10th regiment

tullys book and various others have claimed this happened

im not sure if it did, im just saying what has been claimed

tully is not biased against sikhs but may have been fed lies

its seems to me, and it is quite sad, that without an armed struggle, khalistan will not become a reality, although education is required , a 2 fold policy must be implemented

arms and education

without the back up of arms, politics in india is nothing, the brahmins will always outsmart sikhs

akthough sept 11 has set armed strugglre back, i think it is a phase, in 5 to 10 years time violence as a method of political discourse will become acceptable again

any views

not only did tara singh go back on his fast so did fateh singh as well

so both akali leaders were crap back then

only darshan singh pheruman ex congress by the way! died on his fast

for punjabi suba demands

tohras death is actually bad for khalistanis

he was a khalistani at heart, before his death he gave a funny reply to mark tully on the bbc programme that his thoughts on khalistan were best kept secret

he was a power hnungry man, always wanted to be cheif minister

but with his death, badal aka feeme addict and rss agent becomes stronger

badal will defeat the panthic morcha of ranjit singh and baba bedi ji and badal will control the akali dal and the sgpc

tohra death just makes badal stronger which is bad for all gursikhs

hmm true, when jasbir singh rode givernment agent became jathedar of akal takht he imposed the taksal code of conduct

everyone is out for themselves and their jatha

its a disgrace

strangely his name was actually jarnial singh

but he went to jail in 1937 arrested by british and changed his name to zail singh

he was a sad man, in that he had good intentions but was always indebted to indira rani for making his career

by the end he had written a book, one which is out of print but can get off amazon i think cant rermember the title in which he spoke out against gandhu family

it is widely believed he was killed by the goverment and not in a fatal car crash

and aslo was under house arrest during bluestar but he was aware of it but his life and familys life was under threat if he spoke out

anyway what power does a president have?

kalam could not stop thousands of muslims killed in gujrat what could giani do

and yes he was no giani but was good at public speaking and hence given the title

the dal khalsa are not bad movement although initially were tarnished by the fact that giani zail singh paid thei hotel fees when they were set up

www.dalkhalsa.com

and also during the june attack, the gurbanchan singh secerary dude was killed, in cross fire, either the kharkus got him on the orders of sant ji or the army got him as he was their spy

sodhi was killed in april 1984

sodhi ji was killed on the orders of longowal akali dal secetray gurbanchan singh

due to jealousy or government funding, that is unclear

basically he was ambushed outisde the golden temple by some dude whos name i cant remeber and his girlfriend baljit kaur

they were captureed by sant jis men and tortured, where they admitted the gurbanchan singh , secetray of longowal akali dal had paid them to kill sodhi

they were both killed, the woman had her breasts cut off accoridng to some books

and then a notice was put around golden temple saying we aveneged our brothers blood withing 24 hrs

listen to sant jawab mangde from saintsoldiers media section

sant ji himself admits all this

basically sant ji was saying that representatives of the akali dal in uk had said that they would look after thekedar

(who fled to uk and now lives in southall and runs a gurdwarsa there i think, thekedar was member of dal khalsa from gurdaspur dist. he along with rajinder singh metha, now leader of a faction of aissf or khalsa panchayat (not sure) had 50000 rupees on their head for throwing a cows head in a mandir)

but now they had said that sant ji was congress agent because they had fallen out with thekedar in uk, and longowal had <Edited> off sant ji and now longowal akal dal was saying sant ji was congress agent

he was showing how fickle the longowal akali dal was all over the world

that was very well argued one sikhi

but im sure some clever singh will work out the answers to ur questions

but then again no clever singh is allowed to live

just look at harmander singh sandhu and the way he was killed and by whom

having read it, i can say whats the point in writing to them?

they have already posted it out

they are not going to issue an apology

the indian media is biased we all know, they are not going to change so why bother trying to write to them?

to say khalistan will be a country where drink etc is illegal is rather wrong

people do not want to hear this type of thing because its not practical

if khalistan is to be created it must be a free democracy, during the gurus times people drank etc but the guru jis did not punish those who did, they simply argued their point

in order to get 'swing voters' towards the idea of a soverign sikh state then, it is foolish to say this will be banned etc etc

with this attitude, anti khalistanis and anti sikhs will say look another taliban has been made

a sikh country is a must but we should not try to make into a utopia because this is earth and no such thing exists here

we must be broad minded in order to make khalistan as we need majority of people to support it inculding patit sikhs and non sikhs

once created then we can try to spread sikhi and khalsa values

not wanting to upset anyone but listening to baba thakur singh and obeying his word is rather fool hardy

most members of the taksal accept sant ji is shaheed but wont openly admit it

by not accepting he is shaheed, no new clear leader of the sikhs can come to the forefront, if one does he will forever live in the shadow of sant ji

even his son has accepted he is shaheed as has his wife

sant ji's 'part' the dal khalsa has accepted it as well

i find it rather insulting that a saint soldier would leave the battlefield, and i doubt 5 singhs gave him a hukam to do so

there is no way forward without accepting his shaheedi, baba thakur singh it seems means well, but has indirectly caused the panth to divide

and also baba thakur singhs judgement must be questioned, he was the one who supported jasbir singh rode, and we all know rode was a government agent, as soon as he came out of jail he talked about puran azadi in india, nothing about khalistan

forgive me for any offence