧਰਮੁ ਦ੍ਰਿੜੈ ਸਚੁ ਕੋਈ ॥

ਗੁਰਮਤਿ ਪੂਰਾ ਜੁਗਿ ਜੁਗਿ ਸੋਈ ॥ p1188

There is One Dharma that solidifies the truth out of all

Only Gurmat is perfect throughout the jugs (ages).

 

Harnakash was not a follower of this Dharam, neither was Chandu, among others.