no, i haven't said you need a sant. I merely stated that one who is at sant (mind) has these duties. It was so that others who are stuck going to deras, babas dont get fooled.
Unless I misunderstood, yes you have, you have definetely implied here: http://www.sikhsangat.com/index.php?s=&...st&p=321806
and the above "have this duties" remark imples this too.
One minute you are saying one thing and then in other post another thing.
I appreciate your courage to question these "Keys" leading to His "Vidhis" because this Sewa Singh Tarmala has turned out to be nothing but another fraud imported from Punjab.
Sangat ji, back on October 13, 2006, there were 7 motions passed from Akal Takhat. The third motion passed from Akal Takhat, was against this Tarmala "Sadh". The motion roughly translated in English would read as below;
"The naam simran methods (Vidhis) taught by Sewa Singh Tarmala are NOT approved as per Gurmat. Sangat MUST remain vigilant against his methods (Vidhis)" Motion 3, dated 13-10-2006, Akal Takhat, Amritsar
If you don't believe, you can ask any Gursikh family here in Vancouver & Surrey and my Gursikh brothers in Toronto area and they have copies. The same article was published back on December 15, 2007 in the Canadian Punjabi Times. You can also ask for a copy of the same motion from Akal Takhat, Amritsar and they will send you one. Go to the SGPC website for contact details.
One of the interesting finds in last few weeks has been that we found Sewa's son-in-law from Canada logging under different user names and propping up this guy. Ranbir is the main marketing man for Tarmala in North Amrica and himself was thrown out from a Gurughar stage for preaching the same jogmat and breaking down the Waheguru Shabad into piececs and trying to control breaths as did Jogi Bhangar Nath in Guru Nanak Dev ji's times and they do the same at Holy Hindu places.
There was in an incident that when Gursikhs in Brampton, Ontario wnated to get the proof from Gurbani where these "Vidhis" were listed in SGGS, Tarmala could not answer and got irritated and then his chelas jumped in and told the Gursikhs "This is my personal property, get out, get out get out" The whole incident was published Canadian Punjabi Times. This led to the everybody being aware of him and not allowing to hold Diwans in Gurghar so ended up back in Moga where he has a multi-million dollar Dera even though he only worked as a junior police officer in Punjab Police.
You can read the whole article on the following link: http://www.sikhmarg.com/2007/1223-tarmale-da-brahamgian.html
There is actually a video of the Guy from Gurudwara Millwoods, Edmonton, Alberta where he held two Diwans and a total of 40 people showed up for two days. In that video you can clearly see that this Guy is having refreshments in Gurudarbar in the presence of SGGS while holding a Diwan and then draws cartoons with hats and circles like bwmx and dividing in three categories. I have seen the whole video and there is nothing there about Gurmat even for a second.
The other thing that is being promoted by Ranbir is that Tarmala is the only bRhmigAwnI in the whole universe and to prepare Perfect Amrit you need Five such bRhmigAwnI and that is not possible.
He has surpassed all other sants and opened up a bRhmigAwn university where a three to four year education will lead you to become a Certified Degree Holder bRhmigAwnI.
Is this what Sukhmani Sahib ji tells you?
See for yourself: nwnk bRhm igAwnI Awip prmysur ]6]
SO IS THIS TARMALA GUY GOD NOW?
So SANGAT JI, PLEASE BE AWARE OF THE SUCH GIMMICKS WHERE YOIU END UP LOSING EVERYTHING.
The only way to God is to Read, Listen, Analyze Gurbani and then Adapt it into your Day to Day Life then every one of your actions will become Naam Simran.
Find Gurbani Vichaar for the whole shabad where Guru ji says; gurmuiK hsY gurmuiK rovY ] and you will know what I Mean !!
I am not doing any Nindya but just making stand on Gurmat principles.
There is an open invitation for both, Tarmala and his Son-in-Law Ranbir, to prove their "Vidhis" and Gurbani Analysis according to Gurmat in a public place and have it video recorded but they declined and even refuse to come in public forum to defend their views. I guess that speaks for itself !!
Bhul Chuk Maaf, Guru da Sewak