phalwan

brother i will say some what is true u cant just read bani and say its contradiction u have to read it, understand it and walk yourself through it i was having same problems when i was young i didnt get any religions ,but you will learn if u make yourself a deveotee for example it was muslims who was forcing sikhs and hindus to be in their religion even thoug they were giving money ,what do say about that ?? sikhs always have been peacefull people but when this cruelity was too much on them they started making them selves as warrior just in case if ever needed in future because they knew intentions of muslims were never right ,but t\gurus knew which ppl were gods servant ,that is why foundation of golden temple is laid by a muslim fakir they started preparing after martydom of out fifth guru who was martyted very poorly first religion in this world is of a humanity and everybody believes that and guru granth sahib teaches us that too,guru says kudrat ke sab bande ,we have no discrimination between any of religions but why do every body have problems with sikhs if u say sikhs soldiers are cartoons thats not true heres example u might have heard name of baba deep singh ji ,he was a big devottee that he always used to sing guru's banis .when he heard of muslims attacked on golden temple he gathered his men and went to fight it back ,during fight his head was cut off but still his mind wasnt off from bani ,he fought until he freed golden temple and laid his head in golden temple ....main thing he was at age of 75 no one in this kalyug can do fight at this age and wearing 40 mans of metal during war .all was because fo bani and amrit if u say islam is truth give me answer to this question why did mekka (holy place for you)moved where guru nanaks feet were moved by molvi ,guru nanak ji believed in only one god let me try giving answers to ur quetions 1.god is vast and his presence is everywhere thats why guru nanak describes god as sargun and nirgun 2. reincarnation is process is process of mortals but our soul is immortal which belongs to the one .bhagat kabir ji doesnt questions reincarnation they explains it,they tell us that this body cant be obtained easily ,you have to go through lives of different animals and insects (84 laks joons (births)).a person who uses this life as gods given and die by his name that person wont have to go through these birth cycles 3. its true there is no hell and there is no heaven like place ,it all exists in this playground of god (world),hell and heaven is made by man for himself.its imagination .a man who recites name of god and take him for everything and live simple life ,has heaven and person on other hand doesnt have any gods blessing but have all money ,he wont be able to live a happy life either as he is not remembering one who gave him all the things thats hell for him,heaven lies for person who remembers the one and unite with him and leave all materials behind ,buddhist even teach that too,leaving materialism they become true warriors god has given same life to everybody ,another chance as he is sooo kind to get knowledge and find right path for him but human dont listen ,he also gives chances when person doesn mistakes in his life too as to er is human thats how we are made if u are talkin about money ,its just like a flowere which is here for a day ,if god has granted u money during birth and u loose gods name all money will be gone and even if u take birth in a poor family ,u have gods blessing ,he will provide you with what you need without asking -its a typical explanation given in all religions 4 well thats true hindus are sightless as says just for example they cant see what god is made of .they think god only lies in idols of devis and devtas ,muslims have one eye only as you ppl know what answer is still you cant see it ,we all r children of god and god lies between us but you people dont think that way ,you think that people who recites name of allah are only gods people and what about others -all have same god in their hearts ,hating and hurting others(animals and humans all) is not allahs way either ਅਲਹੁ ਅਲਖੁ ਨ ਜਾਈ ਲਖਿਆ ਗੁਰਿ ਗੁੜੁ ਦੀਨਾ ਮੀਠਾ ॥The Lord Allah is Unseen; He cannot be seen. The Guru has blessed me with this sweet molasses guru arjun dev ji validated vedas as it contains truth too and guru gobind singh ji said both scriptures are same because even if u see both languages originated from sanskrit then just they changed is written fonts ,in speaking both languages loook familiar 5. there is just one way to god by following one track that is live life given by him but its only enlitled by a true follower (guru) which can be of any kind ,guru granth sahib doesnt teaches u other ways it just tells you many names of god as his followers came in different faces at different times and different places thats why he got different names based on different languages .we all are children of god its just the case of realising him,people who dont adorn him dont love him says there is no god have to suffer ,god still says that we are his children as we are part of him but people who dont believe in him can say that he is not our father ,its the path you choose ,its set for you by him but it depends on you to follow 6. these wordings are said by guru and for his guru ,guru ji says that he is blind ignorrant ..it means one guru needs other guru and make me slave of other slaves of urs as if one person losses path there is other slave of god who can show me path .now a days every person is blind ignorant and folow right path by having gurus blessings 7. both hell and heaven lies on earth .if u still have question describe heaven and relate to beautiful place to u like and find resemblence 8.guru ji tells us that this life and world is like a dream ,dream is not there forever ,once ur eyes are open ur dream is gone and hardly u can remember all of same this life is not here for ever and u dont know when its gone and hardly u wont be reemembering in ur next life if u do bad deeds but the almighty knows about it.well its real as u can feel it and ur deeds are counted .u even forget who u are in dreams and u are king of ur dreams ,same as u are king of ur own life and deeds depends on you 9. all powers are given to gurus by god so how can a guru say powers are his all belongs to one and only ,guru nanak ji admitted that because in truth he is performing no miricales all is done by god as his body was only a medium of travelling blessings of god to others 10. guru granth sahib validates vedas as it tells us truth too ,not all things in vedas are explained in guru granth sahib ,only the path of guru and god is taken ,guru granth sahib ji has also banis of diffferent bhagat and fakirs who were deveottes of one god . all vedas and sage vyas are knowledge of history and mistkes and good done by people and devotes ,they are way to tell us not to do mistakes repeatidly and person who adornes god ,god is with him forever ,in sickness and in hell on earth 11.god created all .he is one mysterious lord and king ,if u read line carefully ,he asked brahmans to made this world living ,so that brahmans can teach way of reaching god too..indirectly if he asked brahmans to create world ,its owned by him and powers of brahmans are given by god ,like companies today world ,made by workers but owned by only owner 12. its just way of telling that god lies in everything present in earth ,he is in past present and future ,only thing a person needs is devotion and guru who can teach him right path ,yet idol worship is prohibited as devotion of person should be with him and god is with him for always ,instaead of doing idol worship,just close ur eyes and take his name n all will be well.guru granth sahib doesnt says that all books are false,they are just written by his followers - followers and r paths followed by other ppl ,guru granth sahib ji believes in every religion that why they give example of baba adam acc to christian 13. god is mysterious ,he can never be incarnated neither can be destroyed ,he made this world as a mortal one .why would owner like to go into his world rather he can look into world by sitting there ,all avatars are his servants which knows path to him 14. what guru is that who praises himself ,guru are human and humans are not perfect all have some deficiency ,thats why gurus are asking for blessing of god if they have forgot name ,gurus says that if a person needs to reach god as he is far and path is hard he need a strong ladder ,a ladder that is blessed by him(guru)and tells right path to god 15.all things are created by him and we all are childrens of god ,all world resides around him but he lives in our hearts and he resides inside us so in proper all world is in us ,even our body is made from basic materials on earth .its just matter of realizing him by path given by guru i think you should read all mahals and banis you gave with your questions in detail and with understanding .gurus have gathered all knowledge and binded in holy book because humans are mortals but still there is banis left off ,to guide people who will be coming after them somethings u even dont know and cant be explained ,you know the truth but still u are critisising other i know bani is hard to understand but its soothing if u can understand it oh allah ke bande nakii kar aur mat bhed ko naa bhara!! if u have any questtion u can ask me of any other gursikh sorry for my bad english